Chapter Fourteen

Isaac

––––––––

The next morning, waking up with Cody wrapped around my body and Jonah pressed up against his was amazing. Other than Cody and my platonic sleepovers, I hadn’t actually shared a bed with someone since my last boyfriend, and he hadn’t been much of a cuddler. I’d almost forgotten how wonderful it was to feel warm skin against mine as I drifted out of sleep, and having Cody’s morning wood poking my leg was pretty awesome.

I was used to getting up at or before dawn for work, so it wasn’t surprising that I was awake before the others. Instead of moving, I settled against the pillows and pulled Cody a little tighter against my body as I thought about last night.

It had been incredible.

Being with Cody, feeling his body beneath mine, his hot and tight channel around my cock, and seeing his eyes as he looked up at me in wonder was something I’d remember for the rest of my life.

I’d dreamed of making love to him more times than I cared to remember, but my dreams couldn’t even begin to compare to reality. It had been fucking amazing, and a part of me still couldn’t believe it had finally happened.

Then there’d been the other amazing part— watching Jonah and Cody together. I knew exactly how Cody felt during their encounter because I’d felt it with Jonah too. His hard, passionate kisses that left you breathless. The way he looked at you like you were the only man in the world, and how he could own your body while still being gentle.

I didn’t know what I’d done to deserve having even one incredible man in my life, and now I had two.

After trying to get back to sleep for almost an hour, I decided to get up and make some coffee. It was almost nine so it wasn’t too early, and I was hoping the caffeine buzz might jump-start another session of sexual exploration.

I carefully untangled myself from Cody’s arms and crawled out of bed. I found my briefs on the floor and slid them on before pulling my phone out of my pants pocket. I had a text from Noah telling me to enjoy my night. I’d told him I probably wouldn’t be home before Jonah had come to pick me up.

I put my phone on the dresser and headed down to the kitchen to see if I could figure out Jonah’s coffee machine.

Thankfully he had ones of those single cup ones that used coffee pods, and only one type of coffee so there was no guesswork involved. I turned the machine on and made myself a cup, adding some milk and sugar, and then sat down at the kitchen table to drink it.

There was something about early morning silence I’d always found soothing. Just having a few minutes to myself to sit and enjoy my coffee as I prepared myself for the day was a ritual I’d gotten into while still in high school. I was an early riser by nature, while Noah would happily stay up all night and sleep all day. Mom hadn’t been home much when we were teenagers, preferring to spend her nights over at her then boyfriend, now husband’s place, so mornings had become my sanctuary.

After finishing my coffee I washed out the cup and turned the coffee machine back on. I made two more cups, adding sugar and cream to Cody’s and milk and honey to Jonah’s, and brought the cups upstairs to my men.

It seemed the smell of fresh coffee was more effective than any alarm clock, and both men stirred the moment I came into the room.

“Morning.” I leaned against the dresser, watching as Jonah and Cody sat up, rubbing their eyes and getting their bearings.

“Morning.” Jonah smiled and reached out to me.

I went to him, giving him a quick kiss before handing him his coffee.

“Morning.” I turned to Cody, accepting a kiss from his seeking lips as I gave him his cup.

“How long have you been up?” Cody asked as I sat on the edge of the bed, making sure not to jostle them about.

“A while. I figured you guys would appreciate the caffeine.”

“And the view.” Cody winked at me and I laughed. I liked this new, confident side of him. 

“Definitely the view.” Jonah nodded in agreement, sipping his drink. “This is exactly how I like it.” He gave me a surprised look. “How did you know?”

“You mentioned it while we were talking one night. You said Open Arms had run out of honey so you had to use sugar with your milk and it hadn’t tasted right.”

“You’re so sweet.” Jonah put his hand over mine, linking our fingers together for a moment as he squeezed my hand.

As the men drank their coffees we talked about the rest of our day. None of us were working and we wanted to spend it together, but didn’t have any inclination to go out and do anything. Instead we decided to stay in and watch movies, and it was Cody who declared it a clothes-free day.

Now that he’d broken through whatever had held him back from intimacy, Cody was insatiable. Jonah had barely finished his coffee before Cody was shoving their cups in my hands and climbing on Jonah’s lap to kiss him.

I’d put the cups aside and climbed in to join them, pressing against their sides as we shared sloppy and deep kisses, turning between each other in our haste to make sure no one was left untouched for more than a few seconds.

At one point Jonah had held Cody’s face still and kissed the side of his mouth. I’d taken my cue from him and kissed the other side, and the three of us had been able to share long, deep three-way kisses.

When kissing wasn’t enough Jonah had taken both Cody and I in his hands and jacked us off while I’d stroked Jonah’s thick cock at the same rhythm.

