My attempt to clarify my position with Rory failed spectacularly. And I can’t say I’m surprised. Rory always had a way of calling me out on my bullshit, even if she was completely oblivious to the biggest lie I ever told her. Actually, it was the biggest lie I’ve ever told anyone.

The truth: Hallie left a suicide note. The bigger truth: That note is the reason Rory and I got together. And the biggest, most despicable truth of all is the one conveyed to me, and only me, in that suicide note. Hallie’s last words.

I know most people wouldn’t understand it. And most people would be absolutely disgusted with me for what I did to Rory. But the truth is that I allowed my loyalty to my sister to eclipse my loyalty to the only girl I’ve ever loved. The only girl I may ever love.

So when I come out of the bathroom with sweat beaded on my chest and a towel wrapped around my waist, I’m a little disgusted—not just with myself—to see Tessa checking me out. She’s lying on the bed with her phone hovering above her. When we first started living together, I loved watching her in this position because inevitably she would drop the phone on her forehead. It’s one of her cuter quirks.

Today, I find myself wishing she’d drop the phone on her face just so she’ll stop staring at my body. I’m a bad person. I know that. But I can’t help wishing it were Rory lying in my bed.

“Hey, handsome,” Tessa purrs as I open the top drawer of our dresser and pull out a pair of gray boxer briefs.

“Hey, baby.”

I shed the towel and toss it onto the chair by the window, then I pull on the boxers.

“I don’t think you’re gonna need those tonight.”

I turn around and she’s casting her best come-hither expression in my direction. I try to see Tessa the way I saw her three days ago, as my hot, blonde twenty-six-year-old wife. The woman who gave me a distraction from the painful memories when I thought they would consume me. But all I see when I look at her is two words flashing in bold letters: NOT RORY.

I smile at Tessa and squint my eyes a bit to return her sexy glare. “Is that an invitation?”

The words feel wrong and misshapen in my mouth. Like I’m rehearsing lines from a movie script.

“Do you need an invitation?”

She lays her phone down on the nightstand and I know there’s no getting out of this. A man can’t refuse sex the way a woman can. And, of course, I am only a man. I also have needs. I can’t save myself for Rory when there’s probably zero chance she’ll ever take me back.

I push down my boxers and kick them off as I climb onto the bed. She giggles as I slide between her legs, placing my hands on each side of her head as I lean down to kiss her. She tastes like toothpaste and betrayal.

I reach down and hastily pull off her panties and she yelps. “Hey! Take it easy, tiger.”

Sliding my hand behind her nape, I pull her head to the side, exposing her neck, then I suck hard on her pale flesh. She pushes me back.

“What are you doing? You’re gonna leave a mark.”

“Sorry.” I push up on my hands and look down at her, trying to convey the hunger in my eyes. “Turn around.”

She gazes into my eyes, trying to figure out what’s going on with me, but she decides not to question it. She flips over onto her belly and I wrap my arm around her middle to lift her up onto all fours.

Doggy-style is a primal sex position. It’s the position we perfected as apes and we carried it with us when we became human. I think this is probably why so many women are opposed to it. When sex became less about procreation and more about emotional connection, women lost their love for doggy-style.

Now women want to look into your eyes when you come. They want to imprint the image of their face in your memory at that climactic moment so you associate their visage with your ultimate desire. It’s all a psychological game.

Tessa doesn’t like doggy-style, but she tolerates it because I like it. The worst part is that she’d be right in assuming I’m imagining someone else when I fuck her from behind.

I slide the tip of my cock over her clit a few times to get her extra wet, then I glide into her. “Fuck,” I hiss through gritted teeth.

I close my eyes and try not to picture Rory as I slide in and out of Tessa, but all I can think is how Rory’s cheeks were softer and creamier and how much I’d rather be buried inside her right now. I have to stop this. I’m coveting that which I cannot have.

I open my eyes and focus on Tessa’s body. I lean forward, sliding my hand under her tank top to grab her breast. She looks back at me over her shoulder and I feel myself getting strangely annoyed by the look on her face. Letting go of her breast, I stand up straight again and grab her hips to drive her harder. But she keeps looking at me.

