Chapter Two
The ceiling fan clicked to the tune of “loser, loser, loser.” It mocked me with its easy movement. Every time I twitched, pain swirled in my knee before exploding into my toes and up toward the backs of my eyes. I stared at my reflection in the black screen of my laptop as I waited for the video chat to ding a call. I used to have scrolling pictures of Trish as my screensaver. It had been black since the day of my injury.
The surgeon said to rest for a couple of days before putting pressure on it. He reconstructed my ACL two days ago, and I’d been sitting at home instead of in my dorm room ever since. Why didn’t I pick something simple, less competitive? I’d only chosen soccer because it was fast and exciting compared to the golf game I’d been subjected to the last two years.
The video chat started up, dialing like the old rotary phone my parents kept in the kitchen. Crossing my arms over my chest, I settled back into my pillows and waited to be interviewed by the tutor. When Coach Hummel told me Monroe might flunk me, I thought he was joking. I’d called the history department and Monroe told me Coach wasn’t bullshitting me. I hired the best tutor on campus the second I hung up with the prof from hell, but she required an interview. What kind of tutor interviewed students?
I rolled my thumb over the touch pad and clicked answer.
A girl with wild curls filled the screen. Actually, her hair filled most of the screen while her petite face frowned from the center. She had to be close to my age, even though the splattering of freckles made her look a few years south of legal. Not what I was expecting at all.
“I’m Mallory Fine.” Her lips molded around each word. I opened my mouth to respond, but she didn’t give me a chance. “If I agree to tutor you, I need your complete attention. I’m not going to waste my time on someone who isn’t going to take this seriously.”
She practically bit the last word. I fought the smirk, but it wasn’t going to lose. Battling with my facial muscles had always been my tell.
“And I can see that you won’t, Aaron. Good-bye,” she snapped as she leaned toward the screen.
I sat up quickly, groaning at the pain in my knee. “Wait a minute. You haven’t even given me a chance here.”
She raised her perfectly crafted eyebrows, ones that didn’t need to arch to question your very existence.
“Look, it’s too late for me to drop the class, and Monroe won’t let me turn in my work late, and my first paper was a solid D. I missed two quizzes and a second paper. The only way I can make up the grades is a twenty-page research paper in my worst subject. If I fail, they won’t let me play ball in the spring. You’re the best history tutor on campus, and I need the best to pass.” I fell back into my pillows, wishing like hell I hadn’t shredded my ACL. Since the game, I’d missed all my classes. Unfortunately, Modern American History was the one course with an unsympathetic prof. The rest cut me some slack. “I will take this serious, Mallory.”
“Dr. Monroe can be…harsh.” Her shoulders dropped, and so did her attitude. “I prefer payment weekly as a bank transfer.”
Straight to the point. I liked that in people. “No problem.”
“And my fee is not negotiable.”
“I didn’t think it was.”
“When will you be back on campus?”
“Monday. The doc said I can start using crutches then.” Even mentioning my injury made my knee throb.
“We’ll need to meet at least twice a week, but I think three times would be better knowing Dr. Monroe’s grading scale. We’ll meet in the library on the third floor.” She glanced at something on her desk. “I’ll email you a schedule for the sessions. Any questions?”
I shook my head.
“Then I’ll see you in a few days.” She paused and sucked the right corner of her lower lip into her mouth, turning Mallory into the hot librarian so many guys fantasized about. Damn. “I’m not going to lie to you, Aaron. I don’t think this is a good idea.”
That yanked me out of my soon-to-be-X-rated fantasy. “Why?”
Her eyes darted down for a split second before turning hard when she raised them again. She reached forward. “I don’t like baseball players.”
My mouth dropped open, but before I could formulate a response, she signed out. What the hell? She didn’t like baseball players? Of all the crazy-ass reasons—
My door flew open, and my little sister ran into my room.
“How’d it go?” Chelsea flopped dramatically onto my bed, jostling the mattress. It might’ve been cute when she was a little kid, but at eighteen, my sister wasn’t little anymore. A wave of pain rolled through my leg.
