“Who was that?” I was lying on the bed, cuddled closely to Stephen. Right as we were in the middle of sharing our true feelings, Tyler’s phone rang. Stephen and I were becoming antsy as we waited for him to finish the call. “Sorry, that was rude.” I was asking questions that were none of my business.

“Why?” Tyler said and crawled across the bed. He kissed us both and lay down directly in front of us. “It was my mom.”

“Wow, were her ears ringing?” I teased.

He playfully pushed at my shoulder. “Funny. No, if you must know. She wanted to know if I was coming over for dinner on Sunday.”

I sat up. “What? Seriously?”

“Yeah, why?”

“Can Stephen and I go with you?”

“Zoe,” he ground out and rolled onto his back. He threw his arm over his eyes and moaned.

“You did pinky swear,” Stephen whispered from behind me.

“Yeah, to discuss the topic. Not take you to my family’s house for dinner.” The moment the words were out, I could tell by the look on his face he wanted to take them back. He sat up and grabbed Stephen’s hand right before he was able to leave the bed. “I didn’t mean that.”

“What did you mean?” Stephen said with his back to us.

“I—”

It was hard to see the pain in Tyler’s eyes. Then I moved over and straddled Stephen. There was a tear rolling down his cheek. I lightly brushed it away and kissed each spot. “Don’t leave.”

Tyler wrapped his legs over Stephen and moved in closer. “Please stay. Help me to make this right.”

Stephen was so handsome, and he always seemed so confident. Tonight, he looked defeated by Tyler’s words. “I don’t know if I can help, Ty.”

“We can. Together,” I quickly said.

“You’re acting as though we’re officially together.” Stephen was brushing his thumbs back and forth on my skin.

“Maybe I am.”

“How can you be sure that’s what you want? We’ve only known each other for a few weeks. Actually, you wouldn’t talk to us for several of those days.”

Stephen’s words should’ve upset me. Instead, I leaned forward and kissed him. “I needed time to think.”

“Ahhhh, is that what you were doing?” Stephen tickled my side.

“I heard through the grapevine you smelled worse than a skunk.” Tyler tried to hold in his laughter.

“What? Is that true?” Stephen looked over at Tyler. I grabbed the side of his face and moved him to face me. “Don’t listen to him. He has no idea what he’s talking about.” I bent to kiss him. “Plus, I only smell like roses.”

“Apparently skunk-smelling roses.” Tyler pulled me off Stephen’s body and rolled me under him. “I can’t believe Lucky and Sammy still wanted to lay with you at night.”

“It’s because I’m irresistible.”

“You are that.” Tyler bent down and captured my lips. “And you talk too much.”

“I what?”

Stephen rolled onto his side and kissed me before I could protest anymore. “Way too much.”

The lighthearted feeling in the room immediately shifted. I could see by the look in Stephen’s eyes that the conversation was over. We had more pressing things to discuss.

I did a perfect grappling move that rolled Tyler over so he was lying directly beside Stephen. They were side-by-side, and I loved how their chests were moving up and down at a faster pace with each passing minute. “Show me what to do,” I whispered.

Stephen didn’t hesitate. He leaned up and wrapped his hand around the back of Tyler’s neck to pull him closer. Right before their lips touched, Stephen glanced up at me and then kissed Tyler. His eyes never left mine as he took the kiss deeper.

I ran my hands down their chests, over each definition, and finally reached what I craved. The moment I took their cocks in my hands, their bodies lifted off the bed. I loved how they never broke contact and continued to devour each other. While holding Tyler and moving my hand up and down, I bent to take Stephen in my mouth. He was bigger than I had ever experienced before, and I had to hold back my gag reflexes as I took him in deeper. After a few minutes, I quickly switched over to Tyler and enjoyed the feel of him on my tongue.

“Zoe.” I heard my name but was too lost in the moment. “Zoe, baby,” Tyler said and brushed his fingers through my hair falling around my face.

I lifted up and pouted. “I’m not done.”

“You are for now,” Stephen said and moved to the side of the bed. He reached into the nightstand to grab the lube and condoms.

I didn’t know what to say. Instead of filling the moment with words, I waited for them to tell me what to do next. Stephen didn’t do anything with the items he had just retrieved. He sat there watching Ty and I, which felt odd at first. Then my body started to heat from his stare.

Tyler sat up and cupped his hand behind my neck to bring me closer. “Lie down, Zoe.”

I didn’t hesitate. I did what he asked.

He peppered light kisses up each leg, over my knees, until he reached the junction. “Spread your legs,” he demanded.

I could feel the effects of an orgasm. How was this even possible? I had a feeling tonight I would experience a lot of firsts. Finally, I stopped overthinking and spread my legs.

“God, you’re so beautiful,” Ty whispered. I could feel his breath. The hot air moved across my skin, causing a chill to run up my spine. I thought he would warn me before he dropped his head. He never did. The moment his tongue ran up my core, my body lifted off the bed yet again. “Oh, she tastes delicious, Stephen.” His words almost sent me over the edge.

