NORA
“SHE MUST HAVE USED the hand pump in the yard.” Nora plucked the box of hair dye out of the dry sink and held it between her fingers as if it were something filthy. Vile.
“If the water and electricity are turned off, why would the yard pump work?” Ethan swept the beam of his iPhone flashlight app around the tiny bathroom, illuminating the gossamer strands of broken cobwebs and highlighting the years of dust that had settled on every flat surface. Mirror frame, bathtub ledge, shelf. Nothing had escaped the thick, gray film except the sink where Tiffany had obviously changed her appearance. Dramatically. Beneath the cardboard box, the bowl was filled with long dark hair.
“Because it draws from a cistern. We used it when we were kids to put out bonfires. Lorelei used to hang a five-gallon bucket from the handle. It might still be there.”
“Nobody cared that you had bonfires out here? This place is a tinderbox.”
“Obviously we didn’t have fires in the house.” Nora rolled her eyes, but Ethan’s back was turned to her.
“Still.”
“It probably bothered Lorelei. But it wasn’t like she could stop us. Besides, out of sight, out of mind. There’s half a mile and an old oak grove between the farmhouse and this shack.”
Ethan spun toward her and smiled. In the slanting, shadowy light he looked slightly maniacal. “You’re such a badass.”
“Were,” Nora corrected. She tossed the empty box of dye back into the sink and left the bathroom. “I’m straight as a pin these days.”
“Oh, I don’t know.” Ethan followed close behind, illuminating her path as she led him back to the abandoned living room. It was just as tiny as the rest of the house, with barely enough space for a sagging couch and a plaid La-Z-Boy. “This whole situation is a little off the grid.”
“What’s that supposed to mean?”
Nora had stopped abruptly, and Ethan walked right into her. “Sorry,” he said, catching her about the shoulders. But Nora didn’t want to be touched. She pulled away. “I didn’t mean anything by that,” Ethan said, holding up his hands. The light from his phone glowed white on the water-stained ceiling.
“No, you did mean something by that.”
“I’m sorry.” Ethan searched her face, his gaze earnest. “Bad joke. Nerves. I don’t know. I’ve never done anything like this before.”
“Neither have I.”
But that wasn’t entirely true. Hadn’t the last several years of her life been one giant lie? A game of hide-and-seek—except the people who were supposed to be seeking her never came. Until now. And Donovan was the last person she wanted on her trail.
“I don’t understand,” Ethan said slowly. Carefully. “Why can’t we go to the cops for help?”
Nora brushed past him and sat down on the couch with a sigh. A cloud of dust puffed up around her and she sneezed. Twice in quick succession. “Because they’d take Everlee away. Tiffany is not exactly the mother of the year now, is she?”
“But—”
“No buts. We can’t lose her.”
“You’ve lost her now.”
“She’s safe now,” Nora said, rubbing her nose with the back of her hand.
“With Quinn?” Ethan put his phone on the table between them, then sat down in the La-Z-Boy. Another explosion of dust. They both sneezed. “That’s not a permanent fix, Nora, and you know it.”
Did she ever. “That’s why we’re going to find Tiffany.”
“What about Everlee’s birth father?”
Nora froze. Breathing shallowly, she attempted a joke. “She was immaculately conceived.” It came out brittle.
“Tiffany never struck me as virginal.”
“He’s not in the picture, okay?”
“Why not?” Ethan pressed. “Seems to me we could use this information against Donovan.”
“It’s complicated. Look, you don’t understand. It’s been over six years. We worked so hard to keep Tiffany and Everlee together that—”
“He doesn’t know, does he?” There was no judgment in the question, just a calm statement of the truth, but Nora’s blood fizzed just the same. She shivered.
“If I have my way, he’ll never know.”
“Why not?”
“He doesn’t deserve her. He never did.”
Ethan didn’t ask any more questions after that. He sat on the edge of the rocking chair, elbows on his knees, and stared at Nora across the dim room. She couldn’t see his eyes.
“Sometimes you have to take matters into your own hands,” Nora said quietly, as if in explanation. She felt the need to make him understand that whatever they had done was for love. “Tiffany and Everlee are supposed to be together—and far, far away from here.”
“But Tiffany took off. Without Everlee.”
“We’re going to fix that.”
He didn’t say anything, but Nora could almost hear the questions swirling in the air between them.
