Seth and Theo led me upstairs to Theo’s bedroom.

“Why Theo’s bedroom?”  I asked.

“Bigger bed,” Seth said with a grin.  I didn’t object when he started to strip off my clothes.  Theo disappeared into the walk-in closet.  By the time he returned, I was completely naked and Seth had my legs spread and was fingering my pussy while I clutched at his broad shoulders.

“God, Seth, you couldn’t wait two minutes?”

“No,” Seth said as he pumped his fingers in and out of my pussy.  “Fuck, she’s soaking wet already.”

“Please, Sir,” I moaned.  “Please.”

“Our little kitten is begging already,” Theo said with a smug grin.  “Seth, stop fingering her for a minute.”

“No!”  I protested and then squealed when Seth withdrew his fingers from my sopping pussy and slapped my ass hard.

“Lift her hair,” Theo said as I rubbed at my burning ass.

Theo was now naked and I stared greedily at his erect cock as he moved closer and Seth gathered my hair into a ponytail on top of my head.

“Lift your chin, Libby,” Theo instructed.

I lifted my head and stared at the black leather collar he was holding in his hands.  It was thinner than I thought and I eyed the silver buckle as Theo unbuckled it.

“How many other women have worn this?”  I asked.

Theo glanced at Seth and I thought I saw embarrassment flicker in his eyes. 

“What?”  I asked.

“No one else has worn it,” Theo said.  “I bought it last night specifically for you.”

“But you had no idea I would…”

I trailed off as Theo gave me an adorable boyish grin.  “I had high hopes we could change your mind.”

“Oh,” I said.

There was a moment of silence and then Theo was placing the collar around my throat.  He buckled it and slipped his finger between the collar and my neck before stepping back.  “It looks beautiful on you, love,” he said.  “Show her, Seth.”

Seth walked me over to the full-length mirror in the corner of the room.  I stared at the collar around my throat as Theo stood to my right and Seth stood behind me. 

“It looks good,” I said.  I wasn’t lying.  I never would have thought I’d say a collar looked good on me, but looking at the way the leather pressed against my pale skin made me a little hot.

Seth cupped my tits and I watched as he pulled and tugged on my nipples.  It sent pleasure straight to my pussy and I moaned with need as he kissed my neck above the collar.

“Did you get the other stuff?”  Seth asked Theo.

He nodded as they led me back to the bed.  Sitting on the bed was a pair of leather cuffs, a bottle of lube and – I swallowed hard – a butt plug.  The plug part was silver and at the opposite end a bright red jewel caught the light from the lamp.

“Give me your hands, love,” Theo said.

I held them out obediently and as Seth undressed, Theo buckled the cuffs around my wrists.  They were a tight fit and I stared at the metal hoops embedded in them as Seth joined us by the bed.

“Ready?”  Seth asked.

“Yes,” I said.

“Safe word?”

“Red.”

“Good,” Theo said.  “Bend over the bed, spread your legs wide and hold your ass cheeks open for me, Libby.”

I stared at him as my face turned bright red.  I knew I would have the butt plug inserted but I thought we would make out a little first and then one of them would discreetly insert it for me.  I couldn’t just bend over and – and hold myself open for it.  No way, no how.

“Libby,” Theo prompted.

I shook my head.  “No.  I know I need the butt plug but I’m not going to hold myself open.  That’s humiliating.”

“Libby,” Theo said.  “Do what I say.  Last chance.”

I shook my head and gave him a stubborn look.  “No.  You can make it a bit more romantic or at the very least, help me to – oh dammit!”

Seth had grabbed my arms and without a word, he turned me and bent me over the bed until my cheek was resting against the quilt and my ass was in the air.  Still silent, he spanked me in a hard, quick rhythm as I squealed and twisted.  I reached back and tried to protect my burning ass with my flailing hands.  Seth immediately grabbed my wrists by the leather cuffs and held them against my lower back before spanking my ass again.  The pain made my legs shake and I collapsed face-down on the bed and buried my face in the quilt to muffle my cries.

