I sat up in my bed, a steak knife I’d stolen from my dinner concealed under the covers.

“You said I could see her. Let me the fuck in.” Garrett’s pissed off growl in the hallway had me clutching the knife harder.

“Hold on a minute, now.” Rory kept his voice even. “The Sheriff left me in charge of this whole rodeo, so you can go in when I say you can go in.”

A thump sounded against the rustic wood walls. “Fuck, Garrett. Get off!”

“Move!”

The door opened, and Garrett rushed in.

“Hey!” Rory followed close on his heels. “Ms. Vale, I can throw him out of—”

“Just you fucking try it, Deputy Douche.” Garrett whirled on him.

To Rory’s credit, he didn’t back down. But it didn’t stop Garrett from grabbing him and tossing him into the hallway. Garrett closed the door and clicked the lock. My ears began to burn, my stomach in a knot.

“Ms. Vale!” Rory banged on the solid door.

“I’m okay,” I called. “Just wait outside.”

Garrett rushed to me and sat on the bed, then pulled me into his arms. “Jesus, what’s going on?”

He pulled away and ran his palm down my swollen cheek. “How could he? I knew Danny.” His demeanor turned to stone. “I would kill him with my fucking bare hands for doing this to you.”

“Would you?” I tried to weigh his worth, to decide if he was a monster or a man.

“What do you mean?” He pulled me into his arms again.

The furnace of my heart sputtered and sparked from the nearness of him, but doubt darkened any flames.

“I mean that Danny said things.” I hadn’t released the blade.

“Like what?” He kissed my forehead, his warm lips reminding me of nights spent safe in his arms.

“About the graves.”

He leaned back and peered at me, his hands still cupping my face. “What about them? Does he know where they are?”

Why couldn’t I sense his lies? Everything from the tilt of his head to the worry in his eyes screamed that he was innocent, that he didn’t know what I was talking about.

“I’m tired.” I backed away from his touch and pressed into my pillows.

“Red, please, just tell me.” He clasped my hand between his. “Let me help you.”

“The doctor said I need to rest if I want to get my strength back. We’ll talk when I’m better. I need some time. Alone.”

The hurt that flashed across his face echoed in my heart, stabbing into the soft tissue and starting a slow bleed. But how could I trust him? The simple answer was that I couldn’t. I should have listened to my mother. Until I found the graves and dug down deep enough to hit the truth, I couldn’t trust anyone.

Not even the man sitting in front of me with love in his eyes.

“You all right?” Rory walked down the hall with me.

I glanced back to the room where I knew Garrett was holed up. The sheriff had tried to escort him off the property twice since he’d visited me. Each time was met with broken furniture and more curses than I’d ever heard in my life. He stayed in his room, and I slept uneasily the past two nights.

“I’m fine. Just hungry.” I gave Rory a wan smile.

He returned it five times brighter and put his hand at the small of my back. “Breakfast is already cooking.”

The smell of bacon and butter wafted on the air, and my stomach growled. My appetite had returned once Dr. Lewis stopped the IV. Once the pain from my injuries had receded to a dull ache, I spent my time hunkered down in my room, trying to form a game plan.

Rory and I turned the corner and passed the large glass windows giving a view of the Lodge’s gym and sauna area. A few older men walked on state-of-the-art treadmills and stopped their conversation to give us small waves.

“Mayor.” Rory kicked his chin up.

I stared harder and recognized him. Mayor Freeman walked at a steady pace, his beady eyes focused on me. He’d come to visit me once, assuring me that the school was aware of my condition and that the sheriff’s department was personally overseeing the exhumation of my father’s bones. We continued down the wide hall lined with rustic décor and modern amenities.

Rory pushed the door leading to the large dining room. Antlers and game heads covered the walls and clear windows looked out onto the barren woods. A light dusting of snow had fallen overnight, giving the ground a pathetic smattering of white. The darkness shone through, the rotted leaves and decay overpowering the perfect flakes.

I let Rory lead me to a table next to the windows, and we sat. Pam, the cook and waitress, didn’t need our orders. We’d had the same thing for the past few days.

“Are you sure you want to leave today?” Rory flipped over our coffee cups and poured from the carafe that had already been set out.

“Yes.”

“What are you going to do?”

I took my coffee and sipped it, the bitter sting reminding me I was still alive. “Finish my survey.” Find the graves on Blackwood property.

“I’ll go with you.” He leaned back as Pam put a plate of sausage, eggs, and pancakes down in front of him.

“No thanks.” I slid my napkin into my lap as Pam served me.

“Elise, you can’t go out there alone. Not again.”

I wouldn’t. I intended to go back to campus and get a handful of undergraduates, lots of university attention, and a solid grid-by-grid inspection of Blackwood. The mass grave wouldn’t stay hidden with that sort of inspection. Once I found it, I’d figure out what the hell had gone on—what had gone wrong—at Blackwood. And I’d know for certain if Garrett was responsible for the deaths.

“You still in there?” Rory’s voice snapped me back to the dining room.

“Yeah, sorry. I’m not going alone. I want to get some backup from school. Bring some undergrads to speed up the process.”

He met my eyes. “Good. I’ll be there whenever you want to go. The sheriff won’t give me any shit about spending time with you. Protection is part of the job.”