“There are a couple of motels in Key Lake,” Nora said, changing the subject. Her tone carried a note of finality, but it was diminished when she broke into a wide yawn.
“I thought we were roughing it.”
“This is definitely roughing it. The house is dingier than I remember,” Nora admitted. “Tiff and I used to keep the place in decent shape. We shook out the cushions in the spring and swept the floors . . . We spent the night in the summertime when we could open the windows to catch a breeze.”
“This place is a museum, Nora.” Ethan looked around, taking in the velvet print above the couch and the crocheted doily on the end table.
“When Tiff’s grandparents moved out, they only took a few things with them. They were . . .” She fumbled. “Unique people. Kept mostly to themselves, didn’t much care for the stuff most people get all caught up in.”
“I can tell.” Ethan leaned over and tapped the face of his phone. “It’s one thirty,” he said. “Are we going to stick around and see if Tiffany comes back?”
“She won’t.”
“But Donovan?”
Nora glanced around and felt the skin prickle at the back of her neck. She felt like someone was watching her, just outside the room, and she wrapped her arms around herself to ward off the sudden chill. “He’s already been here.”
“What?” Everything in Ethan tensed. He perched on the edge of his seat, vigilant. “How do you know?”
Nora pointed to the front door, clearly visible from the tiny living room where they sat. It was hanging open a couple of inches, the bolt still protruding from the casement. “I have the key,” she said, holding up the set that she had taken from the piece of loose siding next to the tiny front porch. She hadn’t needed it because the lock had already been popped, forced open by a blunt instrument that hacked away at the soft, moldy wood. Tiffany would have used the key.
“Why didn’t you say something?”
Nora shrugged. “You were walking around the perimeter of the house when I let myself in. It didn’t seem relevant until now.”
“Relevant?” Ethan was visibly upset. “It didn’t seem relevant to share that someone had already broken in? You’re insane, Nora.”
“I just know Donovan. It’s not like he’s going to walk in here and kill us both with a chain saw.” But her words, so blithely spoken, made her stomach somersault. What did she know about Donovan Richter? How could she claim what he was and was not capable of? She said, with more conviction than she felt: “If he was here and she was gone, there’s no reason for him to come back.”
Ethan looked skeptical, but he asked: “Can you sleep? Here?”
Nora folded her arms behind her head and closed her eyes. “Can you?”
“I can sleep anywhere.”
“Me too,” Nora said. But that was a dirty lie.
“And tomorrow?”
“We find Tiffany.”
But Nora wasn’t sure what they were going to do. And she doubted she’d be able to sleep, but Ethan tactfully pretended not to notice her distress. He pushed himself out of the chair and cracked open the double-hung window on the wall behind him. Then he grabbed a straight-backed chair from the kitchen table and shut the front door as firmly as he could, securing the chair beneath the wrecked handle. As if that would save them.
“Thank you,” Nora said softly.
Ethan just eased back into the La-Z-Boy with an elaborate sigh. Yanking up the footrest, he crossed his arms over his chest. “Good night, Nora.”
“Night.”
Within minutes, he was snoring lightly. Or pretending to.
There wasn’t really a breeze, but the cool night air ghosted into the room and raised goose bumps on Nora’s arms all the same. She felt clammy and restless, haunted by memories of this place and the friendship that had taken her so far from herself. Tiffany was more than a friend to her, more than a sister even. They shared a secret, and in some ways a little girl.
It seemed everyone wanted to stake their claim on Everlee.
• • •
Nora thought she wouldn’t sleep, but when Ethan touched her shoulder she bolted upright and realized that the sun was streaming through the windows of the old Barnes house.
“Good morning,” he said with a smile. “I hate to wake you, but I was afraid you were about to fall off the couch.”
The cushions had slipped sideways in the night and Nora was indeed teetering on the edge. She must have had a rough night. She hoped that she didn’t call out in her sleep or do something equally embarrassing.
“Hi,” she said, running her hands through her short hair. No doubt she was a walking disaster. Mussed and wrinkled, bleary-eyed and in desperate need of a shower, a toothbrush, a fresh start. At least Donovan hadn’t come back to the house. But, then again, neither had Tiffany. “Have you been up long?”
“Nah. Fifteen minutes or so. I grabbed my bag and cleaned up by the pump outside.” Ethan smiled crookedly at her and Nora realized that he looked exhausted. He clearly hadn’t slept a wink all night long. But his teeth were white and he smelled of peppermint and soap. Irish Spring, if her nose could be trusted.
