“You spilled juice in my hair.”
Bobby giggles at that. “Mommy said you looked like an alien with purple on your face.”
Daniel’s gaze is as soft as velvet, yet it hits me hard. I’ve never seen a man who looks at his son with such unabashed love. Once Bobby sees that, he’ll know he’s safe in this world. “You were too little to get on the bumper cars.”
“You said they were a dumb ride anyway.”
“Aye. And so they were.”
For the rest of the meal, they trade memories and stories. By the time we head back to the truck, they are smiling at each other.
On the way home, we listen to the radio. It’s Randy Travis’s whiskey-velvet voice singing “I’m Gonna Love You Forever and Ever.” As the words float through the cab, I find myself looking at Daniel.
When we get back to the lodge, it’s almost seven o’clock. Bobby immediately runs to the television and puts a DVD in the machine. He’s chosen The Santa Clause.
I start for my room.
“Where you going, Joy?” Bobby says.
“You and your dad need some time together. I’ll see you to . . .”
“No.” He turns to Daniel. “Tell her, Daddy. Invite her to watch the movie with us.”
I draw in a breath, waiting. I know he will release me and keep Bobby to himself. It’s not even the wrong thing to do.
“Please,” Daniel says softly, smiling my way. “Stay with us.”
It isn’t until then, when I hear his velvety brogue wrap around those three small words, that I realize how much I wanted Daniel to ask me to stay.
“Sure,” I say, hoping I don’t sound as desperate as I feel.
Daniel and Bobby sit on the couch together. I curl into the red chair, opposite them.
As I sit here, listening to Bobby’s laughter, I consider how quiet my own house has become. If I’m to be honest—and why would I lie now?—our house was quiet long before Thom left me. Before he started sleeping with my sister. When I look back on my marriage, the truth is that it was too quiet from the beginning.
On that last night in Bakersfield, Stacey was right. My marriage had been falling apart long before she came into the picture. It’s a truth I can finally admit.
“He’s getting fat ’cuz he’s Santa!” Bobby yells, bouncing in his seat.
His happiness is infectious; in no time, Daniel and I are laughing with him.
When the movie is over and Daniel says, “Time for bed, boyo,” and Bobby grumbles and whines that he’s not tired—even though he can’t keep his eyes open—I am sorry to see the evening end, sorry to face the prospect of going back to my room.
Daniel picks Bobby up and carries him toward the stairs.
“ ’Night, Joy,” Bobby calls out sleepily. “See you in the morning.”
“Good night, Bobby.”
I mean to get up and go to my room. I really do, but somehow I don’t move. I sit there, curled like a cat in the chair, staring at the fire. The family photographs on the mantel seize my attention. I go to the mantel, pick up the pictures, and pour over them like an archeologist looking for clues from the artifacts of a life. Who was Maggie? Why did their marriage end?
Later, when I hear Daniel’s footsteps on the stairs, I realize I’ve been waiting for him.
He comes into the room, stands in front of the fire. In the combination of orange light and dark shadows, he looks drawn and tired. We are close enough that a movement either way and we’d be touching. “I promised Bobby I’d come back down. I’m supposed to talk to you, don’t you know?”
“I’m glad,” I dare to answer.
“I’m not much of a talker these days.” His voice is so soft I have to lean toward him to hear. “The funny thing is, I used to be a real loudmouth, back in the pubs in Dublin, when I was a lad. I could talk till I was blue in the face and falling-down drunk.”
“It’s funny how things slip away, pieces of us, even.”
Daniel sighs. Nodding, he reaches for the single photograph left on the mantel, tucked now behind the Christmas village, and holds it close. It’s a picture of Maggie, looking young and vibrant and beautiful.
I have no idea what to say or do. He looks so raw right now, so utterly broken, that I’m afraid to speak.
He puts the photograph back and sits down on the hearth. “So, Joy.” He makes a sound that’s almost a laugh. “Maybe you could help me, too. It seems I was a bad father and a worse husband. I didn’t even think about putting up a Christmas tree. All I thought about was getting Bobby out of this place where the memories are so bad.”
“Moving won’t put his heart back together.” This is a truth I know; I learned it firsthand. I sit in the chair opposite him and lean forward. In a daring that’s completely foreign to me, I touch his thigh. “He needs you for that.”
A frown darts across his forehead. “What the hell . . .”
I draw back, instantly contrite. “I’m sorry.”
He gets to his feet. “The doc said I should talk to you, for Bobby, but . . .”
I get up and go to him, unable to stop myself.
We’re close now, almost face to face. I feel the softness of his breathing, smell the hint of wood smoke scent that clings to his T-shirt. “Daniel?”
“I feel like a bloody fool. How in the hell am I supposed to talk to you?”
I step back. “I’m sorry. I shouldn’t have . . .”
What? Touched him? Said anything? Come here in the first place? I have no idea what to say to him, what I did that was so wrong.