CHAPTER THIRTY
Sarah’s voice was surprisingly steady as she said, “Calvin and I are both totally able to be objective.”
Calvin noted how she didn’t say they were a couple again. She didn’t say they weren’t. She was the perfect politician, just like her father, hedging her bets, playing both sides.
Jerry looked confused. “So, you’re saying you’re not in a relationship? And that personal issues won’t affect your objectivity? For either of you?”
The barn was utterly, perfectly silent as everyone waited for her reply. Calvin knew he shouldn’t be waiting along with everyone else.
Because only a fool would wait for something that was never going to come.
“No,” she finally said, her response barely a whisper into the microphone. “We’re not in a relationship. And personal issues won’t affect our objectivity. For either of us.”
As soon as she stepped away from the microphone, the crowd stood up to gossip over the strange twist the meeting had taken. But even as darkness stole through him, Calvin couldn’t take his eyes off her. She looked pale. Stunned. As if she couldn’t quite believe the words that had just come out of her own mouth.
Her eyes were big as she turned to him, shaking her head as if trying to clear it. “Calvin.”
“Don’t, Sarah. Just don’t.”
He knew it wasn’t fair to blame her client for any of this, but in that moment, he actually hated the stranger as he came toward them. Simply because his presence tonight had forced her to admit the truth of her feelings—and to make her choice—not only in front of him, but before every single person at the meeting too.
She hadn’t denied being in a relationship with Calvin; she’d simply failed to be the one person he needed in his life to make him whole. He had invested so many hopes and dreams and promises in her, in the future he envisioned for them. But in the end—the end where he’d thought everything would work out eventually—she just wasn’t there, wasn’t ready to step up to the plate and try.
He heard her client speak to her as if through a long tunnel—“I’m not sure what to say, Sarah. I’m more than a little confused about this carousel business and what a knitting fundraiser could possibly have to do with our project plans”—but Calvin couldn’t stand there and listen one more second. Not when everything he’d thought was finally his wasn’t. Not when he needed to get out of there and start figuring out how to pick up the pieces.
Again.
* * *
“Calvin, please wait!” Sarah had followed him to the small room behind the stage, her voice thick with emotion.
He felt broken. All used up. Emptied out. And still, he couldn’t make himself leave. Not when she was still so close.
“I shouldn’t have said that. My answer was a mistake. I saw the look on my client’s face and freaked out. But I didn’t mean it. You know I didn’t mean it.”
Calvin’s throat was so tight he could hardly get any words out, and Sarah was blurring where she stood in front of him. “Your boss was there,” he told her, unable—unwilling—to keep the sarcasm from his tone. “You had to protect your job.”
She kept coming toward him, her hand outstretched. “I messed up. So, so badly. I was just acting out of habit, giving the kind of answer I’ve had to give a hundred times when a deal is going bad.” Tears were in her eyes as she said, “Please, Calvin, listen to me. I swear, I’m going to figure out a way to make it right. I’m going to tell everyone I didn’t mean it.”
All these years, the horrible memories of his father’s suicide had darkened Calvin’s dreams, along with that vision of Sarah walking away from him. He’d had to fight like hell not to guard his sister like a crazed man, not to imprison her with his fears. But he’d made sure to imprison his own heart, to keep what was left of it safe.
Until these past two weeks. Until Sarah returned to him…and he’d let himself love her again.
Only now, all of his fears were nailing him right in the middle of his heart, tearing out chunks, piece by piece, until he wasn’t sure how there could be anything left beating in his chest anymore.
“I always believed in you,” he said in a raw voice. “I know all those years came between us, but we were both just kids then, immature and full of pride. And now that we’re not those kids anymore, I had faith that you’d choose me this time. That you’d choose us.”
“Then give me another chance.” She wiped away her tears with the back of her hand. “Because nothing has ever hurt more than this—than knowing I had a second chance at love and I blew it. Please, believe in me one more time. Just one more time.”
God, it was all he wanted. To hold her in his arms and kiss away her tears. But he couldn’t keep pretending that would be enough. Because it wouldn’t be. He knew that now.
