“Do you have any idea how hard it is to hang balls when you’re doing that?”  I said.

Theo laughed and squeezed my tits again, rubbing his crotch against my ass as I stood on my tiptoes to hang the round silver ornament on one of the branches.  His movement jostled the plug in my ass and I couldn’t help but moan.

“Someone’s getting horny,” he said.

“I’ve been horny since I got here,” I replied.  “But someone made me eat dinner first and then someone else made me decorate their Christmas tree.”

“Hey, it can’t be sex, sex, sex all the time,” Seth said as he crawled out from under the tree.  “We’re not just dicks for your pleasure, you filthy girl.”

“Really?”  I said.  Theo was kissing my neck and I arched into his hands when he cupped my breasts again and played with my nipples through the fabric of Seth’s t-shirt.

“Mostly,” Seth said as he watched my nipples harden under Theo’s ministration.  “Fuck, are we done decorating this goddamn tree yet?”

“Yes,” Theo said.  “Did you plug the lights in?”

Seth nodded and brushed some pine needles from his shoulders.  “Yeah, turn them on.”

Theo flicked the switch to turn on the lights.  The Christmas lights flickered to life and Seth joined us as we stared up at the glowing tree.

“It’s beautiful,” I said.

“Yes, beautiful,” Seth replied.  He was staring at me and I gave him a sweet smile as he took my hand and kissed my knuckles.

While Seth made me dinner, Theo had set the tree up in their living room.  I was secretly thrilled when they asked me to help decorate it.  I knew it was stupid.  I was only here to have sex with them, but even naked under Seth’s shirt and wearing a plug in my ass, it had felt good to do something with them that wasn’t sex related. 

Be careful, Libby.  You’re thinking dangerous thoughts.  This isn’t a relationship and it all ends the minute they both get their dicks into you at the same time.

I know, I thought irritably to inner me.  I know, so give it a rest, would you?

“Libby?”

“Sorry, what was that?”  I smiled apologetically at Theo.

“I said it was getting late,” he replied.

I glanced at the clock over the fireplace.  It was almost ten and all of us had to work in the morning.  I ignored my disappointment.  Yes, I had loved decorating the tree with them and drinking hot chocolate and laughing and swapping childhood Christmas stories like we were in some kind of weird threesome relationship.  But apparently, deep down, I was more interested in the sex.  Pathetic, but true.  I would have happily given up all of that if I’d known it meant I wouldn’t get laid tonight.  Ignoring how sorry I felt for myself, I smiled cheerfully at them.  “Yes, it is.  Thank you for dinner.  I had a lovely time.  Should I leave the plug in for a few more hours and then bring it, um, back to you tomorrow night?”

“What are you talking about?”  Seth asked with a frown.

“The butt plug,” I said patiently.  “Should I take it out now and leave it here or drive home with it in and take it out in another hour or so?”

“You’re not going home,” Theo said.  “You’re marching your sweet little ass up to the bedroom so we can fuck you.”

Excitement radiated through me but I said, “I know its late and we have work in the morning so - ”

“Libby,” Seth warned, “if you keep arguing with us, you will get spanked again.”

I shut my mouth with a snap and took Theo’s offered hand as Seth shut the lights off on the Christmas tree.  We walked upstairs to Theo’s bedroom and Seth disappeared into the closet as Theo stripped off my shirt before stepping behind me.  He was rubbing my clit with one hand and wiggling the plug in my ass with the other when Seth returned.  I was moaning and rubbing my pussy against Theo’s hand and paid no attention to what Seth was carrying.

When he bent and sucked on my right nipple, I wound my fingers through his thick hair and held him tightly.  He sucked and licked until my nipple was hard and swollen. 

Theo stopped playing with the plug in my ass and said, “Put your arms behind your back, love.”

I did what he asked, a little thrill going through me when he hooked his arm around both of mine and held me firmly.  I was trapped against him and I arched my back, pushing more of my breast into Seth’s mouth as Theo bent his head and kissed me.

The pain on my nipple had me yanking my mouth from Theo’s.  I hissed and stared at the small metal alligator clamp fastened to my right nipple.  It had a silver chain attached to it and I moaned and tried to wiggle free when Seth adjusted the fit.

“Too tight!”  I gasped.

