TWENTY-FOUR

KAINE

Maggie's eyes grew as big as saucers as she stared up at me from the altar. 

She looked so innocent with her wide eyes. So pure and beautiful. My cock throbbed hungrily at being the only one to ruin that purity, to make a woman out of her. 

"My ass?" she repeated nervously. 

"Ever had anything in there before?" I asked. 

She shook her head slowly with an anxious bite of her lip. 

I leaned down and kissed her hard, making her lay back flat on the altar as I resumed rubbing her sweet, swollen clit through her panties. 

"You gotta get nice and relaxed for me," I growled into her neck, covering her body with mine as she squirmed. "Best way to do that is to make you come a few times." 

She mewled in reply as her legs quivered around me. I released her clit as the shock waves zipped through her. Her beautiful cheeks flushed and her gorgeous tits heaved on her chest as she sucked in breaths. 

Just as her breathing evened out, I pressed my shaft against her clit and ground my hips against hers. This time she came again in under ten seconds. 

Her panties were absolutely drenched and I would have loved to plunge straight into her tight, sweet pussy, time of the month or not. Not that sex with a woman on her period ever bothered me. It was just an excuse to fuck in the shower, which we would likely do after getting home. 

But right now, I needed to be her first again. 

I couldn't get enough from just her pussy. I needed the dirty, forbidden place where even she hadn't been to herself. 

My soul was already sold by making her mine. And again when I shoved my cock down her throat here in this sacred place. I was beyond saving, sinning without a second thought or regard for this place and I didn't give a fuck.

I shoved her shirt and bra up, pinching those stiff little nipples and made her come a third time by circling my thumb on her clit.

Her eyes closed halfway as her body went completely limp and relaxed. She barely seemed to notice when I pulled her panties down her legs. Her gorgeous pussy quivered, slick with wetness, puffy, and pink from coming so much. I wanted to devour it but knew she was overstimulated in that area already.

Instead, I circled my finger around the tight ring of muscles just below her pussy. Her eyes shot open and she tensed up. 

"It's alright, baby," I told her. "It won't hurt, trust me. Just try to relax." 

She nodded, looking up at me sweetly as I continued just rubbing her tight little asshole, not even pressing inside yet. 

I spat on my finger and pushed the first knuckle inside. She gasped and arched a little, but relaxed as I continued adding saliva for lube and working my finger in and out of her slowly. 

"That... actually feels good," she breathed. Her nipples stiffened into tight little buds again and her pussy was still dripping wet. 

"Ready for my cock in your ass, beautiful?" 

I was so incredibly hard it was almost painful. 

"Yes," she said quickly. 

I loved how eager she was. It just added to this whole hot, taboo scenario of virginal anal sex in a church.

Using a mixture of spit of and precum, I lubed up my cock and pressed the head against her tight hole. 

"Ah!" she cried out and clutched my arms with just the head inside.

Fuck, she was so incredibly, impossibly tight. 

I leaned down over her body and held her to my chest, kissing her neck and her sweet nipples until she relaxed in my arms again. 

"Do you want more, beautiful?" I rasped into the crook of her neck. 

"Yes," she mewled. "Fill up my ass with your cock."

She was already so tight, it took all my control to hold back my heavy load but I pushed forward. 

Inch by slow, torturous inch, with plenty of relubricating and stopping when it got to be too much for her, I was all the way inside her ass. 

"Oh my god," she moaned as I began slow thrusts in and out. "It's so good. You're so fucking big." 

"I love your tight little virgin ass," I growled. "Almost as much as I love your pussy." 

My hand returned to her clit as I worked up a steady rhythm of fucking my sweet girl's ass. She moaned and I felt her muscles clench around me, but not out of pain this time. 

"Your ass and your pussy are both mine, all mine." I bit her nipple as I rubbed her and fucked her, making her cry echo off the high ceilings and stained glass. "No one else has been here but me and no one ever will be." 

"No one but you," she repeated after me in a whimper. Tears streamed down her cheeks but her face wore an expression of pure orgasmic bliss as she looked up at me. "Kaine, you're the only one for me." 

I couldn't hold back anymore. 

I let out a roar as my release took over my whole body like an exorcism. My cum shot deep into her ass which only made her wrap tighter around me from her own orgasm. 

We barely had time to catch our breath and relish in the most intimate, dirty, and wonderfully forbidden moment of our lives when we heard the creak of door hinges. 

Fuck! No one else was supposed to be here! 

I tucked my cock back into my boxer briefs and tried to zip up as fast as I could. Maggie pulled her bra and shirt back into place but couldn't hide that she was naked from the waist down. 

"Wow! This'll make a fortune if I sell it to a porn company!" 

The creaky side door opened up all the way to reveal the last two people either of us wanted to see. 

Rachel, holding her fucking phone out again with another smug grin that I wanted to smack off her face. 

"Don't worry!" she chirped. "I took a video this time and already backed it up to the cloud." 

And next to her, silent but beet-red and scowling, Maggie's mother.