“Let me taste,” Stephen said and bent down beside Tyler.

“Oh fuck,” I ground out.

“You can’t come yet, Zoe,” Stephen demanded.

“I—” There was no way I could hold in what was about to happen. “I have never felt this way before.”

“Then don’t let that feeling go just yet.” Tyler bit down on my clit, causing me to cry out his name.

“Ty, you’re not playing fair,” Stephen said and placed two fingers inside me.

I was going over the edge now. There was no stopping me. Tyler continued to lick and suck, while Stephen moved his two fingers in and out at a faster pace. “I can’t hold on any longer,” I screamed right before finally letting go. Every emotion, feeling, and desire coursed through my veins. When the orgasm finally subsided, they were both still pleasuring me. The feeling was almost too intense. Every part of my body felt over-sensitized.

“Are you ready for more?” Tyler finally stopped and lifted his head to face me.

“Wait, I need one more taste.” Stephen surprised me and bent his head.

“Oh, God,” I cried out the moment he brushed his tongue up once more.

“She really is delicious.” Stephen lifted his head and licked his lips.

“Zoe.” Tyler moved closer. “We both want to be inside you, and now. Are you okay with that?”

I was still coming down from the intense emotions. “If you don’t, I’ll force you to.”

“Oh, well okay then.” Ty laughed and kissed me.

Stephen moved his body to the center of the bed and held his arms open for me. I climbed on top in a sitting position with my back facing Tyler. Before positioning my body perfectly, I rolled the condom up. The moment I realized what was about to happen, I actually got excited. Stephen helped me position his cock perfectly, and then I pushed down slowly. I glanced back at Tyler and pushed down a little more. He was much bigger than I was used to, and it took a few thrusts before I knew he was all the way inside. I began to move up and down so I could enjoy the feeling as he slid in and almost out.

“Zoe.” Tyler leaned forward. “Fuck, you both look so beautiful right now.”

“We’d look even better with you here, too.”

“This may be a little cold.” I thought I was prepared, and then he rubbed the gel on my backside, causing me to gasp. Without warning, I felt the tip of his cock and cried out. “Are you okay?” He sounded concerned.

“If you stop now, I’m going to be pissed.”

“Message received.” Tyler was softly chuckling, but it died away. His light-hearted laugh was replaced with heavy breathing and loud moans. I was facing Stephen, but the moment Tyler started to enter me, I dropped my head to his chest. “Zoe, I need you to relax, baby.” I needed something more to relax me. I lifted my head and started to kiss Stephen. The contact somehow calmed my body. “That’s it, sweetheart.” There was a push and I knew at that moment I had relaxed enough for Tyler. He started to move in and out at a very slow pace.

“Faster, Ty,” I begged.

“Are you sure, baby?” He rubbed his hands up and down my back. “I don’t want to hurt you.”

I didn’t answer him. Instead, I found a rhythm that allowed me to move in and out with both men. The invasion was intense at first, but as we found a pace that worked for all of us, I wanted more.

We continued to move in and out for what felt like hours but was obviously just minutes. “Ty, Stephen, I can’t wait anymore.”

“Then don’t.” Stephen brushed his hand down the side of my face and cupped his hand behind my neck. “Look at me, Zoe. I want to see your face when you come for us.”

It was hard to look up, but I forced myself to do just that. “Oh, God,” I ground out. As I felt the rise of my second orgasm, Tyler increased his pace. “Harder, Ty,” I begged. He did what I asked, thankfully. A second later, I screamed louder than I had anticipated and fell onto Stephen’s chest.

“Lean up, Zo,” Stephen purred beside my ear. “We need you up.”

I forced my body to rise and needed the help of Stephen to keep me focused. I watched as Stephen closed his eyes and let go. There was a single tear that fell from the corner of his eye. Did I hurt him? “Stephen, are you okay?” He only smiled and nodded. Now we both had to work as a team to give Tyler exactly what he needed.

“Watching you both…fuck me,” Tyler said in between heavy moans. “I…oh fuck…I want more of this feeling.” Then he cried out his release and fell onto my back. We stayed connected for a few more minutes. When Tyler moved off, I felt sad. “I’ll be right back,” he said.

I didn’t move off Stephen yet. “You’re stuck with me here for a few more minutes.”

“Good, I’m not ready for you to leave.” Stephen kissed my temple and was rubbing his fingers up and down my back.

“Shit, that needs to happen again,” Tyler said as he crawled back onto the bed.

“Now?” I lifted my head up. What happened next surprised me. I could feel Stephen growing harder inside me. “No, you’re not, are you?”

He shrugged his shoulders. “It’s not my fault.”

Tyler snuggled beside us. “It’s Zoe’s fault, isn’t it, love?”

Stephen was in the perfect position to lean his head over and kiss Tyler. “Exactly.”

I sat up in cowgirl position and rubbed my hands up and down Stephen’s chest. “I’m ready for round two.” I didn’t know how I was, but there was something about being with two men that caused my hormones to race into overdrive.

I definitely could get used to this.