“It isn’t,” Seth said.

“It hurts!”

“It’s supposed to,” he said with a small grin.  He sucked on my left nipple and I tried to will it not to harden so he couldn’t attach the clamp.  Unaware of what was about to happen to it, my left nipple cheerfully rose to the occasion and I couldn’t help moaning in a combination of pleasure and pain.  Seth attached the second clamp and tightened it before smiling at me.

“How’s that?”

“Painful,” I retorted.

He tugged on the silver chain that dangled between my breasts and I moaned as it pulled on my aching nipples.  “Oh God!  Don’t – don’t do that.”

“Behave and I won’t have to,” he said. 

He turned to Theo and said, “Is she wet enough to be fucked?”

God, why did his crudeness turn me on so much?  And would there always be a small part of me that believed I was sick for wanting to be treated this way?

Theo was still holding my arms behind my back.  He glanced at Seth and a silent communication rippled between them.  Theo pressed a kiss against my cheek before saying, “Safe word, love?”

“Red,” I said.

“We’ll only stop for your safe word.  Nothing else,” Theo said.

“I know,” I said in confusion.  Why was he reminding me of that?

“Is she wet enough?”  Seth repeated.

Theo cupped my pussy and rubbed it roughly.  “Fuck, yes.  She’s dripping.”

“Good.  Are you ready to be fucked, Libby, or have you changed your mind?”  Seth asked.

I gave him a blank look.  Why the hell would he think I’d changed my mind?  I was practically begging them to fuck me earlier before dinner, and…

My eyes widened.  Holy shit, Seth and Theo were trying to give me exactly what I wanted.  Fresh excitement raced through my veins and I was suddenly so turned on, I could hardly stand it.  I had never taken a single acting class, had never joined the drama club or participated in a school play but I was about to play the part in my fantasy as eagerly as a waitress trying to make it in Hollywood.

I took a deep breath and said, “I’ve changed my mind.”

Seth arched his eyebrow at me.  “What did you say?”

“I’ve changed my mind.  I – I don’t want to fuck you.  I’d like to go home now, please.”

“Did you hear what she said, Theo?”

“I did.”

A shiver of fear and anticipation went down my spine.  Theo’s voice had both deepened and roughened and he sounded angry.  More fear licked along my veins but beneath it was – oh god, was it anticipation?

Seth reached out and traced my bottom lip with his finger.  I tried to pull back from his touch and liquid dripped out of my pussy when Theo tightened his hold on my arms.  I was trapped between them and that odd but compelling combination of fear and need tingled through me again.

“We gave you what you wanted tonight.  Didn’t we, Libby?”

“I- I don’t know,” I stammered.

“You don’t know?”  Seth’s voice was silky soft.  “I spanked you and Theo gave you an orgasm.  Hell, I even made you dinner.  Is that right?”

“Yes,” I whispered.

“We did all of that for you, and now you’re going to leave without spreading your pretty thighs and giving us a go at your cunt?  Does that seem fair?”

“I don’t have to – to have sex with you just because you did those things.”  I tried to sound strong but there was a waver in my voice that made Seth smile.

“No, sweetheart, you don’t.  But do you know what they call girls like you?”

I shook my head and then moaned when Seth brushed his mouth across mine before whispering, “Cock tease.”

I gasped in a combination of shock and pain when Theo tugged on the chain connecting the nipple clamps.  It made my nipples throb and I whimpered when Seth leaned down and licked the swollen and tender tip of my right one.  It sent pleasure straight to my pussy and I squeezed my thighs together in an attempt to ease the ache as Theo whispered in my ear.

“Are you a cock tease, Libby?”

“No,” I moaned.

“Wrong answer,” Theo replied before tugging again on the chain.

It sent fresh sparks of pleasure and pain radiating through me and I arched my back and stood on my tiptoes.  Fuck, I was so wet I was about to drip all over the floor of the bedroom.

“Please,” I cried out as Theo bit my neck and Seth nipped at my collarbone.

“Tell us what you are, Libby,” Seth demanded.

“I – I’m a cock tease!”  I said as Theo used his knee to push my thighs apart.  He stuck his leg between mine and I rubbed against his denim-clad thigh with shameless need.  “Oh, please!”

