The week goes by uneventfully, and as we grow into a normal routine, I start to wonder when the other shoe will drop. The look in her eyes every time they meet mine is pure sin. She wants me. She wants Caine. She just doesn’t have the courage to cross the line and make it happen.
That is until this evening at dinner. I swear she’s doing everything she can to break us. My cock is still rock hard and my hands are clammy. I feel like a teenager all over again, and because of what? Some nineteen year old girl.
I sigh as Caine retreats to his office again, leaving Maddie and I to clean up after dinner. I’m barely out of my chair before she’s taking our plates into the kitchen.
I follow her, carrying in the pans Caine cooked our food in and find her bent over putting the dirty dishes in the dishwasher. Her shorts are so short I can see the bottoms of her ass cheeks and my dick immediately tents my pants. I imagine myself going up behind her and rubbing my thick length against her ass. How soft she’d feel and the noises she’d make...it’s almost enough to have me saying fuck it and just taking what I want.
Almost.
Before I can make a decision either way, she straightens and looks back at me, over her shoulder, her eyes full of mischievous laughter. “Do you want me to take those?” She nods towards the pans I’m white-knuckling in a poor attempt to keep my hands to myself, and all I can do is nod. I hand them over to her before shoving my hands into my pockets, both to keep from grabbing her and to try to camouflage the situation happening in my boxers.
“You should go relax.” I insist. If we stay in here together much longer I’m going to end up taking something that isn’t mine to take.
Maddie grins up at me, and for a second I think she’s going to tell me she’d rather I take her here in the kitchen. I tense, waiting for it to happen, but also dreading it too.
My cock twitches in my pants at her flushed cheeks and bright eyes. I can tell she’s as attracted to me as I am to her, but touching her without Caine here seems wrong. She’s as much his as she is mine, even if she doesn’t realize it yet.
“Relax? I can’t do that. I’ve got to do my share around here, especially since you guys are being so generous and letting me live here for free.” She announces, bending back over, her shorts riding up even further. She shakes her ass a tiny bit, her hips swaying.
I think back to what Caine and I discussed about boundaries, and before I even realize I’m going to do it, I’m pushing her against the counter, my hands threading into her honeyed colored locks while I push my lower half against her perfectly heart-shaped ass.
“You tease the dog long enough, and you’ll feel his bite. Is that what you want?” I growl into her ear, my teeth teasing her lobe. She smells like sunshine and pure innocence as I grind my cock against her ass.
She’s so young, so naive… and so fucking bad. I should feel guilty for corrupting her, but I don’t.
“Is that what you want? To bite me?” I suck in a breath willing myself to let her go, to remove my fingers from her hair and let the hold I have on her chin go, but before I get the willpower to do so, she flicks her tongue against my thumb, sucking it into her mouth and sending an erotic shiver of pleasure down my spine.
My eyes hone in on her mouth as she sucks on my thumb, her tongue swirling around the tip, doe eyes looking up at me as if she’s seeking approval. As though she wants to see how weak in the knees she can make me.
She’s bad. So fucking bad. She needs punished, but not yet. Not today. I’ll give her one more chance. One more time to tempt me, to tease me before I make her mine, before I tell Caine she’s made up her mind.
“You don’t know what you’re asking for sweetheart. Caine and I are grown men. We aren’t teenage boys. We fuck, and we fuck hard so remember that next time you play with fire.” I say coldly, releasing her, and yanking my thumb out of her mouth with a loud pop.
The warmth leaves my stomach as soon as I lose the connection to her body. Blood roars in my ears and I know I need to get away from her.
She’s intoxicating. She’s under my fucking skin and inside my head.
“What if I want to play? What if I can repay you both for letting me stay here with more than just help in the office and cleaning up in the kitchen?”
I take a step back, straightening my spine, “Go to your room Maddie. You don’t know what you’re asking for. Hell, you don’t even really know me. It’s been what? A week? Yet you’re ready to fuck me. I bet you’re still a fucking virgin.” Her chin raises in defiance, her cute little nose high in the air. Even though I know I’m pushing her away, I can’t stop. “You wouldn’t know what to do with a man like me,” I sneer. I hate seeing the sadness flicker in her eyes, but beneath it is determination.
“So what? What does being a virgin have to do with it? What if I am? Men like you like virgins, don’t they?” The last few words come out as a squeak and set me on fire. I’m seconds away from showing her what men like me want when Caine’s throat clears behind me.
Maddie nibbles on her bottom lip, her thick eyelashes fanning against her cheeks before she looks up at Caine and I seductively.
“What’s going on in here?” Caine tries to hide the jealousy in his voice but it’s so fucking obvious it isn’t even funny.
“I offered to repay you both for letting me stay here. There are lots of other things I could be doing aside from cleaning and organizing your office.” I bite the inside of my cheek, and shift my eyes up to the ceiling. This woman is going to give both Caine and I a run for our money.
