Claudia didn’t hold back her anguish. The crying that was coming from behind a closed door escalated to a full-blown wail as she tried to come to grips with the news of her sister’s murder. Before long, her voice was joined by a younger, more piercing one, and Nick, whose patience and compassion had broken down rapidly, yelled out, “You happy? Now you woke the fucking baby.”
It took fifteen minutes before things settled down and Nick emerged from one of the bedrooms.
“Sorry about the ruckus,” he said. “Claudia never could deal with her sister’s issues. She’s from the if-you-pretend-the-problem-isn’t-there-it-will-eventually-go-away school of denial.”
“But she told us that she warned Aubrey about Janek Hoffmann,” I reminded him. “That doesn’t sound like she was pretending the problem wasn’t there.”
He shook his head. “You’re missing the point. Janek wasn’t the problem. I’m not saying he didn’t kill her. Maybe he did. But it could also have been any one of a thousand other guys. The real problem was Aubrey. She was one of those women—they used to call them nymphomaniacs. I think the politically correct term these days is sex addict. But with Aubrey…”
I thought he was groping for words, but he wasn’t. He’d clammed up.
“You want something to drink?” he asked. “Water? Or I could make coffee.”
“Nick,” I said, “we’re investigating a murder here. Finish what you were going to say.”
He plopped into a cushy armchair and immediately stood up again. “You guys have to sit down. I can’t talk if you’re going to stand there hovering over me like a couple of dark clouds.”
Kylie and I sat on the sofa. Nick reclaimed his spot in the chair.
“Aubrey was a sex addict, but she wasn’t like one of those party girls who really likes screwing. It was different for her.”
“Different,” Kylie repeated. Her body shifted on the sofa, and she turned toward him. “How so?”
She asked the question offhandedly, but I recognized the tone. Kylie is a hunter, a puma lying in wait for the gazelle.
Nick sat back in his chair. “She only got off if the guy was dishing out physical pain or putting her through abject humiliation.”
“That’s very helpful,” Kylie said. “And your wife has trouble dealing with that fact?”
“Dealing? I don’t know if Claudia even has a clue.”
“Then how do you know so much about your sister-in-law’s sexual preferences?” Kylie asked, her fierce green eyes locking into his limp brown-eyed gaze.
“Whoa, whoa, whoa,” Nick said, holding up his hands. “Back off, lady.”
“I’m not a lady. I’m a homicide detective, and if I even smell that you’re holding out on me, I will slap a pair of cuffs on you and haul you in for obstructing justice.”
Nick looked at me for help.
“She’ll do it,” I said. “And I’ll back her up. Answer the question: how do you know what your wife’s sister got off on?”
He looked at me like I’d just handed him a shovel and told him to start digging his own grave.
“This is between us, okay? If Claudia ever knew…”
“If it’s not directly related to our investigation, then it’s our secret,” Kylie said. “We don’t tell your wife, and we don’t even put it in our report.”
He nodded. It wasn’t exactly an ironclad guarantee, but he knew it was the best he was going to get.
“It happened five years ago,” he said, easing into his story. “Claudia had just given birth to our first kid. It was a C-section, so she was in the hospital for a couple of days. It was the second night, and visiting hours were over, so Aubrey and I left together. It started out innocent enough. We were just going to have a couple of drinks and get something to eat.”
He paused, hoping we could figure out the rest on our own. I decided to help him out.
“And one thing led to another?” I said.
“Claudia had complications during the pregnancy. She cut me off in her sixth month. I was horny as a stallion and plenty drunk. Aubrey was even drunker and plenty willing. We went back to her place.”
“And?”
“And the girl was a total freak show. Hey, I’m all in favor of getting a little kinky—leather, role-playing, the kind of shit you read about in those “Spice Up Your Sex Life” articles in magazines—but when a chick begs me to put a cigarette butt out on her nipple, I draw the line.”
“Did you ever consummate the relationship with her?”
“No. I guess I sobered up in a hurry. When I realized what a hot mess she was, I got out of there.”
He leaned forward in his chair. “You must think I’m a real hypocrite. I would’ve fucked my wife’s sister, but I wouldn’t paddle her, whip her, or piss on her. But trust me, there’s a city full of guys who would, and she knew where to find every one of them.”
“How many other names can you give us besides Janek Hoffmann?”
“None. Zero. I swear. I never asked. I didn’t want to know. The only reason I knew Janek was that he was her cameraman, and they had this serious on-again, off-again relationship for over a year. I saw a lot of him. And I saw the bruises on her. I didn’t have to ask him if he did it. He’s the kind of guy who has to beat the shit out of someone, and Aubrey was the kind of woman who needed the beating. It was a match made in sadomasochist heaven.”
“Do you know where Janek Hoffmann lives?” I asked.
His body sagged, and he slumped down in his chair. “I don’t know,” he mumbled. “Somewhere in Brooklyn.”
Somewhere in Brooklyn turned out to be a block from where Aubrey’s car was parked.