RILEY
Zachary strolled into the den soon after her and smiled down at her. He was in simple black sweats and a black tank top. She could see several of his tattoos now, like all of the nautical half-sleeve on his right arm and his tribal half-sleeve. His tank rode up a little, showing off his abs from being tight and his sweats rode low on his hips. He had one of those delicious Vs that made her want to drool. It was almost more sexy when he was wearing pants then when he was nude.
“We’re watching a couple horror movies tonight,” he moved her and took her couch. She gaped at him stealing the couch from her. “And I promised to make sure you always felt safe. So, we’re movie buddies this time.”
She chuckled at his words. That was sweet. Every movie, they forced her to sit with someone else. Like the time first time with Troy and Gabe, they kept things pretty innocent, letting her lay on them to watch the flick.
“Cute,” she teased him. “Big bad tiger wants to keep the little cheetah safe! Awww-”
He grabbed her and pulled her down to him. He was over a foot taller then her and he pressed her into his chest. Her ass hit his hips and he trapped her legs with his own.
“Did you seriously not wear underwear to this run?” He growled low to her. She felt his chest rumble behind her and blushed.
“Yeah. For some reason, I felt better just having less clothing to deal with.” She tried to shrug it off like it wasn’t a big deal.
“Fuck,” he groaned, letting her have a little space from his body. He pulled his hips back from her ass and she had a feeling she knew why. But it was rude to mention certain scents from people. As they had now reminded her several times though it wasn’t easy. It didn’t help that Zachary had started cuddling her like that though. This was his fault, not hers.
They were quiet for a moment. The other guys slowly got into the room. Brenton looked down at them and sighed with a chuckle before claiming his favorite couch on the left. Andrew ended up sitting with him, taking over half the couch. Brenton didn’t seem to care. Troy and Gabe both made a few lewd comments at the sight of her and Zachary until he snarled at them. They claimed their own couch and someone hit play for the movie.
Riley was ashamed to admit that the movie terrified her. She used Zachary’s arm to block her view of the TV during the worst parts in the beginning and pushed her entire body into his.
Only a quarter way through it, he took his arm back and grabbed her hip, holding it tightly. He then rubbed himself into her as he shifted to get more comfortable and she bit back a moan. Lord have mercy, he was hard as a rock.
“If you don’t want to watch,” he mumbled in her ear, “then turn around.”
She did turn around. Normally she liked a good horror but something about the girl from the Ring freaked her out way to much. This movie was the original ring movie as well, from Japan. They did it well.
His hands roamed to her ass and cupped it, pressing her again him tighter. She whimpered at the feeling of his erection pressing in her core. He had positioned her perfectly and her face was pressed into his chest. She didn’t know Zachary liked her this much.
“Zachary,” she whispered. “Do you… um…”
“Yeah, baby?” He growled softly back. She remembered what Brenton had said and moved her hips to roll against him. That brought about a near desperate growl. She wanted him, oh yeah. She had practically forgotten about all the other guys in the room, so pressed again Zachary that she could only smell him and herself. And they were both very aroused.
“Do you…like me?” she mumbled the words as quietly as she could.
“Yes,” he growled softly. “Figured you would have figured that out by now.”
“You can be pretty grumpy,” she poked his ribs.
“I’m not grumpy right now and look who I have pressed up against me,” his hand squeezed her ass as he spoke. “Movie time, we’ll talk after.”
He kept watching the movie, just holding her there nearly the entire time. At one point, she tried to wiggle for some obscene reason and he slapped her ass. That made her moan louder then she had ever dreamed. After that, he rubbed harder against her and she panted, holding him tightly by his tank top. The hand on her ass drifted to her thigh, dragging his nails over her yoga pants. She whimpered, moving that thigh over his legs, giving him space to move that hand between her legs and rub her through her thin yoga pants as the only barrier.
She was going mad and this tiger was the cause. She was turned on to the point that she had no other thought on her mind then solving it. He growled her name and moved a little again, letting his cock find it’s way to grind against her.
“Shit, you two,” Troy laughed. “People are here.” That snapped her out of it and she pushed back a little, looking up to Zachary’s face. He was looking down at her, a lazy smile on his face. He pulled her head close to his and nibbled her ear. She bit her bottom lip, holding back anymore noise.
“You want it,” he growled softly. “Why deny it?”
“Because I have the problem of wanting every dessert option,” she breathed back. She could barely use words much less make them sound normal. “But it would be wrong to sample them all. On top of that, I’m not going to eat one dessert in front of the others, it is just not okay.”
