THEO

 

Fuck, she was perfect.

 

My cock sprang to life just having Penny in my arms. But, what a fucking idiot I was for not having a single condom anywhere around. I should have my man card revoked for life. Fuck. I craved her though. And I wouldn’t stop until I had my cock deep inside her… ass.

“Lose the fucking panties and hop on my lap.” I spoke low, as I thought about claiming her ass.

I’d been wanting to fuck her there for some time, and couldn’t wait to get inside her. She straddled me, facing me with her tits in my face as I stroked my cock with one hand. “I’m going to do evil things to this ass, baby.” I grabbed one ass cheek firm in my grip.

Her eyes widened as I grabbed the back of her neck and brought her closer. “But I won’t hurt you. We’ll go slow. You’re going to come so hard. Do you trust me?”

“Yeah,” she whispered. “Do it, I need to feel you.”

Crashing my lips to hers, I reached down and felt the wetness from her warm pussy and coated my fingers in it. “Fuck, Penny. You’re so wet. All of this sweetness for me?”

Her hips grinded against me making me want to bury myself in her pussy. “Only for you,” she whispered. God, I missed the way her voice sounded when she was turned on and hungry for me.

I plunged my teeth into her sweet skin, just atop her right breast, marking her. She gasped when I slid a finger inside her. Fuck it felt good to have my finger in her tight cunt. My cock throbbed with need, so fucking strong I couldn’t hold off any longer. “Relax, baby.”

I rubbed my cock along her pussy, coating it in her essence, and brought the tip to her ass, pushing slightly. Her pussy was so wet; no lube was needed. I kept coating my cock with her wetness. She dropped her head to my shoulder, her teeth sinking into my skin.

“Oh God, Theo,” she moaned as I kept pushing. It took everything I had not to thrust inside her ass. It felt too fucking good. My thighs trembled from the effort of holding back.

Our groans mingled when she rocked her hips and the head of my cock slipped inside. My head fell back against the seat, and I watched as she worked her way down on me. I dipped my fingers in her wetness and coated my cock with it. “You want more?” I asked, circling her clit and then slipping a second finger inside her. Her pussy would be the death of me.

“I want it all,” she said. I fucked her with my fingers as her ass slid slow and easy down my cock. A low groan rumbled from deep inside as she took me in further. “Penny, your ass is so tight.”

Heaven, the pearly gates, was the place I was headed with each inch she buried herself on me. With her hands on my chest, she slid down my cock.

“Now fuck me,” she said.

The way she demanded it made my cock pulse. I gripped her hips and thrust up into her. Goddamn. So hot and tighter than I could handle. “Touch your pussy, Penny. Rub your wetness on your nipple and then put it in my mouth.” She slid her hand down and then rubbed her fingertips across before bringing her nipple to my lips. My tongue circled and licked before sucking it into my mouth. “Fuck, I love to taste you.”

With each stroke into her ass, my orgasm threatened to explode. Her pants and moans drove me faster and harder into her. I could barely fucking breathe it felt so good. “Beg me for it, Penny. Beg me to come in your ass.”

“Please, Theo,” she murmured, her eyes locking with mine. “Ah, it feels so good.”

God, I was so fucking turned on. I played with her wet cunt as I fucked her in the ass, and she moaned into my mouth over and over.

Her pussy tasted so good, I took my wet fingers and smeared them on her tits again, sucking and licking her pussy-coated skin.

“I love fucking your ass, Penny, fuck,” I groaned.

Watching her body slide along mine, her hips grinding, and her slick pussy taking my fingers all the way in was more than I could bear.

“Keep riding, baby, fuck, grind that tight ass on my cock,” I said, my voice husky with lust.

My cock was ready to shoot off inside her, my orgasm right around the corner. She picked up her pace, riding my body like she owned it. And she did.

With my free hand, I pinched her nipple and brought my lips to suck her full breast into my mouth. She held onto me as if her life depended on it as my cock sank deeper into her tight ass. I missed this girl. I missed her more than I wanted to admit.

Her sexy moans echoed off the car interior, and my body grew closer to climax. Sucking. Rubbing. Biting. I couldn't hold back much longer but my body tried its hardest to ward the need to come for a while longer. I needed more of her. Not wanting this moment to end, I kept calling out her name. “I’ve missed this pussy, Penny,” I said as my hand went faster.

“I’m going to come.” Her voice rang through the car.

I didn’t care we were in a parking lot, or in my car for that matter. The only thing important to me right now was getting off inside her.

“That’s right, come on my fingers. Come baby, I want to feel it dripping down my hand.” I went deeper, crooking my finger inside her to reach the spot I knew would make her explode. She screamed unintelligible words before her teeth sank into my shoulder.

Her pussy tightened around my fingers as her body trembled. It only made me go faster, determined to come as hard as I could.

“Fuck, baby. Your ass is so hot. I love your fucking body. I can’t stop staring at your tits.” I gazed into her eyes. “Your tits are getting fucked next.” I removed my fingers from inside her and grabbed her face with both hands. “I fucking own you,” I said right before kissing her.