“I figured something out tonight. Something I didn’t want to see.” His throat felt like he’d swallowed fire. “It doesn’t matter what I believe. You’ve got to believe it too. And I don’t know how to make that happen.” She looked at him with those big blue eyes, tears falling one after the other as the words he had to say gutted him, body and soul. Gutted them both. “I thought it was about you admitting your love for me. I thought once you did that, everything would be okay, that you’d be able to be happy. I thought we could finally be happy together. But now I can see it’s not about me at all. It never was. You always loved me the best you thought you could. You still do.” And it wasn’t enough. “You said what you said tonight to drive me away.” He made himself hold her gaze, even though just looking at her hurt. “Congratulations. It finally worked.”
He made himself walk to the door, not stopping even when she said, “I thought you were going to love me forever. I thought you said you’d love me no matter what this time.”
Loving his mother hadn’t stopped her from dying too young. Loving his father hadn’t stopped him from killing himself. Loving Sarah hadn’t stopped her from leaving at eighteen. And it wouldn’t stop her from leaving now. He thought he’d broken through the final shred of fear in his soul. But now he knew that he couldn’t survive being left again by someone he loved.
Looking at her over his shoulder, he said, “I meant it, Sarah. I will always love you.”
And he would. Forever.
Even though he had to be the one who left this time.
* * *
Sarah needed to get out of the barn, out of the place where she’d made the biggest mistake of her life. She ran down Main Street, the wind whipping through the trees, her hair flying, goose bumps running up and down her limbs. It wasn’t until she was past all of the stores and restaurants that she realized it was raining.
The storm had come. And she’d been right to be afraid.
She ran until she was out of breath. Until she couldn’t run anymore. And that was when she looked up and realized she was standing in the cemetery. She hadn’t planned to run here, to run straight to her father, but she had nowhere else to go for answers. Tears and rain made it hard for her to find his gravestone. Finally, she saw the contours of her father’s name etched so carefully into the granite.
“I’ve missed you.” She dropped to her knees in the wet grass. “So much you wouldn’t believe it.”
She knew he wasn’t actually there in front of her, but she felt that he was listening all the same. And that was why she had to be honest. More honest than she’d ever let herself be.
“I tried to grab the brass ring. I gave it everything.” She bowed down over his grave, her sobs heaving in her chest, her entire body. “But I couldn’t do it.”
She’d never wanted to have to admit to anyone that the reason she’d always worked so hard was not because there was something vitally important that she needed to achieve…but simply because she was terrified of failing.
“Do you know that I never really felt like I fit in? I was so busy chasing after you, after your approval, that I never really let myself focus on the people who were here all along.”
She’d always felt like an outsider looking in. Searching for her place. Last night in Calvin’s arms, when she’d finally confessed her love, she’d wanted to believe that she’d found her place. But she hadn’t.
“Now that I’ve come back, I don’t want to be an outsider anymore. But I am. And it’s all my own fault. Especially with Calvin. I’m still in love with him. He was in love with me too, and he gave me a second chance.” The magnitude of everything she had just lost sent shooting pains through her. “But I ruined that. I threw his love away. For a job.”
Oh God, how could she not have realized until now—until it was too late—that losing her job was absolutely nothing compared to losing Calvin?
“I know you loved me. I know you raised me to be strong. And I tried. I did just what you said and gave it everything I could. But I don’t think I have anything left to give this time.”
Nothing but losing Calvin ten years ago had ever hurt this bad. Not even, she now realized, her father’s death.
She felt her phone ring in the pocket of her suit jacket. Please, let it be Calvin.
But it was her boss, Craig.
* * *
Calvin could hear laughter coming from inside Betsy’s house when he knocked on her front door.
“Oh, Calvin, hi!” She had on a sparkly hat. Behind her the house looked warm. Happy.
“Thanks for having Jordan over for dinner while I was at the town hall meeting. I appreciate it.” He tried to smile, but he couldn’t. “I can take her home now.”
“Calvin?” Betsy moved closer to him, pulling the door partway closed behind her. “Is everything okay?”
Uncomplicated was all he could think as he looked at the woman standing in front of him. Being with Betsy would have been so uncomplicated.
“It’s been a long night.”
Her eyes were full of concern. “You look like you need a drink. I’ve got an open bottle of wine that I’d be happy to share with you.” Betsy wasn’t the kind of woman who would break his heart. She would always be there, waiting for him with a smile, with open arms. “You’re getting wet. Come inside.”
And for the first time ever, he followed her in.