“What about the mayor?”

“He won’t say anything.” He shrugged and speared a piece of sausage. “Sheriff Crow is the boss of me.”

“You weren’t able to find out anything else about Danny?” I tasted my grits, but gave up on them when I realized nothing could compare to the ones Ty whipped up at the diner.

“No. That’s a kicker.” He shook his head, his short sandy hair barely moving. “I can’t even trace him back to a house, under a bridge, anywhere. I don’t know where he was living. That sort of ruins the whole search for clues. I think he was just crazy, you know?”

I chewed through my disagreement and remained silent.

“Just like, found your dad out there, killed him. Found you out there, tried to kill you. Crimes of opportunity. He got lucky. You got unlucky.”

“Sure.” I bit into my bacon and tried to gauge whether Rory was truly clueless. My bullshit meter didn’t blink, but I’d been wrong before. The thought of Garrett, of the things I’d done with him, burned through me until I couldn’t eat another bite.

“I’m ready.” I folded my napkin next to my plate.

“Now?” Rory spoke around a mouthful of pancake.

“Yeah.” I stood as he took a gulp of coffee.

“Sure.” He followed me to my feet. “I was thinking it would be this afternoon. I have to run to the back of the Long property first, check on a report of a deer in the road. Can you wait for me to get back?”

I didn’t want to spend another minute in my room. With my mind made up, it was time to leave. Time to get started on finding the truth no matter how much it hurt. “I’ll just go with you.”

He put a hand on my shoulder. “There might be a dead deer. Is that okay?”

I wanted to laugh. I’d seen my father’s skull a few days ago. I could handle a deer.

The SUV rocked along the gravel road, bumping over the back way out of the Lodge. A shotgun was locked upright between the front seats, and dirt was caked along the floor mats.

“You want music?” Rory reached over and flipped on the radio. A country song warbled through the speakers.

I stared out the window and fought the sadness that seeped into me. Garrett. I was leaving him behind. Was he still in his room or watching me leave? Did he know that I intended to bring him down? That whatever sins he’d committed two years ago wouldn’t stay buried as long as I drew breath?

“I used to hunt out here before they built the Lodge. Seems like now, though, they scared the game away. Too many people, you know?” Rory cleared his throat. “Hey, I’ve been meaning to ask you something.”

“Mmhmm?” I pulled my coat closer around me as I waited for the heater to warm the small space.

“I know this isn’t the most, um, opportune time to ask. But since you’re going to be in town for a little while, would you like to—”

“Shh.” I peered out the window. “Stop the car!” Something in the woods caught my eye. A flash of orange.

The SUV halted, its tires skidding a little over the gravel.

“What is it?” Rory leaned over and stared in the same direction.

“I saw something.” I couldn’t find the mark anymore, but I knew it had been there, the same one from Lillian’s photos.

“What?”

“Come on.” I yanked on the door handle and stepped out into the frozen air.

I walked through the gravel and up onto the short bank next to the road before plunging into the woods.

“Wait just a gosh darn second!” Rory caught up and took my elbow, but he didn’t stop me from walking. “What did you see?”

“Orange.”

“Elise, maybe we should go on back to the Lodge. I don’t think you’ve recovered enough.”

I stopped and turned to him. “I’m not crazy. There’s a mark. I think it’s on one of these trees. I have to find it. If you don’t want to help me, go back to the truck, but I will find it.” I ripped my elbow from his grasp and clambered over a fallen tree, my boot slipping in the snow along the top.

“Jeez, woman. No need to get mad.” He followed and took my elbow again, helping me along.

“Keep looking.”

He scanned the trees as we maneuvered around a fallen branch. “What kind of mark?”

“It’s like a circle with a squiggle through the middle.”

“Like the Ghostbusters thing?” He tipped his hat back on his head.

“Yeah, kind of like that.”

“That’s familiar. I’ve seen that in these woods.”

“In Blackwood?” I stuffed my hands in my pockets to avoid the chill.

“No. Never out on that side of the county. Only over here.”

“Here? What, like at the Lodge?”

“Yeah.” He helped me over a small stream. “I reckon that’s right. It’s just a hunter’s mark, to remind them where the game trails are.” He pulled me to a stop. “It’s nothing, just a hunter’s mark, okay?” He put a hand to my cheek. “You’re already frozen. Let’s go back.”

“No.”

“Why?” Exasperation colored the word, but once again, he helped me walk farther into the woods.

“Because I saw photos of that mark. I saw a grave near one of those marks. A mass grave.”

“A mass grave? In Millwood County?”

“Yes,” I hissed. “There’s something out here. I thought it was at Blackwood.” A burst of orange caught my attention. “There!” I pointed.

He peered through the woods. “Yeah, there it is.”

We trudged over to the marked tree, and Rory ran his hand over it. “Just a hunter’s mark, like I said.”

“No. There’s more.” I took a few more steps, my eyes trained on the ground. “A clearing. Right up ahead.” And something else, highlighted by the dusting of white. “Come on.” I hurried forward, almost jogging through the trees until I found it.

“Whoa, what is that?” Rory caught up and stopped next to me.

I looked from the ground to him. “It’s—”

A shot went off, and one of Rory’s eyes exploded as the bullet cut through his skull.