It wasn’t an innocent kiss. It was one full of tongues and hot moans. The passion dwelling in the kiss made her body shake and shiver. I ached for this girl.

My body climbed higher as my orgasm neared. I wanted to tell her I loved her. But, clamped down the idea, chalking it off as a bad decision. My heart banged against my rib cage, fighting with my brain to say the words. “Penny,” I said after breaking the kiss.

“Theo, I need you.” Her eyes told me more and I hoped she felt the same.

My hands flew to her hair, twisting and pulling, as my cock throbbed deep inside her. “Oh fuck, Penny.” My muscles clenched right before my orgasm ripped through me. It wouldn’t stop as I kept pumping inside her tight ass.

 

*** 

 

Having Penny in my arms felt right. She was mine again, well, sort of. We still had the issue of her being engaged to my half-brother. Furthermore, we were no closer to coming to any conclusion about her father. A time machine would be cool, so I could travel back to the first night I met Penny and do things over. I wouldn’t let her leave me afterward. And, of course, I would have never bought the fucking Goat.

There was nothing I could do, and I just needed to get my head in the game and figure shit out.

After kissing Penny goodbye, we both headed to the Lopa. As I stepped inside, I felt better about her feelings for me. Some of the hurting had subsided, and I knew we could get through this.

The morning rush helped distract me from thinking of her engagement but only for a little while. Once my break came, I ducked outside to call Xavier.

“Do you still have that P.I. friend? The one who investigates offshore accounts?” I asked.

“Yeah, Steve Bobson. Need his number?”

“Sure.”

“Does this have to do with Pardo?”

“Doesn’t everything?”

He laughed. “Yeah, I guess so.”

“Thanks, man,” I said after getting the number.

Penny found me around the side of the building just as I hung up the phone.

“Hey, I was wondering where you ran off to.”

“Just got off the phone with Xavier. Got the number to a P.I. Hopefully he can help us out.”

“Nice. Can I ask you a question?”

“Sure.”

“Am I a bad daughter? I mean, if we’re right he could go to prison.” She chewed on her thumbnail as her big eyes met mine with a glint of worry engrained in the tawny color.

“Let’s hope so.” Oh shit, maybe I said the wrong thing, judging by the crestfallen expression on her cute face. I wrapped one arm around her, pulling her against my side, kissing the top of her head. I let go and stepped back to meet her eyes, with both hands on her shoulders. “Sorry, listen, your father hasn’t been a very good one. No one should ever force their daughter into something they don’t want to do. I would never do that to Lucy.”

She smiled at me. “You’re a great dad.”

My face heated as I rubbed along the back of my neck. “Thanks.”

“Now get back to work,” she said, slapping me on the ass.

“Oh, that’ll cost you later.” I laughed as I walked away and headed back into the bar. I couldn’t wait to get ahold of Xavier’s friend. It was getting late, so I didn’t want to call after business hours.

Wiping the bar, my phone vibrated in my pocket.

Glancing down to the caller ID, I let out a deep breath. Fuck.

“Hi, Mom. Yeah, been a long time.”

My mother started in on not seeing Lucy enough, and after ten minutes she brought up Dex.

“I know you and him don’t see eye to eye…”

“It’s a lot more than that, Mom. He’s an asshole,” I barked out after excusing myself from the bar and heading back outside into the Florida heat.

“But, he’s getting married. And, he even told me he wants you there.” Her high-pitched, shrill voice indicated her frustration. I ran a hand over my beard as I tried to think of a way to explain to my mother it would be a cold day in hell before I attended his wedding. Of course he wanted me there.

“Mom, I think I’m busy that day,” I said, chuckling.

“I didn’t even tell you when it is, smartass.”

“Mother, language please,” I said, laughing now.

“Oh, ha ha,” she said.

Out of the corner of my eye I noticed Penny making her way toward me again. “Mom, I have to let you go.” I hung up and smiled to her.

“Should I put a desk out here? Maybe a phone so you can make all of these important calls you need to make?” she asked, her voice full of sarcasm.

“Sure, I’ll need someone to massage my shoulders, too. Know of anyone?”

Her eyes sparkled in the sun as I slipped my phone into my pocket. “You wish.”

“My mother asked me to attend your wedding. That’s fun.”

The spark in her eyes burned out, and she frowned. “Yeah that. It won’t happen, Theo. I promise.”

I grabbed her around the waist. “Baby, please don’t promise me things you may not be able to keep.”

“This one, I swear to you, I’m keeping.”

I kissed the top of her forehead. “What are you doing tomorrow? Can you get away and let’s spend the day together?”

“I’m going dress shopping with your mother in the morning, but I can get away after that.”

I held her tighter, wishing I stood at the altar with her instead of him. “Ok, I’ll come in for inventory here and then we can meet up.”

 

 

 

*** 

 

The next morning, bright and early, I headed off to Lopa. I had everything packed for a great day out, and I couldn’t wait to show her where we were going. I asked her to pack her bikini, but that was all the clues I would give her.

