I was pacing the apartment, feeling nervous and anxious when I heard their voices, and then the door unlocked.

I rushed into the living room, my face still blotchy from crying, and my eyes locked on Levi and Kendall, hand in hand, laughing about something and looking every bit as perfect as they should.

Seeing them together like that killed a part of me. I hated that they had this connection, this love that should have been mine. I’d been in love with Levi since before I could remember, in love with the way he looked and acted, how mean he could be but how loving when given the chance as well. I hated the easy camaraderie between them, hated the way they looked at one another. Jealousy washed over me in a toxic wave, and I had to look away for a second, worried that my eyes would betray me.

They’d made up. Of course they had. They belonged together. Levi had always wanted Kendall, never me. And I was just going to have to live with it.

I looked back at them, my eyes swimming with emotion. But I noticed now they weren’t looking at each other anymore. They were still hand in hand, but now both of them were looking at me.

Fuck.

I was really in trouble now.

“Why did you do it, Amanda?” Kendall asked me.

There wasn’t a hint of anger in her voice. Instead, there was genuine curiosity. She wanted to know why I’d chosen to fuck Levi, why I’d gone to such elaborate lengths to make sure I got him for myself, even if it was only for one night. And what was I going to tell her? I wasn’t even sure myself why I’d done it.

“I’m sorry,” I said lamely.

“Sorry won’t do it,” Levi said, his voice booming across the room. “Tell us why you did what you did, Mandy.”

This was going to end badly. They were going to kick me out of here. I was going to have to go back to my mother… And now I really was crying.

Kendall tore her hand out of Levi’s and approached me. She pushed my hair off my shoulders and onto my back, giving me a quick, tight hug. I was surprised by it, by her readiness to forgive me, even though I’d fucked up her relationship. Sometimes I didn’t understand myself, why I chose to sabotage something so good between them.

“I wanted what you had,” I said lamely. “I just… I couldn’t stand not having him. I was jealous of you. Always have been. You got it all, and I… Well, I just had to do what Mom said. I didn’t have anyone.”

“But you had all those boys at school,” Kendall said gently, and I shook my head, feeling miserable.

“I’m not close with anyone,” I admitted. “Just Mom. I’ve never had a boyfriend. Just those… men that came into town.”

Levi glared at me, and I looked at the floor.

“I know what I did was horrible, but I just… I just wanted to pretend for one day someone wanted me for me. Not you, Kendall, not the girl Mom was trying to sell. I just wanted someone to like me.”

“I like you,” Kendall said softly. “But you’ve been pushing me away any chance you got.”

“I’m sorry,” I said. “I didn’t want you dragged into Mom’s mess. My worst nightmare was that she’d end up using you too. I couldn’t fucking let that happen.”

“You need to be punished,” Levi said, and we both looked up at him. “For what you did. Pretending you were Kendall. If I’m going to fuck you…”

He took a step towards us and I swallowed thickly, my eyes locked on his, the lust washing over my body unmistakable. Yes, I’d felt it before, with some of the men Mom arranged for me to see. But not like this, never this intense, this fucking head-spinning crazy.

“I’m going to decide how, when and where,” Levi finished.

Kendall stood behind me, gathering my hair in her fist while Levi stood in front of me.

“W-What’s going on?” I stuttered as he reached for me.

It only took him a flick of his fingers to untie the ribbon on Kendall’s blouse I was still wearing.

My whole body shivered. God, I wanted him. I wanted him so fucking badly.

“Are you going to be a good girl?” Levi asked me gently, and I found myself nodding even though I had no idea what on earth was going on. “Good, good.”

He reached for me and my body fucking jerked, I was so desperate. But I was aware of Kendall standing right there, and I did my best to resist the magnetic pull of his body against mine.

“I want to fuck you, princess,” Levi said roughly. “I want to fuck you while your sister watches us.”

Kendall giggled behind me and I paled. I couldn’t believe this. What had he turned my sister into?

I looked at her over my shoulder, but I soon realized I’d seen the devious look in her eyes before. Once, when we were kids, when she tore the head off a girl’s Barbie doll when she was bullying me.

