“I never touched her!”
“Liar!” I was shouting now. “You ruined that girl, Powell!”
“Damn you, I never touched her! Nobody did, damn you! She’s still a virgin! She’s still a virgin!”
I took a breath. “The hell she is,” I yelled. “I had her last night, Powell. She came to my room all hot to trot and I bedded her until she couldn’t see straight.”
His eyes were wild.
“Did you hear me, Powell? I had your girl last night. I had Lynn, Powell!”
And that cracked him.
He charged me like a wild man, his whole body coordinated in the spring. I stepped back, swung aside. He tried to turn and come toward me but his momentum kept him from pulling it off. By the time he got back on the right track, my hand had gone up and come down. The barrel of the gun caught him just behind the left ear. He took two more little steps, carried along by the sheer force of his rush. Then he folded up and went out like an ebbing tide.
He wasn’t out long. By the time Jerry Gunther got there, flanked by a pair of uniformed cops, Powell was babbling away a mile a minute, spending half the time confessing to the three murders and the other half telling anyone who would listen that Lynn Farwell was a saint.
They started to put handcuffs on him. Then they changed their minds and bundled him up in a straitjacket.
ELEVEN
“I guess I missed my calling,” Ceil said. “I should have been a detective. I probably would have flopped there, too, but the end might have been different. We all know what girls become when they don’t make it as actresses. What do lousy detectives turn to?”
“Cognac,” I said. “Pass the bottle.”
She passed and I poured. We were in her apartment on Sullivan Street. It was Tuesday night, Ray Powell had long since finished confessing, and Ceil Gorski had just proved to me that she could cook a good meal.
“You figured it out beautifully,” she said. “But do I get an assist on the play?”
“Easily.” I tucked tobacco into my pipe, lit up. “You managed to get my mind working. Powell was a genius at murder. A certifiable psychotic, but also a genius. He set things up beautifully. First of all, the frame couldn’t have been neater. He very carefully set up Donahue with means, motive, and opportunity. Then he shot the girl and left Donahue on the hook.”
I worked on the cognac. “The neat thing was this—if Donahue managed to have an alibi, if by some chance somebody was watching him when the shot was fired, Powell was still in the clear. He himself was one of the few men in the room with no conceivable motive for wanting Karen Price dead.”
Ceil moved a little closer on the couch. I put an arm around her. “Then the way he got rid of Donahue was sheer perfection,” I continued. “He made it look enough like suicide to close the case as far as the police were concerned. And Jerry Gunther isn’t an easy man to bulldoze. He’s thorough. But Powell made it look good.”
“You didn’t swallow it.”
“That’s because I play hunches. Even so, I was up a tree by then. Because the murder had a double edge to it. Even if he muffed it somehow, even if it didn’t go over as suicide, Donahue would be dead and he would be in the clear. Because there was only one way to interpret it—Donahue had been killed by the man who killed Karen Price, obviously, and had been killed so that the original killing would go unsolved. That made me suspect Joe Conn and never let me guess at Powell, not even on speculation. Even with the second killing he hid the fact that Donahue and not Karen was the real target.”
“And that’s where I came in,” she said happily.
“That’s exactly where you came in,” I agreed. “You and your active imagination. You thought how grim it would be if Karen had only been playing a joke with those phone calls. And that was the only explanation in the world for the calls. I had to believe Donahue was getting the calls, and that Karen was making them. A disguised voice might work once, but she’d called him a few times.
“That left two possibilities, really. She could be jealous—which seemed contrary to everything I had learned about her. Or it could be a gag. But if she was jealous, then why in hell would she take the job popping out of the cake? So it had to be a gag, and once it was a gag, I had to guess why someone would put her up to it. And from that point—”
“It was easy.”
“Uh-huh. It was easy.”
She snuggled closer. I liked her perfume. I liked the feel of her body beside me.
“It wasn’t that easy,” she said. “You know what? I think you’re a hell of a good detective. And you know what else?”
“What?”
“I also think you’re a rotten businessman.”
I smiled. “Why?”
“Because you did all that work and didn’t make a dime out of it. You got a retainer from Donahue, but that didn’t even cover all the time you spent before Karen was killed, let alone the time since then. And you probably will never collect.”
“I’m satisfied.”
“Because justice has been done?”
“Partly. Also because I’ll be rewarded.”
She upped her eyebrows. “How? You won’t make another nickel out of the case, will you?”
“No.”
“Then—”
“I’ll make something more important than money.”
“What?”
She was soft and warm beside me. And it was our third evening together. Not even an amateur tramp could mind a pass on a third date.
“What are you going to make?” she asked, innocently.