“But—”
“Faith, please! This is important.”
“All right,” she agreed, although he could tell how worried she was.
It wasn’t until after midnight that Troy’s hunch proved to be correct. He was sitting in the pitch-dark living room when he heard a slight commotion near the garage. Not wasting a moment, he contacted his deputies and had them surround the area.
“Troy?” Faith whispered from the hallway. “Did you hear that?”
Apparently she was a light sleeper or hadn’t been to sleep at all.
“Go back to your room and stay put,” he said, not hiding his annoyance. He enunciated each word as distinctly as he could, keeping his voice low.
She didn’t respond.
“Did you hear me?” he asked more loudly.
“Fine, fine. I’m on my way,” she muttered. “I never knew you were so bossy.”
Maybe he was but Troy refused to take any chances with her safety. He was the one paid to take risks, not Faith.
A louder commotion broke out in the garage, and Deputy Weaver gave a shout. Troy ran for the back door and opened it just in time to see a man dressed completely in black dash across the side yard.
Troy was long past his physical prime, but, junk food aside, he kept in shape. Racing after the man, he tackled him, landing hard on the wet grass. Weaver, who was directly behind him, grabbed the intruder by the scruff of the neck and dragged him to his feet. Troy slapped on the handcuffs he’d kept attached to his belt.
Deputy Johnson shined a flashlight into their prisoner’s face and Troy instantly recognized the man who’d been the source of all this trouble. He felt a sense of satisfaction.
“Take him to the station,” Troy said after Deputy Johnson had read the perpetrator his legal rights.
The two deputies led him away while Troy brushed off his uniform. He was getting way too old to be chasing felons, but he wasn’t about to let this one escape.
He returned to the house, turning on the kitchen light. “It’s safe for you to come out now,” he called.
Faith hurried in, wearing her housecoat. “Troy—oh, my goodness, what happened?” Without waiting for him to answer, she opened a drawer, retrieved a towel and dampened one corner. Standing close, she dabbed at his mouth.
“What?” He was surprised to realize he was bleeding. He hadn’t felt a thing.
“You got him?” she asked.
Troy nodded. “Sure did.”
Faith pulled out a chair and they both sat down. Her hands were trembling, and he reached for them, chafing warmth back into her cold skin.
“Did you recognize him?”
“I did.”
“Who is it?” she asked. “And why does this person hate me so much?”
“His name is Mark Schaffer.”
A puzzled look appeared on her face. “Who? I’ve never heard of him before. What could I possibly have done to make him target me?”
“This isn’t about you, Faith. I should’ve seen that much sooner. This has absolutely nothing to do with you.”
Faith stared at him in confusion. “I don’t understand.”
“I haven’t got all the answers myself, but I’ll tell you what I think happened and why.”
“Please.” Her eyes implored him to make sense of it all.
“Schaffer was a friend of Dale and Pam Smith, who were the tenants before you. While they were living here, my office received a number of complaints about them. I spoke to Schaffer personally on several occasions. He’s involved with drugs and hangs out with a rough crowd.”
“But…he eventually moved away.”
“I don’t think it was by choice. I can’t say for sure exactly how they did it, but I believe Cliff Harding and Jack Griffin persuaded the Smiths and their gang, including Mark, to leave. They hadn’t paid rent in months and they were bringing undesirables into the neighborhood. Grace was afraid that if she evicted them, they’d trash the house.”
“And you figure Cliff and Jack convinced them to move?”
“True. But I don’t know how.” He gave her a half smile. “You’ll have to ask Grace about that and, when you find out, don’t tell me, okay?”
“Okay.”
“My guess is that Mark, or one of his cronies, left a stash of drugs behind in their rush to vacate the premises. He’s been coming back looking for that. Most likely drugs, but it could be money or something else of value. I assume it’s hidden somewhere in the garage, seeing he’s targeted that area.”
“But he broke into the house first.”
“Either he doesn’t remember exactly where he hid his stash or whatever it is—or he was hoping to get you to move so he’d have time to search after you left. When you didn’t turn tail and run, he had to take his chances, which is why he returned to the house. Then you got the alarm system and he was limited to the garage.”
“It’s over, then.” The relief in her voice was evident.
“I believe so. Ironically, I think there’s a good possibility that whatever was hidden inadvertently got tossed out when Grace and Cliff had the house cleaned and repainted.”
Troy stood up to leave. The cut on his mouth had started to throb and he needed to get to the station to deal with Schaffer.
She walked him to the front door, but stopped him before he could open it.
“You’re safe now,” he assured her.