Then again during a game of spin the bottle, when the bottle landed on us and everyone told us to spin again. But Kendall had kissed me, smacked me right on the lips.

And now here, with the man she was in love with.

She wanted to share.

My heart nearly thumped out of my chest when Levi grabbed me and pulled me towards him. I felt Kendall moving behind me, coming up behind me and wrapping her arms around me. She held me lovingly, and he could barely hold back the lust telling him to fuck me, to take advantage of my willing body.

“Open your mouth,” he groaned at me, and I did, my jaw going slack as he kissed me, fucking me with his tongue and pushing it so deep I nearly choked on it.

He kissed like he fucked – with reckless abandon and not giving a shit whether I was enjoying it or not, because he was so sure my panties were soaked already.

While he was kissing me, Kendall tucked my hair behind my ear and whispered against my skin.

“Strip,” she said gently, and I felt goosebumps erupting all over my body.

My shaky hands reached for the blouse, and Kendall helped me pull it off from behind. My skirt followed suit, and I slipped out of it until I was standing before Levi in nothing but panties and a bra, the same ones he’d seen already.

“God, you’re fucking beautiful,” Levi muttered, taking a step back and drinking me in. “Make her turn around, Kendall, I want to see that ass.”

Kendall gently tugged on my arm and I turned for him. Levi groaned at the sight of me and it sent shivers down my spine. It was happening, it was really fucking happening.

“Take her bra off,” Levi ordered Kendall, and I felt my sister’s fingers undoing the clasp at the back, letting the lace fall to the floor.

Levi took a sharp intake of breath when he saw my tits, and I reveled in it. This was what I wanted. This was fucking perfect. All day, I’d thought about him pulling out of me, never coming inside me, and I hated myself for missing the opportunity. I wanted him to fuck me. Wanted him to fill me up. And now, finally, he was going to… And I wasn’t hurting my sister doing it. In fact, one look at Kendall told me all I needed to know. She was fucking loving this.

“And her panties,” Levi growled, and my body trembled.

Kendall’s thumbs hooked under my panties and she pried them off, so slowly I wanted to help her along. But I was too scared. Instead, I just wiggled my ass, trying to get them off as fast as I possibly could.

“Are you going to fuck me?” I asked Levi.

“What do you think?” he grinned at me, then turned towards Kendall. “Should I fuck her, baby girl?”

“Yeah,” Kendall whispered. “Fuck her. I want to watch, Daddy.”

He groaned and pulled me towards him. Kendall let me go easily, and I looked at her, watching Levi’s fingers digging into my skin, pulling me against him. I couldn’t resist anymore. Fuck, I needed to get off.

I rubbed myself all over him, my desperate mouth finding his while my sister watched. I kissed him hungrily, and he pushed a hand between my legs, his fingers fighting their way into the tightness of my pussy. He got me off in seconds. His touch was that of an expert, and he had me mewling, coming all over his fingers in less than a minute. It made him laugh out loud.

“Do you see what a good little slut she is for Daddy, Kendall?” he asked, and my sister giggled. “We’re going to have to train you to come as fast as that, aren’t we?”

“Yes, Daddy,” Kendall answered obediently, and Levi continued his assault on my body.

His mouth was hot and needy on mine, his fingers bringing me pleasure I could only give myself. And then he grabbed me by the waist, turning me over the table and I pushed my ass up for him, desperate for him to bury his cock in it.

“I wonder…” he said, his fingers gliding down my ass, gently caressing me and making me mewl out loud. “We all know you’re not a virgin, princess, but have you had anyone in your ass?”

I thought of the last man Mom had made me see, of his fumbling attempts to force his cock into my ass. How he’d failed.

“N-No,” I stuttered. “Nobody.”

“Nobody, what?” Levi growled at me, and I felt my body dissolving in pleasure without even having him touching me.

“Nobody, Daddy,” I whispered, and I heard Kendall giggling across the room.

“Good fucking girl,” Levi muttered back. “We’re going to make sure Daddy’s your first, aren’t we?”

