Something doesn’t feel right.

When I walked into that interrogation room, I was sure we had the right guy.

Lock him up. Throw away the key. There was no doubt in my mind that Milo Murray was a hardened killer.

But something about his eyes makes me pause.

I sit and stare at his new mugshot on my computer screen, flipping between it and the old one of Jacob Tyler. I’ve looked into the eyes of dozens of killers. You never see the same eyes twice. No killer is the same as another but there’s always been a feeling deep inside of me that tells me they’re guilty long before I have the evidence to back it up.

I expected that feeling when I walked in there today but when I looked into Milo’s eyes again and I saw something bright and innocent… and achingly familiar.

Trevor scoffs behind my back. “You’re not developing a crush on this guy, are you?”

I look up and glare. “No. I’m doing my job, Detective. It’s a thing some of us do around here.”

He sneers and walks on, casting another suspicious glance at my monitor as he goes.

Milo Murray, I think as I stare into his multicolored eyes. What am I missing?

My desk phone rings and I pick it up. “Silva,” I answer.

“Anna, we have a Mrs. Emery Nelson down here,” Sally says. “I believe she’s your witness.”

“Thank you, Sally. I’ll be right down.”

I drop the phone and jump up to rush downstairs.

I reach the lobby to see an older woman lingering at the front desk with Sally. She stands tall and talks fast, showing a spry woman for her age. Good. The more competent she is, the better her testimony will be.

I walk over and extend my hand. “Mrs. Nelson, thank you for coming in. I’m Detective Silva. I understand you got a good look at the man fleeing Burn Street last night?”

She nods and shakes my hand. “Yes, ma’am.”

“Would you be willing to do a line-up for us?” I ask.

“Absolutely,” she says. “Whatever you need.”

“Come with me. It won’t take long.” I guide her down the hall. “We have a suspect in custody so whatever you can tell us will be helpful for keeping him here.”

She visibly shudders. “Just don’t understand how someone can do that kind of thing…”

“I’ve spent most of my adult life trying to figure that out myself, Mrs. Nelson.

I lead her onto the elevator and we ride up to the fifth floor. We walk down the hall and I gesture her into the viewing room on the left. I look through the glass at the six men standing there waiting. All tall, dark men with short, brown hair and thick arms.

Milo stands in the middle, looking down at the floor.

“Mrs. Nelson, do you recognize any of these men?”

Her head cranes up as she studies the glass.

“It’s a one-way mirror, ma’am,” I tell her. “They can’t see you. It’s all right.”

She grins. “Always wanted to do this. How exciting!”

I smile back before looking into the connecting room again at Milo’s downturn face.

“Oh!” She points at Milo. “Number three.”

I reach out to enable the intercom switch by my head. “Number three, step forward,” I say into it.

I click it off and watch as Milo slides closer to the glass. He looks straight ahead, his dark eyes standing out beneath the bright lights.

I turn away from him. “This is the man you saw last night?” I ask Mrs. Nelson.

“That’s the young man who runs that taco truck, isn’t it?”

My eyes twitch. “I can’t tell you that, ma’am. Now, do you recognize—”

“He’s not in any trouble, is he?”

“Mrs. Nelson, is this the man you saw last night fleeing the Burn Street apartment block or not?”

“Oh, heaven’s no!” she says. “I definitely would have recognized him if it were.”

I flex my jaw and flick on the intercom again. “You can step back, number three,” I spit.

Milo’s eyes shift left and right twice before he eases backward to stand by the wall.

“The man I saw was much shorter,” she adds. “Thinner, too.”

“Would you mind sticking around and working with a sketch artist?” I ask.

“Sure,” she says with a shrug.

“Thank you, Mrs. Nelson.”

She pulls her purse higher up her shoulder and smiles through the glass. “He always gives me extra sauce, you know,” she says with a smile. “Doesn’t even charge me for it.”

I glare at Milo. “Is that right?”

“Such a wonderful young man.”

I clear my throat and gesture to the hallway. “This way, Mrs. Nelson.”

She follows me to the door and I glance back over my shoulder toward the line-up again. Milo Murray seems to have a lot of people fooled but that’s not surprising. That’s what frauds like him are good at. Ruthless. Charming. There’s a reason why everyone is always so surprised when they’re finally unmasked.

