Chapter 5
Casey was thankful and surprised at the same time that her mom and stepdad never realized that something odd was going on between her and Paul. Maybe they were just completely oblivious to this whole thing? Surely not, there were times where it was super awkward but no one would comment on it. Possibly for the sake of not embarrassing the other or something along those lines, she wasn’t sure.
Paul was beginning to find it harder to not focus on Casey either. Every time she just moved, his eyes would be on her body, whether to watch her ass and hips sway or her breasts jiggle if he was lucky. He knew that if he didn’t start being careful, she was going to notice or his dad was going to say something about why he was hard.
That afternoon, Paul’s dad texted him and said that him and his stepmom were going out for the night and wouldn’t be home until that next morning. He didn’t give many details but it gave Paul the perfect window of time to figure out what was exactly going on between him and Casey.
“Casey, mom and dad are going out tonight!” he called from upstairs as he waited for her to reply.
“Okay!” she called back as she felt her heart thundering in her chest. Tonight was the night she would get to seduce her “brother” and figured out if he liked her or was even slightly attracted. Casey wanted desperately to think that he did, but it was possible that he wouldn’t but she refused to believe that until she had her proof.
Paul decided to head downstairs so they could discuss the plans for tonight. For all he knew she may be hanging out with friends or something.
“Are you busy later?” he asked while trying to keep his eyes on hers.
“Nope, I figured I would just go out or stay in… I kinda want to get drunk,” she giggled while trying to see if he would take the bait or not.
“Well I vote for staying in then,” he winked before looking for his wallet, “but first let me go get the alcohol. Mom and dad wouldn’t appreciate if we drank from their stash I think.”
“True,” she stood up and followed her brother out to his car, not bothering to hide her gaze as she examined his muscular back and ass.
“Do you want anything in particular?” he asked when they got in the car and began driving off.
“Something strong but fruity?” she asked innocently as Paul felt his cock stir. The way she was looking at him was making him hard enough to fuck her right there in the car. If only he could get her to suck him off…
“I’ll see what I can find for ya,” he teased her while returning his thoughts and mind towards the road. This wasn’t the time or place for him to be distracted.
About two hours later the siblings found themselves laughing their asses off at some videos that were playing on the television that made no sense. However they were too drunk to comprehend what was going on really, other than the fact that there was indeed an electrical current running between the two of them.
“Hey Case?” Paul asked again for the thousandth time as he would try to crack a joke but epically failed as Casey continued to crack up anyways since her brain wasn’t exactly at its top performance.
“Not another one Paul,” she drawled out his name while he chuckled and threw his hands up.
“Okay, no more then,” he rested his arm on the couch, letting his fingers brush against her bare shoulder.
Casey shuddered internally, she enjoyed the feeling of his skin on hers… now was the time to make the move before they became anywhere near being sober.
“Paul,” she began slightly hesitant. “Do you think I’m pretty?”
Paul felt his breath catch while feeling the haziness slowly disappear from his thinking. Of course he thought his sister was pretty, she was absolutely gorgeous! Why would she ask him that? Was it a security thing?
“Of course Casey, any guy would be lucky to have you,” he smiled gently and played with a strand of her hair.
“Prove it,” she pressed gently.
“How?” he looked confused, “do you want me to hook you up with one of my friends? I’m not kidding about you being beautiful.”
“No,” she shook her head and scooted closer to him as she stared into his eyes. “I just want you to prove to me by yourself that I am.”
“How,” he stuttered while feeling his cock harden as she shifted into his lap, giving him a good view of her cleavage.
“However you want,” she breathed gently and pressed her lips to his gently while tangling her fingers in his hair.
“Case,” he breathed against her while pressing his lips to hers again. He had wanted to feel her lips for the longest time now.
“Shh,” she shushed him and breathed, “just keep going.”
He took that as his cue and slipped her shirt off in a frenzy before kneading her breasts through her blue bra that she had on. He wanted desperately to pull it off and see her breasts again like that day when she had finished showering, but the quicker he moved the clumsier he became.
Casey helped and pulled off her bra and his shirt within seconds while kissing him yet again. He moaned while grabbing her breasts within his hands and kneading them harder. God to feel this flesh within his palms was more than enough for him to explode within his pants. He needed to control himself better if he wanted to go further with her.
“Strip for me,” he breathed against her as she shook with delight and stood up to flip her hair behind her while sliding her shorts down slow.
Paul groaned as he wasted no time in pulling his pants down and pumping his seven inch cock that was begging to be released.
“Wow,” she breathed while sliding her thong off, revealing her lips that were completely bare except for a small patch of hair on top.
“God, I’ve been dying to see the front of you for so long,” he breathed and pulled her back towards him as he began to suck her pink nipples within his mouth.
“Paul,” Casey gasped as she felt his tongue envelop her nipple and flick it gently. She began to wrap her hands around his cock and pump furiously, feeling herself leaking onto his legs as he continued to suck her skin.
They were both thinking the same thing as he released her breasts reluctantly and kissed her for a brief moment.
“May I?” he whispered while feeling her cunt gently with his fingers.
“I need it now,” she whined as he pushed her down onto the couch and spread her legs.
Her core was pulsing as he stared at it mesmerized, how could he be so lucky to get an opportunity like this?
Casey growled, while trying to push him to place his cock inside her. She wanted to know what it would feel like to have his thick meat inside, rubbing against her walls.
Paul kissed her again slowly, while rubbing his cock up against her slippery entrance. “Slow baby,” he whispered as she moaned quietly.
“You like that?” he teased her while sliding it in slowly as her back arched.
“Yes,” she groaned and thrusted harder as he slid in completely and remained still for a split second before pulling out and slamming back in.
Casey gasped before shutting her eyes and letting the pleasure roll over her body and creating a rhythm with him.
Paul began to thrust faster while grabbing her ass and pulling her in harder. He wanted her to feel all of him inside her.
“I’ve… wanted you since… I saw you drop the… towel when you… finished… showering,” he huffed as he continued to pound in and out of her.
Casey blushed bright red as she remembered that day like it was yesterday. She had been so embarrassed at the time, but now knowing that Paul had found her so attractive washed away all her fears.
“I’ve… wanted you since… we kissed…” she panted as he slowed down gently and looked at her with adoration.
Pressing his lips to hers again, he whispered, “me too,” and pulled out as he exploded all over the floor with Casey writhing in pleasure on the couch.
“We’re a mess,” she giggled when she finally came down from her high.
Paul agreed and quickly began to clean up before their parents would ever realize what would happen. No one could know.