“Say it again,” Seth demanded.

“I’m a cock tease,” I said.

“That’s right, you are.  Your little cunt belongs to both of us and we’ll fuck it whenever we want.

I barely heard Seth, I was rubbing my clit against Theo’s hard thigh and I was so damn close to coming.  I needed a little more friction, a little more pressure and…

I howled with pain when Seth pulled hard on the chain between my breasts.  It yanked me back from the exquisite edge of my orgasm and I made inarticulate pleading noises as Theo pulled his leg from between mine.

“Fuck, Seth, I can’t wait another goddamn minute.”

Theo’s voice was as ragged as my breath and to be honest, Seth was looking like he was on the verge of losing his control as well.

“Please, Seth, oh, please,” I moaned.

He hesitated and then cursed under his breath before grabbing my arm and roughly pulling me to the bed.  “On your hands and knees, facing the headboard, Libby.”

I obeyed him without hesitation.  Part of me was sorry I had ruined my fantasy so quickly, but I felt nearly wild.  If they didn’t give me what I wanted, what I needed, I would lose my goddamn mind.

I clambered onto the bed and dropped to my hands and knees, staring at the headboard.  Seth and Theo were tearing off their clothes in record time and I only made a small whimper of protest when Seth wrapped a heavy chain around the center iron spindle of the headboard and grabbed both my wrists.

“Hands up,” he demanded hoarsely.

I lifted my hands, balancing myself on my knees as Seth threaded the chain through the hoops in the leather cuffs around my wrists before securing the chain to the headboard. 

I squealed in surprise when Theo grabbed my hips and lifted me up enough for Seth to slide beneath me.  My legs were spread wide around his hips and my back was arched from the way my hands were tied.  Seth was already wearing a condom and I resisted when his hands replaced Theo’s on my hips and pulled.

“Libby,” he said warningly, “lower your tight pussy on my dick, right now.”

“Seth,” I whispered.  Even as turned on as I was, my insecurities were rearing their ugly head.  “Seth, don’t make me do this.”

“You’re going to ride me, sweetheart, because if you don’t, I’ll tell Theo to pull that plug from your ass and replace it with his cock.  What do you think, Libby?  You think your ass is stretched enough to take Theo’s cock?”

I stared at Seth and knew he meant every word of what he was saying.  I must have hesitated too long because he pulled hard on the chain between my breasts.  I cried out and quickly lowered my body until the tip of his cock brushed against my pussy.  He groaned and reached between us, guiding his cock to my entrance.  I pushed down and we both moaned when he entered me fully with one hard thrust.

Thanks to my hands being restrained, I had to bend over him, leaving my breasts in his face.  He took advantage of it, sucking on my protruding nipples and pulling on the clamps with his teeth.  I moaned and pleaded for mercy as the bed dipped and Theo kneeled between Seth’s legs behind me.

I was stuffed full of Seth’s cock, restrained with my nipples clamped and there was so much lust coursing through my veins, I was afraid my heart would explode from it.  The deep breath I took that was meant to help calm me, turned into a wailing scream of pure pleasure.  Theo was pushing and tugging on the plug in my ass while his fingers pinched my clit and that was it for me.  I came with another hard scream as the pleasure rolled through me in endless tumbling waves that made my entire body shake.  Dimly, I was aware of Seth thrusting into me from below, of the way his hard cock pounded into my pussy.  He made a harsh roar that shook me to my core with its intensity and arched upward.  There was a brief flash of pain as he thrust deep and then it was his turn to shake and moan.

“Seth, fucking move!”  Theo’s voice was the sound of a desperate animal.

I cried out when he yanked on my hips, pulling my body up until Seth’s cock popped out of me.

“Goddammit move, Seth!”  Theo said furiously.

With a low groan Seth slid out from under me, rolling to the far side of the bed and laying on his back as he gasped for air.

My thighs were pulled apart so wide that the muscles screamed in protest.  I hung my head and took great gasping breaths of air and then squealed with pleasure when Theo pushed in to the hilt.

“Fuck, oh fuck,” he chanted in a low moan as he pushed and retreated with hard and punishing strokes.  I braced my hands against the headboard, the chain that bound me to it rattling loudly as new tingles of exquisite pleasure started up in my pussy.