Cody was the one who’d stopped us, begging to get fucked again. Jonah had flipped him onto his hands and knees and used the lube I handed him to open Cody up while I rolled a condom onto his cock. As Jonah had pushed inside Cody’s tight body I’d slipped underneath Cody and lined my mouth up with his dick so I could suck him as he was getting fucked.

The dual sensations seemed to be too much for Cody to reciprocate and suck me as well, but the hand he moved over my cock was enough to bring me to the edge of orgasm. I’d swallowed Cody all the way down, holding still so he ended up fucking my mouth every time Jonah thrust inside him.

Cody and Jonah had come at the same time, and I’d gone over only seconds later.

We’d wiped up and cuddled for a while before climbing into the shower to cleanup, and again, Cody had other ideas.

After a few moments of kissing he’d dropped to his knees in front of Jonah and taken him into his mouth. I would have been happy to watch them as I jerked off, but seeing the ecstasy on both of their faces made me want to join in and give pleasure to both of my men.

I’d knelt behind Jonah, using one hand to split him open so I could rim him while reaching between his legs to jerk Cody off. I loved hearing Jonah’s sounds of pleasure as we both teased him, the way he’d called out our names as Cody had moaned around Jonah’s cock.

Jonah had come with a shout, spilling down Cody’s throat as he greedily swallowed every drop, and only seconds later Cody’s cum had splashed over my hand as his orgasm hit.

My cock was aching with need, so I’d started to jerk off while my men recuperated, but they were having none of that. Jonah had pulled me to my feet as Cody had grabbed my cock so he could swallow me down. At the same moment his chin had rested against my balls Jonah’s slick finger had pressed inside me, instantly finding my prostate so he could massage it.

The sensations swirling around inside me had been so strong I’d come in less than a minute, my legs giving out as I’d shouted in pleasure. Jonah had held me up as Cody had swallowed my release, and then the three of us were holding each other and kissing again.

We’d spent the rest of the day alternating between watching action movies and fooling around. It had all been hot and incredible, but the moment that stood out to me was when the three of us had been sitting on the couch after dinner. Cody and I had curled up against Jonah’s sides as he’d held us. We’d talked for hours, ignoring the movie that was playing as we’d told each other stories from our pasts and about our plans for the future.

Saying goodbye had been hard. I’d wanted to stay in our little bubble for just one more day, but it was the start of a new work week and we had to get back to our own schedules.

I hated that we had so little time together, but I was grateful for what we did get.

As I lay in bed, listening to the music coming from Noah’s room, I thought about my men. I was in love with both of them. I might have loved Cody longer, but my feelings weren’t any less strong for Jonah. I needed both of them, and I couldn’t imagine one of them not being a part of my life. I hated to think about it, but I would never choose between them. If Cody or Jonah decided to walk away I would be devastated, but I would still want to be with the other. They were my future, and I needed to make sure they knew just how important they were to me, and how much we all needed each other.

* * * * *

After a near sleepless night I decided that I needed to put a plan into action. On one level I knew relationships should develop organically and that you couldn’t force something that wasn’t meant to be, but that didn’t mean you couldn’t give it a little nudge in the direction you hoped it would end up.

That week on the site we were working on flooring, and it was my job to install the floors the client had paid for. My days were spent on my hands and knees lining up slats of ridiculously expensive hardwood and hammering and nailing them in place. It was monotonous and tedious, and gave me way too much time to think.

The job was wrapping up next week and my hours were getting cut. I’d worked it out with one of the other guys on the crew that I’d take the second half of the shift and he’d take the first. So for a week I’d be working from eleven until four instead of my usual six a.m. start.

On Wednesday I called Cody and told him my plan. He was excited, and by Friday we had everything set. Now it was time to let Jonah in on it.

* * * * *

“Cody? Isaac?” Jonah looked between us as we stood on his front step on Friday night.

“Hello.” I grinned at the expression on his face. It was halfway between surprised and aroused, and it was sexy as fuck.

“I wasn’t expecting you.” He stepped back to let us in. “I’m thrilled, just surprised.”

“We made a decision,” I informed him as we all sat on his couch in our usual position with Jonah between us.

“Oh? And am I going to like this decision?” He looked between us, a curious smile on his lips.

“I think so.” Cody put his hand on Jonah’s thigh and I felt my cock thicken as he squeezed Jonah’s tight muscles.

“Then please share.”

“We need to spend more time together, so we made that happen.” I put my hand on Jonah’s other thigh, loving how powerful and strong he was. “Next week I’m working half shifts since the job is almost done, and I worked it out so I’m getting the afternoons.”

“Interesting.” Jonah put his hand over mine, linking our fingers together.

“And I switched shifts with Blaze today so I’m done for the night, and Evan scheduled me for all day shifts next week.”

“Really?” Jonah grabbed Cody’s hand and looked between us.

