My stomach growls, ready for the rush of sugar. "Bring it out. I need something to cheer me up," I say. "There's a problem with my trip to Spain."
Irina gasps. "Oy, vat hoppened?"
I shrug. "It's a long story."
"I come bring pie right now, da?" Irina says before disappearing into the kitchen. She comes back a few minutes later with a huge slab of pie. I can tell before I taste it this is going to be a best-selling dessert at Auntie Mae's Diner next week.
Before I take the first bite, I say "You're the best, Irina," and dig my fork into the white moistness speckled with graham cracker, caramel, and chocolate chips. She always waits next to me until I swallow the first bite and give her my analysis.
"It's awesome," I say, savoring the moistness of the creamy part and the soft crunch of the chips blended with the smooth caramel and crumbly texture of the graham crackers. "One of your best."
Irina whisks herself back into the kitchen with a flutter.
"I see Irina found you," Mom says as she holds a tray full of double-decker platters. "By the time you finish the pie, I'll be done here and we can go home."
I watch as my mom places the platters expertly in front of the hungry bowlers.
When I take my second forkful, another customer walks in. It's an old lady with grey hair, white pants, and a turquoise jacket. Mr. Reynolds greets her with a kiss on her cheek. "Mom, why didn't you tell me you were coming?" he asks the lady. "Wait, where's Gladys?"
"I fired her yesterday," the lady says. "She was a pain in the you-know-what. Besides, I don't need a caretaker. I made it here without one, didn't I?"
Mr. Reynolds looks worried. "Mom, why can't you get along with anyone I hire to help you? I swear you just fire them to spite me."
The old lady stands up straight with her chin in the air like a three-year-old. "I don't need any help."
"You have a heart condition," Mr. Reynolds says.
She waves her hand in the air, dismissing his concern. "Who says?"
"Your doctor."
"What do doctors know, anyway? They call it practicing medicine because that's all they ever do. Practice. If you'd visit me once in a while, you'd know I'm doing fine."
"I just saw you on Saturday." He huffs, then says, "Are you hungry?"
"What do you have on special this week?"
"Irina will make you anything you want, Mom. Name it."
She narrows her eyes at him. "Corn and a big, juicy steak."
Mr. Reynolds shakes his head and chuckles. "Mom, you have diverticulosis and a heart condition. Try again."
"You're no fun, Lou."
"And you're a barrel of laughs. Just sit down at a table. Wait ... follow me and you can meet Linda's daughter. You've never met her before."
I look down at the pie, trying not to give away the fact I've been eavesdropping on their conversation.
"Maggie, this is my mother," Mr. Reynolds announces. "Mom, this is Linda's daughter Margaret. Everyone calls her Maggie."
I smile and hold out my hand. "Nice to meet you, Mrs. Reynolds. Are you the Auntie Mae?"
The old lady takes my hand and shakes it. "Dearie, Mae was the name of my son's first dog."
No way! I look to Mr. Reynolds for confirmation. He's smiling sheepishly.
"It's true," he whispers. "Shh, it's a secret. If the town finds out I named my restaurant after a dog, this place will be deserted within a week."
I highly doubt that. Auntie Mae's is crowded almost every night. Besides, there's not another diner within a ten-mile radius.
"I didn't know Linda had a daughter. How old are you, Margaret?" she asks, ignoring the fact that her son told her everyone calls me Maggie.
"Seventeen."
"She just started her senior year of high school, Mom," Mr. Reynolds announces loudly, as if his mother is hard of hearing. "And she's going to Spain in January for school. Why don't you sit with her while she tells you all about it. I'll go in the back and have Irina fix you something to eat."
"Tell her not to make it too healthy," Mrs. Reynolds orders before sitting down on the opposite bench from me. She eyes my plate. "Lou, tell Irina to cut me a generous slice of that pie, too."
I don't think Mr. Reynolds was listening to her last request, or maybe he wanted to let her think he wasn't listening.
The old woman places her purse beside her in the booth, then looks at me. She doesn't smile, she doesn't frown. She tilts her head, as if trying to figure out what's inside my thoughts. "Why do you want to leave Paradise so badly?" she asks, almost as if she really can read my mind.
"I just do," I say, hoping she'll leave it at that.
She makes a tsking noise with her tongue. "If you don't want to talk about it, just say so. No sense in beating around the bush."
I had been busy chipping the nail polish off my fingers, but I stop and look at Mrs. Reynolds. "I don't want to talk about it."
The old lady claps her hands together. "Fine. If you don't want to talk about it, we won't talk about it."
The only thing standing between me and this woman is the pie I have and she wants. And awkward silence. It's not that I'm trying to be rude, I just don't want to put into words how my life has become one disappointment after another. It's almost as if misery is following me and I've been cursed. If I only knew how to break that curse ...
"I'm sure you have your reasons for not wanting to talk about it. I can't imagine what those reasons are, but you're probably better off being silent and brooding about it rather than talking it out with someone who has nothing better to do than listen."