Seth was merciless.  He spanked me at least twenty times while I wiggled and squirmed and cursed a blue streak.  When I finally collapsed against the bed in silent submission, he rubbed his hand over the curve of my burning ass before pushing it between my thighs.  He rubbed my shamefully wet and swollen clit as I moaned and spread my legs wide. 

“On your knees, sweetheart,” Seth commanded.

I climbed to my knees, keeping my face and upper body buried in the bed, and moaned when Seth pushed my thighs wide.  Cool air washed over my anus, but Seth said, “Use your hands to spread yourself open, Libby.”

This time I did what he asked.  Certain that my face was as red as my ass, I kept my eyes squeezed shut as I reached back and held my ass cheeks apart.  I was embarrassed beyond belief but there was also a deep and painfully strong part of me that was incredibly turned on by what they were forcing me to do.

I moaned and twitched when Theo sat down on the bed beside me and ran his rough fingers over my clit.  He used the moisture from my pussy and rubbed his fingers over my anus as my fingers dug into my butt cheeks.

I gasped when Seth pressed a kiss against my right ass cheek.  “You look so pretty in this position, Libby.”

“Yeah, right,” I muttered.

I received a hard spank to my left cheek from Theo for my impertinence and I gasped and cried out, “I’m sorry, Sir.”

Theo rubbed my aching ass.  “Hold still, love.”

The lube was cold against my ass and I tried to clench my ass shut when Theo probed at me with his slick finger.

“No,” Seth said.  “Don’t do that, sweetheart.  Relax.”

“Easy for you to say,” I added a hasty “Sir” before he could spank me.

I could hear the grin in Seth’s voice as he said, “Take some deep breaths.”

I breathed deep and tried not to moan when Theo eased his finger past the tight ring of muscle.  “How does that feel?”

“Like I have a finger up my ass?”  I said.

Both men laughed and my answering giggle turned to a moan of need when Seth rubbed my clit.  My discomfort disappeared in an instant and I rubbed my pussy against Seth’s fingers as I dropped my hands to the bed.

“Make her come first,” Theo murmured.

I cried out when both men leaned over me and kissed their way up my back.  The combination of their mouths and tongue, the feel of Seth’s rough fingers against my swollen clit and the way Theo trailed his free hand up and down the back of my thigh, brought my climax on in an embarrassingly quick fashion.  I moaned and shuddered and clawed at the quilt as Seth kissed my shoulder before brushing my hair back from my sweaty face.

“Hold your ass open again, sweetheart,” he demanded.

My embarrassment gone, I did what he asked, spreading my cheeks wide as Theo removed his finger.  I jerked when he added more lube and Seth kissed my back again.  Thanks to my orgasm, I was more relaxed than before but I still tensed the moment I felt the blunt end of the plug against my ass.

“Don’t tense,” Theo said.

“I’m not.”

He slapped the back of my thigh and I grunted in pain before saying, “I’m trying not to, Sir.”

My fingers squeezed my sore ass as Theo said, “Take a deep breath and push back against the plug.”

I did what he said, groaning a little at the pressure as he steadily pushed it into my ass.  There was a brief eye-watering burst of pain and then nothing but a feeling of dull pressure in my butt.

“You okay?”  Seth asked.

“Yes, Sir,” I replied. “Is it in?”

“It is.”  Theo leaned over and pressed a kiss against my cheek.  “You did so well, love.  How do you feel?”

“Very glad that you ignored my suggestion to just stick your dick in my ass,” I said.

They both laughed and I made a small noise of protest when Theo took my arms and lifted me to my knees. 

“Off the bed, Libby,” he said.

“What?  No, why?”  I didn’t even want to try and walk with the plug.

“Because we want to show you how pretty your ass is,” Seth said.

I tried to resist when they pulled me off the bed, but I was no match for their strength.  I felt incredibly self-conscious as they walked me over to the mirror.  Afraid the plug would fall out, I kept clenching my ass around it and I was shocked at the little spikes of pleasure it sent through my body.