But he was so nice. So thoughtful.

He was the perfect gentleman.

I’m not falling for it.

Milo is hiding something.

And I’m going to find out what it is.

* * *

I sit at my desk, quietly scrolling through Milo’s financial records. The judge gave us a warrant to access everything we could, so we swiped up whatever we could find in his and Jacob Tyler’s name, too. So far, I’ve found nothing. He’s good at covering his tracks but that doesn’t mean I won’t leave any stone unturned.

I’m gonna nail this son-of-a-bitch.

My attention drifts to the corner where our volunteer sketch artist, Abby, sits with Mrs. Nelson. Her pencil moves quickly against her sketchbook, pushing softly to easily alter it according to Mrs. Nelson’s suggestions. She glances at me and gives a nod before adjusting her glasses up her nose and getting back to it.

My phone rings and I reach for it. “Silva,” I answer.

“Hey, it’s Kendall. We just checked the last three registered addressed for Milo Murray and another one registered to Jacob Tyler.”

“What’d you find?”

“Nothing,” she answers. “Literally nothing. They were all abandoned, meaning this guy’s got some secret hideout somewhere.”

“Keep digging until you find it.”

I don’t wait for an answer. I hang up and click over to his mugshot.

What are you hiding?

For a moment, I lose myself. His eyes seem so clear and real, almost like I want to believe him, but evidence doesn’t lie. People lie. People like him.

“Well, here’s your man.”

I blink out of my trance to find Abby lingering over my desk. She holds out her sketch and I snatch it from her hand. Unfortunately, sketches often turn out to be a lot more average than not. A normal-looking man stares back at me with dark hair, thick brows, and a pointed nose on a clean-shaven face.

“No other features stood out to her?”

Abby slides her sketchbook into her book bag. “She said it was dark. It’s the best I could get out of her…”

“Thanks, Abby,” I say, laying it down. I raise my arms, stretching them out over my head as I take a breath. “How are your classes so far this semester?”

She grins with excitement. “Tonight… we start nudes.”

I laugh at her sinister, winking eye. “Have fun.”

“I will. See you next time, Detective. You have my number.”

“Bye, hun.”

She heads toward the elevator and I pick up the sketch again, frowning to myself.

“Let me see him.”

I look over at Trevor in the desk next to mine. He gestures for the sketch and I pass it to him.

He scoffs. “Looks like every random dude on the street.”

“And not enough like Milo to help our case. No shortage of tall, dark, and handsome in Boston, I guess,” I say.

“I mean… I don’t want to prove your point or nothing, but…” He holds the sketch up to his own face, showing off the resemblance.

I roll my eyes. “Another dead end, then.”

“Good sketch, though.”

“I’m talking about that forehead,” I quip. “You could sell ad space on that thing.”

He laughs. “I walked into that one.”

“Said your forehead.”

He glares at me with pouting lips as I turn back to my computer. Pages and pages of transactions and statement balances wait for me. It’s going to be a long day and I’ve already hit my five cups of coffee limit that’s not actually a limit.

My scroll finger stops dead.

“Boston Bio?” I read.

Trevor looks up. “What?”

I blink. “Nothing, just thinking out loud.”

A large four-figure deposit stands out between trips to a grocery store. Boston Bio. A fertility clinic. Coincidentally, the same clinic I used to help conceive Charlotte.

What the hell was Milo doing at a fertility clinic — I check the date — five years ago?

My stomach turns over.

Oh, no.

I click over to his mugshot again, slamming the mouse button down hard as if it will make it happen faster.

No, no, no.

I zoom in on his eyes. Those gorgeous multicolored eyes. Brown irises with spikes of bright blue shooting out from his pupils.

I grab my phone, quickly swiping it on to see the photo of Charlotte on my home screen.

Brown-hair. Dimples. Cleft chin.

This isn’t possible.

There was a profile. Donor #7134-C. I chose the sperm of a tall, dark, and handsome lawyer. Milo fits the first part but he’s miles away from the second. I saw a photo of the donor. That guy was literally James Bond by way of Chris Evans. He had a dalmatian puppy. It wasn’t Milo. It isn’t Milo.

I look between their photos again, feeling that same dread fill to the edges of my gut.

Oh, no.