“Really.” Cody nodded, smiling broadly. “I already had tomorrow and Sunday off, so we have all weekend together, and next week we’re on the same schedules.”

Jonah leaned forward and kissed Cody, his tongue sweeping between Cody’s lips as he immediately deepened it. Cody’s moan went straight to my dick, and I had to actively stop myself from grabbing my erection as I watched them.

Jonah broke the kiss with Cody and turned to me. His lips were hot and the kiss was hard. I wanted things to keep going and have both of them right there on the couch, but I was starved, and I knew Cody was too.

There would be plenty of time for fucking, we had the whole weekend together.

* * * * *

We ended up ordering Chinese food and watching a movie as we ate on the couch. Cody and I had each packed a bag of clothes and personal items, hoping that Jonah would be on board with our plan and want us to stay with him. I would have loved to have them at my place, but I had Noah to think about, and Cody’s apartment was too small.

Jonah had a house and a Queen-sized bed, and he hadn’t had an issue with us being over before. It might have been a little presumptuous to think he’d want the time as much as we did, but I was glad we’d gone through with the plan because he seemed as excited as we were.

When our food was done and the containers were cleaned up, we relaxed on the couch and put on a movie. Cody lay down with his head on Jonah’s lap as Jonah gently rubbed his scalp, and I curled up against Jonah’s side as he held me close. As soon as he’d laid down, Cody had reached behind him for my hand and I’d linked our fingers together and held on throughout the movie.

When the credits were rolling I moved so Jonah could reach the remote and turn off the TV. When everything was shut down he leaned forward to give me a sweet kiss.

“How about I drive you boys home so you can grab some clothes for the weekend? I’d say wear mine, but I don’t think they’d fit too well.”

I laughed as he bent down to kiss Cody.

“Yeah, not so much.”

Jonah was four inches taller than Cody and two taller than me. He also had at least fifty pounds of muscle and bulk on Cody, and while we had similar builds Jonah was definitely broader. I might be able to wear his clothes in a pinch, but they’d be big on me. On Cody, they’d be huge.

Picturing Cody in Jonah’s clothes, with pants falling off him as a shirt hung down like a dress sent a new wave of giggles through me, and before I could stop myself I was laughing so hard tears sprang into my eyes.

Jonah stared at me like I was crazy, but Cody joined right in, holding his stomach and rolling onto his side as he gasped for air and laughed with me.

“What did I miss?” Jonah asked when I stopped laughing long enough to pull in a few shallow breaths, wiping tears from the corner of my eyes as I did.

“Sorry, nothing.”

“You guys are about to split in two from laughing so hard... what is it?”

“Just Cody, in your clothes... so big... like wearing bad hand me downs—” I snorted as another burst of laughter bubbled out of me, sending Cody into another fit as well.

This time Jonah laughed with us, and it wasn’t until my sides and stomach were aching and I could barely breathe that I was able to stop.

“Oh fuck that hurts!” Cody gasped, his hands on his stomach as he shook his head. “Ow.”

“I haven’t laughed like that in a long time.” Jonah cleared his throat and glanced over at me, his eyes twinkling. “Remind me never to mention sharing clothes again.”

I bit back a snort of laughter. There was no way in hell I was starting that again. My stomach wouldn’t survive.

“Deal.” I pulled in one more deep breath and sighed. It still hurt, but at least now the giggles had passed. “We actually brought our own stuff. You know, just in case you wanted us to stick around.”

Jonah grinned and pulled me toward him for a kiss. “I definitely want you around.”

“You know what I want?” Cody asked suddenly, grinning up at us.

“What’s that?” I braced myself for some sort of crazy food request. Cody was notorious from having strange cravings at the weirdest times.

“Chocolate covered pretzels.”

“Now that does sound good.” I leaned down and gave Cody a quick upside-down kiss.

“I’m in the mood for something sweet and salty.” He winked and Jonah and I chuckled.

“As good as that sounds, I’m afraid I don’t have any on hand.” Jonah said regretfully.

“I’ll go pick some up,” I offered. “I’ll bring our bags in when I come back.”

“Are you sure?” Jonah asked.

“Yeah. Believe it or not this is one of his tamer requests. The last time he had a craving he sent me out for banana chips and salted caramel candy.”

“Don’t give me any ideas or I’m going to have to send you out with a list.” Cody grinned.

“Yeah. On that note, I’m out.” I leaned in to kiss Jonah and then dropped a quick kiss on Cody’s forehead. “I’ll be right back.

“When you get back and our boy’s stomach is satisfied, I have a surprise for you,” Jonah said cryptically.

“Really?” I paused and glanced over my shoulder as I stood. “Intriguing.”

Jonah just gave me a casual smile and leaned back against the couch, his hand threading in Cody’s hair as they both stared at me.

Shaking my head I hurried out to my car, very curious to find out what Jonah was talking about.