“I’m a wreck,” she said, standing up. She was a little unsteady, but Ethan didn’t reach to right her. Instead, he handed over her backpack.
“Take your time,” he said.
The water was icy, but the morning was already warm. Nora scrubbed her teeth first, brushing away the film of the night and the fear that had turned her tongue sour. Then she began to wash her face, but, thinking better of it, dunked her whole head under the stream of well water. Short hair, don’t care. She finger-picked it out and shook her head. It would settle into a tousled, beachy style that would fit in perfectly in Key Lake. Not that it mattered.
While Nora changed her clothes in the bedroom, Ethan straightened out the house and erased the signs of Tiffany’s presence. Donovan had already seen the evidence (or maybe he had witnessed the transformation?), but it seemed imperative that they destroy any trace of what Tiffany had done. Her hair and the box of dye went into an old grocery bag that Ethan stuck in the trunk of his car. Then they tried to lock the damaged front door of the shack and replaced the key in the hiding spot.
“Where to?” Ethan said, rubbing a hand over his face.
“Why are you doing this?” Nora asked suddenly. She was surprised by her own boldness but compelled by the guilt that she felt. It hurt to see Ethan like this. To know that she was the one who had etched lines across his usually smooth, carefree forehead. “Seriously. I don’t know why you’re here.”
But rather than trying to defend himself, to offer up some trite, made-for-the-movies answer, Ethan just gave her a small smile. Something about him softened. Fell away. For just a moment he looked younger than he was. And scared, too. “You need me,” he said simply.
It was true. It was so true Nora didn’t know what to say. She swallowed hard. “You need to eat,” she finally offered. “Cinnamon rolls? Coffee?”
“Sure.”
“I’d like everything to-go. I don’t really want to bump into anyone I know today.”
“Small-town life, huh?”
“Something like that.”
“I’ll pop in. You can wait in the car. Just give me directions.”
The clock in Ethan’s car read 8:07. Nora was sure the people she wanted to talk to would be up by now, but it was Saturday morning. Estes Law Offices would be closed for the day, but that didn’t mean she couldn’t look up Roger Estes’s number in the white pages and knock on his front door. Thankfully Pine Hills was always open. They could start there.
Ethan picked up a pair of giant cinnamon rolls and two cups of coffee in paper cups from Luverne’s, then followed Nora’s instructions to one of the lesser-known beaches along the south side of Key Lake. Redrock Bay, with its long expanse of sifted sand, was a favorite among locals and vacationers, and there was the Key Lake public beach along the west side that attracted families with younger kids because of the playground equipment, shallow waters, and gradual drop-off. But Pocket Beach was exactly that: a little pocket of land hidden by weeping birches. The beach itself was shaped like a diamond and too stony to make sunbathing an option. They would be alone, Nora felt sure of that.
She was right. The slip of rocky sand was deserted. A stiff summer wind stirred up chop on the water that spread out blue and foamy from the small headland. There were boulders along the south edge of the secluded beach, and Nora headed there, coffee in one hand as she shielded her eyes from the glare of the morning sun with the other.
“Key Lake’s best-kept secret,” she told Ethan as she settled cross-legged on one of the wide rocks. “Nobody ever comes here.”
Nora expected him to at least try to chatter back and pepper her with questions or comment on the unexpected beauty of the alcove in the trees. His personality mandated it. But when Nora turned to face him, she found that Ethan was holding something out for her—and it wasn’t the bag of cinnamon rolls.
“I found this on the bulletin board at Luverne’s.”
“What is it?” she asked without reaching for it.
“Just take it.” Ethan took a step forward, the set of his jaw uncharacteristically grave, and pushed the paper toward her. Nora had no choice but to accept it.
How could a sheet of white printer paper be ominous? Even terrifying? But as Nora unfolded the page her heart shuddered and stopped, if only for a moment.
It was a picture of Everlee.
The photo had been snapped a year or so ago, her head tilted to the side, her eyes wide and reflecting twin points of light. She was smiling, but it was a closemouthed, hesitant smile, as if someone had instructed her to do so and she’d obeyed. Good girl.
Nora had never seen the picture before.
And she was so intent on studying the curve of her cheek, the way Everlee’s long blond hair fell past her shoulders and beyond the frame of the photo, that she almost missed the text beneath the portrait.
Missing Child
If you have any information, please call the number below.