“And what did Knox have to say about it?” Caine furthers the conversation, while need for her sinks deeper into my balls.
I want to claim her, and watch as our come slips out of her tight channel. Would she beg for more after one night or would she be too afraid of the men she begged to take her?
“He said I don’t know what I’m asking for…” She pouts, acting as though we’re hurting her feelings, and a smug look forms on Caine’s face.
“Well you don’t, but since you’re so eager to be shown take off those shorts and bend over against the counter.” I blink my eyes going wide. I swallow past the knot in my throat. I’ve wanted this moment to happen since I first laid eyes on the beauty.
“Okay.” She says coyly, tossing her blonde hair over her shoulder before popping the button on her shorts and shimmying out of them. They hit the floor with a soft thud, and my eyes move all on their own taking in her bare ass and the flimsy piece of fabric that slips between her cheeks.
“What now?” She asks, looking over her shoulder at us for instruction.
Caine glances over at me, and I already know what he has planned. We’re going to show her just what men like us want, and the pleasure we can bring when we take it.
“Now you prepare yourself for the hardest orgasms of your fucking life sweetheart. You’ve tempted your two daddies, and it’s time to pay up.” Caine stalks forward, his fingers tracing across her ass cheeks. He pulls a hand back, and lands a hard smack against the globe of her ass, leaving a pink welt behind.
A soft cry escapes Maddie’s lips as her head falls forward, the noise bouncing off the kitchen walls. I stand there for a long moment before deciding what it is I want to do to the little brat. She did say she wants to repay us after all.
“Spread those long legs real wide for me,” I growl, moving toward her. Dropping to my knees on the ground, I turn so I’m between her thighs, with my back against the cupboards, and her innocent pussy on display for me.
“You’re wet, aren’t you?” Caine goads her while I lick my lips and eye up the dessert in front of me. “I bet you’re soaked with need for us. That perfect untouched pussy is just begging to be devoured by us… isn’t it?”
I can see Maddie’s chest rise and fall, her cheeks flushed red. She bites on her bottom lip trying to hide the moan of pleasure that escapes her.
I smirk knowing if she won’t answer, I’ll find out for myself. “Fuck me Maddie. I have to taste you.” I barely get the words out before sinking between her thighs, my hands gripping her ass cheeks as I lick up every drop of need from her asshole to her clit. She writhes against the floor, a scream of pleasure leaving her pink lips.
I can’t help but smile against her mound as she grinds against my face. “Fuck yes. Fuck my face Princess.” I growl, the words vibrating against her clit.
“Mmm, so pretty…” Caine starts again, I can hear him undoing his belt and wonder what kind of mischief he has up his sleeve. “Have you ever sucked a cock before?” He asks her. I don’t hear her response because I’m so caught up in my own feast, my own starving need for something more. I have to have this sweet beauty. I have to taste her again and again so I do. I suck on her clit, forcing her to orgasm against my tongue, her screams muffled but it only turns me on more knowing Caine’s controlling her sassy mouth while I steal the breath from her lungs.
“God you’re perfect for us. So fucking perfect.” I mumble, pulling away slightly. Sliping two fingers deep inside her, I rub against her g-spot, watching gleefully as Caine moves in and out of her mouth, his movements almost jerky.
“When I come I want you to swallow it. Swallow every drop. Do you understand me?” Caine’s voice grows deeper the closer his orgasm gets, and I curl my fingers deep inside her, her body writhing between the two of us. My cock is begging for release right now, but I don’t care. Nothing matters more than seeing Maddie get off.
“Come for me, Princess.” I order. She shudders, moaning all over Caine’s cock. His eyes roll to the back of his head as she squeezes my fingers so tight. If she squeezes my dick this tight I might fucking die. Her orgasm drenching my hand in come.
It’s only seconds before Caine’s coming too. His hand rests on the back of her head, forcing her to take every last drop of him. I’m envious as fuck of him right now, but I’m also happy that I got to taste that sweet little bud between her thighs finally.
“Fuck. Fuck. Fuck. That’s right, swallow it. Don’t waste a drop or I’m going to spank your ass till it’s bright red.” Caine orders, and Maddie follows through as he pulls out of her. I move over and watch as she swallows down every last drop, the entire event hot as hell.
So hot I know I’ll have to beat myself off later imagining it’s me shes sucking down.
She looks up at both of us, doe eyes, and full of innocence like she didn’t just let us almost fuck her. There’s a small drop of come on her lip, and Caine, sweeps his thumb over it, shoving his thick digit deep inside her mouth.
“Next time you think you can play with the big dogs, remember baby, we aren’t all bark….”
Caine starts but I finish pressing a soft kiss to her forehead. “Sometimes we bite too.” And as I walk away, up to my bedroom and away from the beauty I wish I was balls deep inside I remember how much I want this to work, and how much it probably won’t.