Rushing through the inventory for Lopa, I smiled when I glanced at my watch and noticed it was almost time for Penny to meet me here. My phone pinged with a message. When I glimpsed down, my heart sank.

 

I’m trying to get away from Dex, I’ll be there as soon as I can.

I tried my hardest not to see red as I read the text again. Hatred for Dex seeped from my pores. My mind had a hard time remembering Penny didn’t love him.

Stepping from the bar, I headed to the back office. Once inside, I scanned over the applications for a new bartender. There were a few who would have been really good choices, and I wondered if Penny had called any.

After another hour of going through emails, a frazzled Penny rushed through the office door.

“Are you ok?” I rose from the chair and made my way to her. When I kissed her forehead, she let out a breath.

“No, I’m not, but I promise I’m getting better now. Just take me away from here.” The weary expression on her face made me hug her tighter.

“Let’s go. It’s a bit of a drive. Are you up for that?” I asked.

“Yes.”

We piled into my car, and I headed North on the interstate. The music, at max volume, blared out a tune, and Penny danced in her seat. I smiled to her as the sun shone through the windows. It felt good to have her all to myself. Road trips were something I enjoyed. That’s how you can tell if you get along. Nobody wants to be stuck in a car with someone with a stick up their ass. I reached my hand across the seat and grabbed hers. Intertwining our fingers, I brought her hand to my lips and kissed her soft skin.

She grabbed her phone with her other hand and sat staring at her screen. Her laughter filled the car, and I let go of her hand as she swiped at her screen.

“What are you giggling about over there?”

She dropped the phone in her lap. “Oh, sorry. I’m reading a book.”

“Oh yeah? One of your smut books?” I teased.

“No, not one of my smut books. This one is funny. It’s called Date Me.”

“Sounds dumb.”

She gasped as she tried to hold back her laughter. “It’s not dumb. It’s wonderful.”

“Really, Penny? Wonderful?” I arched a brow as I shot her a look of disbelief.

“Yes. It’s about a pilot who needs to find a date to his ex-girlfriend’s wedding. Well, he ends up in a big mess of a situation. It’s written by a new male author.”

I’ll admit it. I was jealous. “Sounds stupid.”

“Oh, but cartoon books are top of the line reading? Please. Maybe you should give a romance book a try.” She pulled her feet into the seat with her as she leaned closer to me.

“Not a chance in hell. I’ll stick to comics.”

“Suit yourself, but you’re missing out. The lead, Erik in the book, he reminds me of you.”

“Oh yeah, why?”

“He has a really dirty mouth, too.”

I kissed her hand as she went back to reading about weddings and smut. Weddings. I finally asked the question I had been putting off all morning.

“What happened with Dex this morning?” I wanted to know.

“He stopped by this morning. Said he wanted to talk,” she said as her hand ran through my beard.

“About?”

Her smile dropped from her face. “Wedding stuff. They want this wedding as soon as possible.” She turned from me to stare out the window.

“Ouch, did he say why? Scratch that, I know why.” If Penny were mine, I’d make sure I married her immediately too.

Whoa.

A cold sweat broke out on my forehead. That was the third time I thought of Penny and a wedding. Usually imagining weddings meant you were in lo… Fuck. I dropped her hand as I continued driving. She kept her stare fixed on the passing scenery. An awkward silence loomed between us. I was afraid to say anything for fear of confessing some undying love to her. Although, the way I felt, the grey area of “I really like you.” no longer applied. What if she didn't feel the same? Yeah, she liked me. But this wasn't one of her romance novels where people fell in love after a great fuck. Although, how could she not fall in love with the way I fucked her? It was that damn good.

Trying to push away the feelings and thoughts of love and marriage, I saw the exit for Blue Heron Blvd and turned off.

“Where are we going? Singer Island?”

“Yeah, I know a spot just under the bridge. Figured we could go swimming.”

“Oh ok, sounds fun.”

I parked the car, and we pulled out all the snorkeling equipment I packed. Heading a way down the road, we stepped onto the sandy area leading into the Intercoastal Waterway.

“I figured we would swim in the waterway instead of the ocean,” I said as I lifted my shirt over my head. Her eyes trailed over my abs.

“Great idea. Is it going to rain?” She tilted her face, looking up at the few gray clouds rolling by.

“I think we’ll be ok for a while. But, you never know, it is Florida after all.” I laughed.

We waded out into the calm blue water, and as she swam, I watched reverently. I swam after her.

I had to touch her, away from her father—from Dex. Out here she was all mine.

Something brushed against my leg. I dunked my head into the water and saw a huge loggerhead turtle swimming along the bottom of the ocean. Popping my head out of the water, I searched for Penny.

“Penny, look.” I pointed my finger down below. She nodded then dunked her head into the water. I lowered beneath the surface and watched as she swam with the turtle.

It was a sight to see for sure.

I wanted to touch her.

Share her excitement.

Feel her joy.

I wanted her to love me.