Ben flipped me over and told me to get on my knees. I did so willingly when I realized he was planning to fuck me doggy style. The mere thought of how I’d look this way turned me on and as soon as I was in position I puckered my lips, lowered my head as low as I could to the seat, and raised my ass high up in the air for him.
“Gimme that,” Ben told me as he gave my ass a hard slap. The sound rang through the van and it made James laugh.
“She’s got a nice big ass,” James commented.
“She does,” Ben confirmed as he got into position behind me.
“Now it’s time to put it to good use.”
I was too exhausted to even question what that meant. All I could concentrate on was the sudden sensation of something entering my body. However at this position I felt his cock more thoroughly than I did previously. This time I felt its width and length more intensely as the muscle of his manhood rubbed tightly against my walls as it tried to burrow its way deep inside me.
“Aah f-fuck me,” I cried out in pleasure as I buried my face in the van’s seat. I heard a smack and I realized it was Ben’s body smacking against my ass cheeks as he pounded his way through. He then pulled out and then abruptly pushed back in and I heard another smack and then another. Pretty soon my whole body began to rock as his thrusts became faster. I could feel the friction of his cock rubbing against my pussy’s insides and I felt his body begin to tense and tremble.
Suddenly both his hands were on my ass as he started to jerk his cock in and out of my pussy. I felt like a rag doll under his control and the sheer violence of his thrusts made me drool wildly. Pleasure and pain blended together and before long I could no longer tell if I was dreaming or if I was awake. All I could see was a blinding light of white and my body seemed so numb save for the regular, rhythmic thrusts between my legs that induced me with an intoxicating dose of ecstasy.
“Fuck! I’m cumming Sabrina, I’m going to cum inside you!”
I heard Ben’s words and for a moment I wondered if I should have asked him to pull out. There was always the risk of getting pregnant. Yet somehow I didn’t utter a single word. I just took him in like it didn’t matter. Suddenly he stopped pumping his cock and just thrust it in as deep as he could when it suddenly exploded with his seed. I felt his cock begin to throb as it shot out his cum. Deep inside my body it felt hot and I felt like I was being filled to the brim, as if my innards were being bloated with fluids. It took a while and soon enough his cock started to relax.
When Ben pulled out some cum dripped out of my soaked pussy. At this point I couldn’t even tell if it was his or mine.
Finally, Ben reached for a towel inside my backpack and rubbed himself clean. Once done he got himself dressed and then sat beside me to admire my naked body.
My mouth was open as I drooled and my eyes were blankly staring into nothingness. I was still in the doggy position, I was still covered in sweat, and my pussy and legs were still covered in cum. But I was too exhausted to even move or care.
“That was amazing,” he whispered to my ear as his fingers gently tapped over my back and then over my ass cheeks.
I managed to smile but I couldn’t mutter a single word. Exhaustion had finally taken its toll over me. If I shut my eyes I would have fallen asleep but then Ben’s next suggestion woke me up in a flash.
“Hey James, don’t you want to give her a try?”
Wait, what?
My eyes shot wide open as the suggestion ran through my brain over and over again. Ben was actually offering me to James, the same guy who heard and saw everything that happened while he was driving to get us all the way to Seattle. How was this a sane idea?
“Fuck yeah, man, I can’t let you have all the fun.”
That response jolted me back up. I grabbed the towel and wiped my face before using it clean up my legs and pussy. As I did I shot a confused look at Ben, “You just offered to let him fuck me!”
“Would you say no?” Ben asked me as if there was any other reasonable answer.
I looked at him intently and was about to say that I would have rejected the notion before it was even voiced out but then something within me held my tongue back. I stared at him and when I couldn’t give an answer he smirked and gave me a kiss on the forehead.
Why did I not just say I wasn’t going to let James fuck me? I know it’s insane, especially because I literally just lost my virginity about thirty minutes ago, but then again I had to think about how all of this was playing out. I just met these two and yet here I was already having sex with one and letting the other guy watch as if it was nothing. I even let them do it to me for free!
I’ve gone this far though, so what was the point in saying ‘no’ now?
“Let’s do it,” I said.
Ben looked at me with pride and James swerved the van to get off the highway.