I know it the instant I push inside. I didn’t go deep with my fingers, because I wanted my cock to be the first thing inside those sweet depths. But I can feel the minute my cock goes deep inside of her, tearing through her innocence.

She’s a virgin.

She cries out and I instantly go still. It almost kills me, but I don’t allow myself to move and I stop before I sink in completely.

“It hurts,” she whispers and there’s a tear falling from the corner of her eye that kills me. I prop all my weight on one arm, unable to move, so I don’t hurt her further. Then, I take the pad of my thumb and brush the tear away.

“Why didn’t you tell me, Carly?”

“I was afraid,” she responds and I hate that answer.

“I never want you to be afraid to tell me anything, Carly. Baby, we’re going to be together for a long time. You need to be able to let yourself go with me. I promise you’re safe.”

“We are?” she asks. The entire time we’re talking, I’m moving my finger across her nipple lightly, trying to ease deeper into her. I can feel her getting wetter this way. I want to touch her pussy, but fuck, I can’t manage it in this position and I’m not leaving her. If I could find a way to stay inside of her 24/7 that would be a definite possibility at this point.

I didn’t want a virgin. I was afraid of hurting them, but fuck if I’m not happy that I’m the only one that’s been inside Carly. No one else will ever get the chance. I’m keeping her.

“I’m not giving you up, Carly. You’re mine now,” I tell her. Her hips rock into me and I sink another couple of inches into her. “Is the pain better?” I ask her, dying to move.

“Yes,” she says as she nods.

“Good. We’ll go slow and easy,” I murmur, kissing her forehead, trying to reassure her.

I pull out carefully, not all the way, but close. Then I push back in. I’m going so slow it may kill me, but eventually she takes a little more of my length. Afraid to feed her all of me, I do my best to make this as delicate as possible, even though my first urge is to slam all the way home.

Her hands move down my back, her fingernails scoring my skin as she does.

“You feel so good,” she whispers into my neck and fuck, I like that confession way too much. If I’m not careful she will own me.

“Yeah, baby?” I ask with a groan as she moves her legs, bending them so her feet are flat on the bed. It widens her stance and I sink in even further. That’s when her fingers move and her nails bury into the cheeks of my ass. “I feel so full,” she whimpers and this time her body moves up to meet me as I push deeper. I want to hold back, but now she doesn’t let me. She wants me deeper, and fuck if I don’t want her that way too.

“I need more,” she cries.

I go back on my knees, pulling her legs so her feet wrap around my body, opening her to me. My woman wants more and I’m going to give it to her. I hold her legs at first, widening them so I can watch my cock tunnel in and out of her pussy, the shaft coated in her sweet juices. The sight is so fucking good that I can feel my balls tighten with the need to explode inside of her. I put a finger on her clit, pushing hard, and then sweeping it over her clit faster, still keeping the pressure. Her body jerks, her head thrashes.

“That’s it baby, come for me,” I urge her.

“I’m going to come,” she yells, and I can’t be sure she even hears me; she’s going wild in my arms and it’s beautiful.

“Look at me, Carly,” I demand and I can feel my cum building. I’m going to lose it soon. She slowly opens her eyes, looking at me, her body bucking underneath me as she fights to claim my cock, her greedy pussy demanding he come back inside to the hilt. “This is my pussy now. It belongs to me, just like you do. There’s no going back now, Carly. Do you hear me?”

“No going back,” she sighs.

“Admit you’re mine, Carly. I need to hear you say it.”

“I’m yours, Stone. I’m yours,” she says.

With that, I fuck her hard. She might be small, but she can take me. She was made for me. I keep teasing her clit with my finger and thrusting into her at a fast, steady rhythm. I feel the exact moment that Carly’s climax hits her.

“Give it to me baby, give it to me,” I whisper in her ear as I blanket her body, sinking up to my balls and grinding her tight little cunt.

“Stone!” she cries as she comes apart on me. Her greedy pussy sucks my cock and triggers my own orgasm. I release jet after jet of hot cum inside of her and I don’t stop until she’s so full it’s dripping down my balls.

Carly is mine. Finally, after all this time, I have her and I’m never letting her go.