“Oh God, no,” I moaned.  “I can’t have another one.  I can’t have… oh God!”

Without breaking his rhythm, Theo had reached under me and was rubbing at my clit.  It was too much and I tried to break free, crying out when his hand wrapped in my hair and yanked my head back.

“No,” he snarled into my ear.  “You come for me right now, baby.  Come all over my cock with your tight pussy!”

He pulled on my clit and I screamed as I climaxed again.  This one was just as intense as the first one and I shook wildly as white light exploded behind my eyelids.  Theo shouted my name before driving me down into the mattress.  His big body shook on top of mine and his hand pulled hard at my hair as he came deep inside of me.

His weight was making it hard to breathe and I protested my lack of oxygen.  He pulled out and collapsed on the other side of me, nearly falling off the bed in the process.  I pulled at the chain connecting me to the bed and Seth quickly unclasped it before tossing the chain on the floor beside the bed.  He rolled me over onto my back and I stared glassy-eyed at him as he made soft crooning noises into my ear and rubbed my quivering belly and thighs.

“Such a good girl, Libby,” he said.  “She’s our good girl, isn’t she, Theo?”

“Yes,” Theo said.  He was removing his condom and he tossed it into the trash can next to the bed.  He rolled to his side to face us and propped his head up with one trembling hand.  “Fuck, that was unbelievable.”

I stared mutely at them and Seth smoothed the hair away from my sweaty face.  “You okay, Libs?”

“Yes,” I whispered.  “I’m sorry.”

“Sorry for what?”  Theo gave me a puzzled look.

“For – for ruining the fantasy,” I said.  “I tried to pretend I didn’t want it for longer but…”

I trailed off and blushed when both Seth and Theo laughed.

“Baby, it was amazing.  Besides, this was all for you so if you wanted to end the role playing five minutes in, that’s perfectly fine.”

“I really liked it,” I whispered.

“Good,” Seth said.  “We liked it too and we can always try it again and see if we can make it past five minutes.”

I didn’t reply.  What had happened was so intense, I couldn’t imagine trying it again any time soon.  I needed time to recuperate, time to reflect on what it was about me that found this type of role playing so appealing.  This was my only chance to live out that fantasy and I had kind of ruined it, but I refused to feel bad about it.  I couldn’t feel bad about it.  Even if it was short-lived, it was fucking amazing and I would masturbate to this night in my head for years to come.  I was sure of it.

“Are you ready, sweetheart?”  Seth asked.

“Ready for what?”  I gave him a look of confusion.  Oh God, they didn’t want another round already did they?  My legs were like noodles and my heart was still beating like a runaway freight train.  I needed some recovery time.

“This is going to hurt,” Theo said.

“What’s going to hurt?” I asked as he released the clamp around my right nipple and Seth released the clamp on my left.  For a moment there was nothing and I shifted on the bed.  “It doesn’t hurt.  It doesn’t even…oh fucking hell!”

The blood was returning to my swollen nipples and oh sweet Jesus, did it fucking hurt!  Tears gushed from my eyes and I tried to clap my hands over my nipples in some misguided attempt to soothe them.  Before I could touch them, both Theo and Seth took a nipple into their mouth.  They soothed and licked my nipples with their warm mouths and tongues.  It helped ease the pain and tingling and I moaned and bit my bottom lip as they lifted their heads.

“Sorry, sweetheart,” Seth said.  He wiped the moisture from my cheeks as Theo rubbed the soft skin between my breasts.

“Fuck, that hurts,” I said.

“I know and we’re sorry,” Theo said.

“Are you?” I squinted at them in suspicion and Theo laughed before rolling me to my side.  He pulled the plug from my ass and tossed it into a basket on the nightstand.

“Should I go now?” I mumbled.  I didn’t want to go.  I was tired and warm and wanted to sleep but spending the night had never been part of the deal despite sleeping over last night

Theo curled up behind me and stroked my side and hip as Seth rubbed my upper chest.  He avoided touching my nipples and I relaxed into Theo’s embrace as Seth kissed my forehead.

“No, sweetheart.  You’re spending the night with us.”

“K, cool,” I mumbled again before yawning.  “Night, guys.”

“Goodnight, love,” Theo whispered into my ear.