I close my eyes and force myself to think of anything other than Rory. First, I think about work, and visions of brew tanks and bags of barley and hops flash in my mind. Then I think of my office and suddenly I remember that box I have hidden in the closet of my office.

I open my eyes to clear away this memory. My thrusts are slow and deliberate as I try to focus on anything but Rory and her soft, pliant body laid out beneath me. I try not to think of the perfect fit of my mouth on hers. Or the time we became parents for two seconds. Then it was over.

When I took Rory home, after she had the abortion, I waited until she had slept off the sedative. Then I waited until she had washed up, pretending not to hear the aching song of her cries in the shower. Then I waited some more, until she had eaten solid food and fallen asleep. Then I left.

I’ve been waiting five years to tell her the truth. The truth about Hallie. The truth about why we were together. And, most of all, the truth about how I’ve never stopped loving her. I’m tired of waiting.

I pound Tessa from behind, completely oblivious as to whether or not she’s actually enjoying herself. All I can see and hear over my blinding memories of Rory is the vague curve of Tessa’s hips and the faint sound of her moans. Whether those are cries of pain or ecstasy I don’t know.

Because even if those are cries of ecstasy, Tessa will still find a way to complain. No matter how many times I fuck her senseless. No matter how many times I make her come so hard she cries real tears. No matter what, it will never be enough unless I fuck her with the intention of making a baby.

I told Tessa from the beginning of our relationship that I don’t want children. But she was undeterred. She probably convinced herself that she could change my mind.

I will never change my mind about wanting children with Tessa. And the reason is simple: I don’t want to have to choose.

If Rory ever wanted to give me a second chance, I wouldn’t want to choose between her and my children. And I know it’s crazy to risk losing my wife over something that may never happen—will almost certainly never happen—but I can’t bring children into my life when I’m still living a lie.

My cock twitches and I pull out of Tessa. She waits as I come on her ass, then I grab a tissue off the nightstand and quickly wipe it off. She turns over and narrows her eyes at me. I know what she’s thinking.

I always come inside her. She has an IUD implanted in her uterus, which means she has less than half of one percent chance of getting pregnant. Not a single pregnancy has been reported with the use of this particular IUD, so I’ve always been quite happy to release my load inside her. But I can’t bring myself to do it tonight.

Rory was on birth control when she got pregnant. And I know a .05 percent failure rate on this IUD means it’s basically impossible for the same thing to happen with Tessa, but I can’t take the chance anymore. I won’t take the chance anymore.

“Why did you do that?” she asks as I climb off the bed and head for the door.

“Do what?”

“You know what.”

I keep walking into the corridor. “I don’t know what you’re talking about.”

I make it to the kitchen and manage to pour myself a glass of cold water before she catches up with me. Her panties are back on and her face is contorted in disbelief.

“Are you fucking someone else?”

This wouldn’t be the first time Tessa has accused me of having an affair with absolutely no evidence. I’m pretty certain she does it just to remind me how much I don’t want to end up like my father. But this tactic isn’t going to work with me tonight.

“What?” I reply calmly, placing the empty glass in the sink.

“You heard me. Are you fucking someone else?”

I let out a soft chuckle as I shake my head. “I didn’t come inside you, so now I’m having a fucking affair? What if I happened to read an article on the ineffectiveness of IUDs today? Nope. Right away you jump to the worst fucking conclusion.”

She gets in my face. “Did you read an article on IUDs today?”

I roll my eyes as I try to step around her, but she blocks my path. “No. No, I didn’t. Are you happy now?”

Her gaze falls to my chest and she swallows hard. “I think I’m gonna be sick.”

I sigh as I grab her face. “Tessa, I’m not cheating on you. I’m just… I’m sorry.”

She looks into my eyes. “Sorry for what?”

What am I supposed to say? I’m sorry for not coming inside you… I’m sorry for fantasizing about someone else while I was fucking you.

I’m sorry I never loved you.

“I’m sorry for being in a shitty mood. It’s not your fault. I’m just stressed about this new contract.” I pull her face to mine and kiss her softly on the lips. “I love you. Come to bed and we’ll do it right this time.”

She lets out a soft sigh as her shoulders slump with defeat. She nods and I take her hand as I lead her back to the bedroom for round two. I’ll let her win this one.