“Shit, Chels. Be careful.” I grabbed the sides of my leg, as if that would stop the throbbing.
She sat up, her gaze darting to my knee. “Sorry.”
“S’kay.” I lifted my ass off the mattress one cheek at a time to get some feeling back. Being bedridden was not fun. “And it went fine I guess. She agreed to tutor me.”
“Weird. You always managed a solid C average without help in high school.” Chelsea fidgeted, shuffling her feet on the navy-blue rug beneath her.
“Yeah, well, college Cs are high school As.” I waited for the static to build and for her to zap me with her finger. But thankfully that didn’t happen. She was too distracted. “What’s going on?”
Her gaze darted around my room, pausing at the corkboard with a map of the world and pictures of me with Trish. I’d avoided looking at them since I’d been home, but they needed to come down. Trish made it clear we were over, but I just wasn’t ready to let go yet. Not like she did. Four years don’t disappear overnight. I almost told Chelsea, but for whatever reason, I kept the breakup to myself. Maybe I’d hoped Trish would change her mind. Maybe I wanted everything back that she’d taken away when she dumped me. The lines blurred lately. If I was honest with myself, I didn’t miss Trish as much as I missed the clear path I’d set out on: college, marriage, MLB career, World Series ring, family, retirement, taking over Betts Family Farm and Implement. The only things that were certain now were college and Betts Family Farm and Implement.
“I sent them off.” She turned to look at me. Her nerves almost made her vibrate. “The applications. For New York. I applied to every school for early action. Hell, I even applied to a few in New Jersey.”
“Mom’s going to shit.” That was an understatement. This wasn’t going to be easy for my sister.
“Ya think?” She rubbed her hands over her thighs and stood to pace from the closet to the bed.
“And she’ll get over it. Don’t worry.” I nodded to reassure myself as well as Chelsea. “She’ll get over it. Give her time.”
Chelsea stopped and stared at me with tea-saucer-wide eyes. “I hope.”
“Remember how she freaked out when I was drafted in the thirtieth round? And when Texas A&M offered me a partial scholarship?” I shook my head. Being drafted, that was a dream come true, but I wanted to get drafted higher. A lot of players choose college over low A ball. And I was eligible again after this year; I just needed to get my ass back on the field. “She worried about me going a few hours away to Westland. She got over that.”
“True. But Madison’s in Iowa, not New York.” Chelsea pressed her fingers against her eyes, rubbing them as if she just woke up. “At least you didn’t go to San Diego or Texas.”
“Nah, too hot there.” I smiled. “You do understand why she’s freaking out, right?”
Chelsea sighed. “Yeah, I know.”
Mom had told the story of us getting mugged in New York a million times. One incident ten years ago and she was determined never to let us out of her sight. She’d taken us to New York, to Broadway, because she knew how much my sister loved the stage. That’s the story she used on me when I was drafted. But I knew better. Mom didn’t want us to grow up, move out, and leave her. “She’ll let you go, Chels. And she’ll worry every single day.” I shrugged. “So will I. It’s kinda our thing.”
She finally smiled before bouncing over to kiss my cheek. “Thanks, bro.”
“Anytime.”
Chelsea ran out of the room, slamming the door behind her. The girl was a whirlwind of energy. Mom wasn’t going to let her go without a fight. Her fears outweighed anything else. But I had Chelsea’s back. And she knew it.
I glanced over at the corkboard. Prom pictures, homecoming photos, courtwarming dances. All of the things Trish and I had done in high school. I’d left them behind when we both left Medill for Westland University. My dorm had the photos from our first two years of college. I’d boxed them up the day she told me it was over.
Four years with the girl I’d planned on marrying someday.
I closed the computer and put it on the desk by my bed. Four years I wasted. Thinking about everything we had and wouldn’t have was a rabbit hole I didn’t want or need to go down. Living in the past wasn’t going to get me through a new future. Neither was living with the what-ifs. So my plan had to change when it came to her. I just hoped the baseball career wasn’t going out the window, too.
I popped a painkiller and pushed my duffel off the bed with my good leg. It didn’t take long for the ache in my knee to fade as the meds kicked in.