Every guy in the room started laughing. She wanted to believe the horror movie on was just funny instead of scary. She groaned tried to pull back from Zachary, who laughing harder then she had ever heard. Before she could get away, he rolled his back and made her sit on him. It pushed his cock right up against her and she couldn’t stop another gasp.
“Did you just compare us to a dessert buffet?” Troy giggled hysterically. Gabe couldn’t speak at all from laughing. He looked like he could barely breathe.
Brenton was howling with laughter, unable to look at her and even Andrew was losing it, practically falling off the couch he was on.
“Yup,” she responded with fake confidence. “I did. Got a problem with it?”
“Yeah I do,” Zachary growled seductively. “How do you know you favorite if you don’t sample them all?” He held her hips and pushed up and ground against her. She couldn’t stop the moan that time either. They all stopped laughing at that sound and she watched them all readjust their sweats. The room now smelled like all of them, aroused and not a lick of real jealousy to be found. She could feel the room heat up and her nipples were hard under only her tank, her jacket lost sometime earlier. One of Zachary’s hands roamed up and a thumb swiped over her left nipple. She whimpered, which made every guy in the room growl or groan.
“You can’t all possibly be okay right now,” she gasped, trying to pull off of Zachary. “This is so… perverted and very much not appropriate for-.”
“Most of us have shared women between us,” Brenton cut her off. He stood up and walked over to her spot on top of Zachary. He leaned down to her ear and she couldn’t bring herself to look at him. “You can tell him no, if you really want to. He won’t hold it against you. But I think we all know it’s going to happen eventually.”
She could barely breath, staring down at Zachary. She shook her head slowly.
“I want to but I can’t… not like this,” she whispered to him. The entire situation made her hot and bothered in the best way but she couldn’t summon the courage to do it. It could screw up everything. She couldn’t just fuck her way through all of them. Right? They were supposed to be family and pride. She couldn’t let this be her position in the pride, right?
Zachary groaned and flipped them again. She squealed and landed on her back with him pressed between her legs.
“Are you sure?” He growl, deep and hoarse into her ear. It made her fucking bones vibrate. “We could go up to my room right now.”
She didn’t know really how sure or unsure she was about sleeping with him. She knew she couldn’t do it front of the others, that was for sure. As for the rest, she didn’t want to sleep him and hurt the others. She didn’t want to hurt any of them. They all knew she wanted them and she found out today how much they wanted her. But she didn’t want hurt them, especially sweet Andrew who was probably losing his mind right now.
“I’m not on anything and it’s just been a wold day…” She waved a hand at the others guys in the room. “And I don’t want to ruin the good thing we have going. I don’t want to-”
“Alright,” he whispered. “When you’re ready, let any of us know.” He kissed her then, passionate and wild. His tongue did circles around hers until she moaned from it. “But this is game on, baby. We want you. And we’re going to make sure you know it. All of us and who ever you want or don’t want is your choice. You get the final say but that doesn’t mean we won’t work for it.”
Then he was off her and leaving the room.
“I need a cold shower,” he growled to them as he closed the door.
She laid wide eyed on the couch. This wasn’t what she was expecting from movie night. For three weeks, they had done nothing and now they were all over her. And Zachary of all people had been grinding against her in front of everyone. She had come today for her first shift and run. She hadn’t been planning on Zachary nearly shoving his cock in her in front of the room.
She couldn’t slow her heart rate down, couldn’t take a real breath. Brenton just looked down at her, a mild smile playing on his lips. She just watched him and noticed he was also pitching an impressive tent in his sweats.
“Yes?” She squeaked out. He only chuckled, shaking his head.
“I think we all need cold showers,” he snorted and leaned down and kissed her as well. She gasped after he was done, his gold eye twinkling. “All bets are off now that you know how we feel about you. You’re a good friend, you’re becoming part of this pride and we all want you. Just don’t forget that this goes at your pace. Don’t be afraid to say no whenever you want. Remember, you are in charge of this. Though, you might not want to encourage Zachary like that if you don’t follow through. You’ll give him a heart attack.”
“Why?” she mumbled to him. “Why today?”
“We didn’t want to get hot and heavy until you were in the pride fully. We wanted you to approach the shift with a clear head, not with us panting after you. But now you’ve done it and I won’t hold back anymore and neither will they. We knew you would notice our… physical attraction after you shifted so there’s no pointing in hiding it anymore.”