My body prickled at the thought. He was going to fuck my ass… The one thing I hadn’t done, the one thing I was so scared of I hadn’t even been brave enough to try it myself.

“Daddy,” Kendall said, and I looked up to find her pouting. “You’ve never fucked my ass.”

“That’s because you’re special, baby girl,” Levi told her gently. “But little princess here is our slut, isn’t she? And she deserves a fucking punishment.”

I heard him unzipping his jeans and my body tensed as he stripped behind me. I put my hands on the small of my back, twisting for him, giving him all the control in the world. He smoothed my hair down, and I reveled in his gentle touch. He was so fucking perfect. I couldn’t believe our luck.

I felt his hard cock against my bare ass and I gasped when I did, making Levi chuckle out loud.

“You like that, don’t you?” he asked me gently. “Little princess likes Daddy’s cock getting hard because of her.”

“Fuck her,” Kendall insisted. “Put it inside her, I want to watch.”

“Don’t be so impatient, baby girl,” Levi grinned at her. “Come closer, help me.”

Kendall approached him and I heard them kissing behind me.

“Make Daddy’s cock wet, baby girl,” Levi told her sweetly. “Come on, get it nice and dripping so I can fuck Mandy while you watch.”

I heard Kendall dropping to her knees, wet, slurping sounds letting me know she’d done as he’d asked of her. She sucked him and he groaned with pleasure each time she came up for air.

“That’s not enough, Kendall,” he said gently. “You have to make it fucking drip. Now, do your best or Daddy’s going to have to fuck the back of your throat himself.”

I heard her choking on him. I heard the wet, slippery sounds telling me she was doing everything in her power to soak his cock in her spit to make sure it didn’t hurt me as much. And God, did it make me drip. My poor pussy was spasming with orgasms that needed to be forced out of it, slippery juices leaking down my thighs and making me so wet I was embarrassed, blushing on the table in front of them and so very desperate for Levi to finally do it.

“Fuck,” I breathed. “Please, Levi…”

“Levi?” he barked at me, slapping my ass with the palm of his hand.

I cried out at the pain, and looked at him over my shoulder.

“Daddy…” I whispered, and he grinned at me.

“Good fucking girl,” he said easily. “Now, tell your baby sister to suck fucking better.”

“Kendall,” I said eagerly. “Kendall please, I want him to fuck me, suck harder, suck better, please, Kenny please…”

I heard her working him, but then he wrapped his fingers in her hair.

“Not good enough,” he groaned. “Have to fuck that throat now, baby girl, have to get my dick nice and wet. You need to get it slippery, Kendall, fucking dripping with your spit.”

She mewled with her mouth full as he pushed into her. I heard her choke, just like I had so many times before on strangers’ cocks.

“Yes, Daddy,” I said eagerly. “Fuck her deeper, get your cock so fucking wet. Get off with her mouth.”

“Is that what you want?” Levi asked me roughly. “You want me to fuck your sister’s throat like it’s a cunt, princess?”

“Yes, Daddy,” I begged needily. “Please, do it, Daddy please!”

He groaned and started moving his hips, thrusting into her throat while Kendall rolled her eyes back, getting the air fucked right out of her. She couldn’t breathe, her face getting paler, her eyes desperately pleading with me, then Levi, to go easy on her. But he wasn’t going to, and I was enjoying it too much to remind him to be gentle. He fucked that mouth of hers until she howled, and then he pulled out suddenly, sending Kendall on her ass, falling back and whimpering, desperately trying to catch her breath.

Thick, slippery strands of spit hung from her mouth to his dick, and Levi laughed out loud, coming up behind me and pulling my ass open for me.

“Daddy’s coming home, princess,” he told me sweetly, and then, in one thrust, he was inside me.

God, it fucking hurt. It hurt so much I screamed out loud when he slammed into me, my arms trying to reach up at him, but he held them behind my back firmly and pleasured himself with my ass.

“Jesus fucking Christ,” he muttered. “God, your fucking ass, princess. Such a perfect tight little hole for me.”

I mewled as he fucked me, and in a few seconds, it stopped hurting. The pain was substituted by a feeling of being so fucking full I could have burst.