They turned me away from the mirror and I stared at the wall as Theo said, “Turn your head and look, Libby.”

“I’d rather not,” I said.

He started to bend me over and I hastily turned my head.  “No, wait.  I’ll look, Sir.  I’ll look!”

I stared over my shoulder at my flaming red ass and the jewel between my ass cheeks.  The red of the jewel matched the skin on my butt and I twitched when Seth ran his fingers over one ass cheek.

“So pretty, sweetheart.”

I moaned a little when Theo pressed on the jewelled part.  He grinned at Seth and my cheeks flushed.  I knew some women got pleasure from having something shoved in their ass, but I didn’t think I would be one of them.

“Our little kitten looks so pretty in her collar, maybe we should get a tail for her too,” Theo said thoughtfully as he stared at my ass in the mirror.

My eyes widened and I shook my head immediately.  “No fucking way, Theo.  I am not having a tail hanging out of my ass.”

Theo grinned at Seth.  “Sounds like pet play is a hard limit.”

“Damn straight it is,” I said.  “You come anywhere near me with a tail and I’ll scream red so loudly, your neighbours will hear it.”

Theo leaned forward and pressed a kiss against my mouth.  “Understood, love.  Come back to the bed.”

We returned to the bed.  Seth cupped one breast and toyed with my nipple as Theo sat on the bed before reclining on his back.  I was shaking my head before the words were out of his mouth.

“I’m not riding you,” I snapped.  I could hear the anxiety and shame in my voice.

Seth rubbed my lower back as Theo said, “I don’t want you to ride me, love.  I want you to sit on my face.”

My jaw dropped and I pulled away from Seth.  “You what?”

“I want to taste my kitten’s sweet cunt,” Theo said. 

“No.”

“It’ll be fine, Libby,” Seth said.  He tried to guide me closer to the bed and I tore away from him.  Adrenaline was rushing through my veins and Theo sat up and gave me a look of concern.

“Love, it’s okay.”

“It’s not,” I said.  “I’m-I’m yellow right now and if you try and make me do this, I’ll be red.  Do you understand?  It all stops, and I won’t come back to your place.”

“We understand,” Seth said immediately.

“We’ll do a different position,” Theo said.  “It’s okay, love.”

I stared wide-eyed at them before whispering, “I’m sorry.”

“Don’t be,” Theo said.  He crossed to me and took me into his embrace, pressing kisses against my face and my mouth.  “Don’t ever apologize for telling us exactly how you feel.  That’s why we have a safe word, right?”

“Right,” I said shakily.

“Do you want to stop, sweetheart?”  Seth had joined us and he gave me a solemn look.

“No,” I said.  “No, I don’t want to stop.”

Theo and Seth glanced at each other and I shook my head.  “I’m good now.  Just – I don’t want to sit on your face.”

“Okay,” Theo said before giving me another gentle kiss.

He led me back to the bed and I didn’t protest when he and Seth had me sit at the head of the bed with my back leaning against the headboard, my knees bent and my feet resting on the bed.  There was added pressure on the plug and I shifted a bit as Theo pushed my thighs apart before stretching out between them.  He kissed the patch of curls on my pussy as Seth kneeled next to me.  One hard hand was stroking his cock and I stared at the bead of pre-cum at the tip of it before leaning down and licking it away.

“Fuck!” Seth muttered.  He cupped the back of my head and I sucked at his cock with enthusiasm as Theo licked my inner thighs.  I moaned around Seth’s cock when Theo kissed the wet lips of my pussy.  When his tongue wandered over my clit, I arched my hips and clutched at his head as I stared up at Seth.

He gathered up my hair and pulled roughly on it.  “Suck harder, Libby.”

I tried to concentrate on Seth’s dick, but Theo’s tongue was goddamn magic.  It didn’t take long before I was moaning and thrusting my hips against Theo’s face.  I pulled Theo’s hair with one hand and stroked the base of Seth’s cock with the other as he pushed his dick in and out of my mouth. 