She watched him leave this time and looked to the other three. The movie was paused and they all watched her. Troy and Gabe were both grinning. Andrew was giving her shy smile.
“You guys can’t be serious?” She gaped at them. “I must be messed up to want you all like this! Right?”
“We not all madly in love with you, it’s much too soon to tell on that front,” Troy laughed, “but we all want some action with you, definitely. We all want you here, in the pride. And Brenton was right. You are a part of this pride. You’ve been a good friend and you didn’t even want us as friends. We can handle it.”
“You’ve been open about everything we’ve thrown at you and,” Andrew sighed, “I can’t even lie and say I was jealous of Zachary just now. It’s hot to see you get worked up like that by someone I trust. I had no idea I could feel that.”
“Yeah, you’re a kinky freak over there, Andrew,” Gabe grinned back at her after that. “Seriously. Troy and I have shared women our entire lives. Brenton and Zachary do it too. Andrew seems to like watching and you think you’re the problem? Damn. People are naturally attracted to loads of different people in their lives. You have a cute boyfriend but still want to fuck the hot celebrity one day? Bam, attracted to more then one person. On a scale of one to ‘that’s fucking weird’ the woman who’s attracted to five guys doesn’t stack up to the five men who all want to share her since we refuse to fight over you.”
She blinked several times as Troy stood up and walked over to her.
“You need a ride home?” He leaned down to her. She knew he and Gabe were the players of the group but the emotion in his eyes at that moment choked her up a little. She lifted up to him and kissed him slowly. He groaned in her mouth, wrapping a hand in her hair. When they finally broke it off, Gabe was there to replace Troy. He pushed her back down into the couch for the kiss, much more aggressive then Troy.
“Andrew will take, if you want to go,” Troy whispered in her right ear as Gabe nibbled the other.
She could see why girls went with both of the brother instead of just one. They worked well together even out of their garage. That was a hot fantasy she definitely should not have been thinking about in that moment.
She nodded and both of them moved away from her. Andrew filled the space they left to go take cold showers. Considering every guy had pitched an impressive tent, she considered her assumption was correct.
“And you?” She laughed softly. “You going to get your one in too?”
He shook his head slowly, smiling at her.
“I’m going to take you home and kiss you there.”
She felt her breath catch at that and Andrew helped her stand up. They left quickly, taking his gunmetal gray pickup. Andrew was speeding more then normal she realized. Was he okay?
“Andr-”
“Yes, I am perfectly fine if you sleep with any of them,” he told her before she could even ask. “I know, it’s weird. But we’re adults. Do you hold your own hook ups against yourself?”
“No,” she mumbled. She had an impressive number of those. Definitely more then five.
“Take your time. The sex and the pride have nothing to do with each other, no one will hold one over you to get the other. Make them buy you dinner first. I know I will if get the chance,” he chuckled. “Speaking of which, do you want to get dinner with me in Denver one night? Just me and you?”
“A date?” She laughed, thinking about the last time she had been on one of those. Years ago, definitely. “Are you asking me on a date, Andrew Hicks? My boss?”
“Yup,” he smiled over to her. He pulled them in front of her apartment and turned the truck off. He didn’t let her answer yet, jumping out to open her side for her. Andrew always did it and she just stopped fighting him over it.
They walked up to her front door and she turned to him, smiling.
“I would like a date, Andrew,” she pulled his head down to her, fusing their lips. He groaned into her mouth and pushed again her door. His tongue teased her and his hands held her hips gently.
When they finally broke off, they were both panting. He watched her and she wondered what he saw.
“Let me come in and take care of you,” he groaned softly in her ear.
She laughed and shook her head.
“Let me get comfortable with idea first. Just twenty minutes ago, I was grinding Zachary’s dick pretty hard. It’s weird. The kissing is easy, more is a bit…”
“It was fucking hot to hear you moan,” he growled. “Fuck, I’m normally more of a gentleman then this. Dinner, a date and we’ll see where it goes. I can text you tomorrow?”
“Sure,” she smiled playfully at him as he stepped back and turned to leave. She watched him go, his sweats having a tent like all the others.
She unlocked her door and decided it was straight to bed with her. Well, feed Star then straight to into bed.
Straight into bed to masturbate maybe. She definitely wouldn’t be able to sleep. She was never move thankful about having a day off. She needed to clear her head.
She wanted it. She wanted all five of them and every piece. And they took her worries out of the equation. They wanted this. They hadn’t led her astray with the shifting stuff yet, maybe she should just jump in on this and see where it went like that.
That sounded like a great idea.