“Daddy,” I breathed. “Daddy I feel so full, so fucking full…”

“Good girl,” he muttered. “That’s right, you should feel fucking full with Daddy’s cock stretching you like this. Kendall, get those clothes fucking off of you. I want to watch you playing while I come inside her.”

I looked at my sister through hazy eyes, watching her tear at my dress and rip it off her body, her panties sliding down to her ankles. She laid on her back and opened her legs up like a wanton whore, her fingers sliding along her slit, getting off on watching him fuck me like a slut.

“That’s right, baby girl,” he told her roughly. “Let Daddy fucking watch, just like that.”

He reached between my legs, and I saw stars when his fingers sought out my clit, gently pinching it and making me mewl and cry out like crazy. I was desperate to come, but I couldn’t get past the pain in my butt. I wanted to though, I wanted to squirt for him again.

“See, Kendall,” Levi said lovingly. “Your slut sister has a special talent that we’re going to have to teach you all about. She’s a fucking squirter.”

I mewled and Kendall gave me a jealous glare while she stroked her pussy.

“I can squirt, Daddy,” she said, sounding offended.

“Not like this you can’t,” he grinned at her. “She squirts like a fucking fountain, baby girl, and we’re going to have to make sure she teaches you, so you can squirt for Daddy too.”

I saw how jealous she was and it made me grin at her. Kendall rubbed her pussy furiously, desperate to be better than me. That old competitive side of hers was coming out, and I fucking loved it. I loved it so much when she was feisty.

“Daddy please,” I begged again. “Will you please fill me up? I’ll squirt for you.”

“Of course you will, slut,” he said, fucking me deeper, making me cry out. “You’ll do anything Daddy tells you to, won’t you, Mandy?”

“Yes,” I said eagerly. “Anything Daddy, anything you fucking want, just keep fucking me, make me come for you…”

He strummed my clit and I dissolved underneath his touch, the incessant pounding inside my ass and the way he pinched my swollen clit making me lose my focus. I was so fucking ready to burst, droplets of my juices flowing down my legs freely, desperate for him to hurt me more.

“Leave marks,” I begged him. “Leave marks on me Daddy, I want to remember this…”

He grabbed my ass with one hand and spanked it with the other, so roughly I started sobbing from the pain. My hand dipped between my legs and I touched my own pussy, fucking it furiously with two fingers, so desperate to get off I couldn’t even see straight. Levi didn’t even try to stop me, focusing instead on fucking me deeper and bruising my ass until I howled.

And then I felt it coming, felt the orgasm washing over me in waves so strong my head slammed against the table.

“God!” I cried out. “Daddy please, come inside me, I can’t take it, fucking please just fill me up.”

He groaned, and he sounded so fucking helpless in that moment, like he was a slave to my pussy and like all that mattered in the world was fucking me up beyond repair.

“Kendall, get over here,” he said, and my sister crawled closer while I spasmed.

He made her put her ass up, and he spanked us both so roughly we cried in unison.

“Matching marks for matching girls,” Levi growled, and it was too much.

I felt my pussy running down his crotch, rivulets of my sticky sweetness messing up the triangle of hair around his dick, my pussy spasming as he fucked my ass. I didn’t need to see Kendall to know she was coming too – it was obvious enough from her desperate wails, the needy moans ripping from her mouth while Levi punished our asses.

And then I felt him coming apart with a sexy growl, his cock leaking inside me, Levi completely helpless as my ass milked him of everything he had. He fucked it into me, fast, desperate thrusting motions ensuring my ass was filled to the brim. And then he pulled out.

I turned around to see him watching us, his cock still erect, his hands running through his hair, looking at the mess we’d made in absolute shock.

“Daddy,” Kendall cried out, crawling to him on shaky knees, her hand still between her legs. “I don’t want her to be your favorite, Daddy, I don’t want you to love her better, Daddy please!”

She sounded so desperate, and my eyes locked with Levi as he smoothed down her hair, his hand shaking.

“I love you both the same, baby girl,” he told her easily. “Like every Daddy does with his little girls. Don’t you worry your pretty little head.”