I was already close to a second orgasm.  When Theo reached under me and wiggled the plug in my ass, my climax was hot and immediate and lasted incredibly long.  Wave after wave of intense pleasure flooded my lower body.  My scream was muffled by Seth’s cock and he shoved it in deep as I writhed against Theo’s tongue and lips.

Seth pulled out and I gasped in some much-needed oxygen as I pushed at Theo’s head.  I was shaking all over and was so weak I slumped against the headboard.  I barely noticed when Theo sat up and rolled a condom onto his dick before lying on his back next to me. 

Seth was urging me to my knees and I pouted and whined, “Tired, Sir.”

“I know, sweetheart.  Theo’s going to fuck you and then you can sleep.”

I smiled at the thought of being fucked as Seth pulled on my right thigh.  “Come on, sweetheart.  Leg over Theo, now.”

Feeling almost drunk from my unbelievable orgasm, I did what he asked.  It wasn’t until I was straddling Theo, my knees pressed against his hips as Seth pulled my arms behind my back and held them firmly, that I realized what was happening.

Theo was beginning to press his dick against my opening and I froze as fresh adrenaline pumped through my veins. 

“I can’t be on top!”  I shouted like an idiot.  “Stop, wait, I’m going to hurt…oh fuck!”

Seth had pushed me down, impaling me on Theo’s thick cock.  I moaned and wiggled and tried to ignore how good it felt to have my pussy filled to the brim with dick.

“Stop,” I whispered unconvincingly.  “Theo, I’m too heavy.”

“You’re not,” he rasped as he reached up and cupped my tits.  He pulled hard on the nipples and I arched my back.  “Baby, your soft curves feel like heaven.  I need you to fuck me right now before I go insane.”

“Are you sure?”  I whispered as Seth tightened his hold on my arms.

“Fuck, yes,” Theo groaned.  “Seth, let her go.”

He released my arms and Theo tugged me down until I was bent over him with my hands resting on the bed above his shoulders.  He kissed my upper chest and I rubbed my nipples against his chest as his hands cupped my tender ass.  He thrust in and out and I moaned with pleasure before bouncing enthusiastically on his dick.

“Fuck,” he muttered again, “the plug makes her even tighter.”

“Libby, look at me.”

I turned my head and automatically opened my mouth for Seth’s cock.  He was kneeling next to my head again and I sucked on his cock as Theo fucked me hard.  His rhythm was rough and out-of-control and I cried out when one of his hands pushed on the plug in my ass and the other rubbed furiously at my clit.

Seth held tightly to my hair, guiding my mouth back and forth over his dick as Theo made another hoarse groan.  “Fuck, I’m not going to… I can’t…”

His body arched beneath mine and he pinched my clit hard.  It should have hurt, and it did, but the pain brought on a third and completely unexpected orgasm.  I forgot completely about hurting Theo and ground my pelvis against his as he grabbed my hips and came deep inside of me.  Seth pulled me away from his cock and into a sitting position with a hard tug to my collar.  He pumped his dick with his hand and came with a loud roar of pleasure, his cum splattering all over my breasts.

Panting harshly, Theo helped me ease off of him.  I fell to the bed on my side, my entire body quivering and pulsing.  Theo disposed of the condom as Seth used a towel to wipe my chest clean.  I kept my eyes closed and moaned happily when both men slid into the bed on either side of me.  Seth was at my back and I jerked when he touched the plug still in my ass.

“Take it out,” I whispered.

“No, sweetheart,” he said.

“Please, Sir?”  I asked.

“No,” Seth repeated.

I must have been pouting because Theo made a low chuckle before pressing a kiss against my mouth.  “The longer you wear it, the sooner you can take Seth’s dick in your ass.”

“But it’s getting late and I should go home.”

“No,” Seth said.  “You’re spending the night with us, Libby.”

I should have argued.  I should have gotten up, taken the plug out of my damn ass, dressed and driven home.  Instead, I snuggled in closer to their hard bodies and sighed with pleasure when Theo cupped my breast and Seth kissed my back.

“Sleep now, Libby.”

“Yes, Sir,” I murmured.